Peppe's Pizza & Grill

Pros - Nice staff and good prices. You can eat outside. Cons - I was with a group of people, and the only one who seemed to enjoy their meal ordered the eggplant parm sandwich.

6/22/24 my first time at Peppe's in Gilbertsville. My son and his wife bought a new home in the area and we ordered take out from Peppe's. I hear it's always busy so they must be doing something right! The restaurant is along swamp pike and used to be the Allstar Cafe.We ordered a Cobb salad with grilled chicken, a white pizza with spinach and ricotta, order of fries and a chicken cheesesteak calzone with fried onions. Altogether the cost was 78$. A bit on the high side but I know food costs have skyrocketed as well as inflation.The food was delicious and high quality. They must have put the equivalent of half a pig in my salad- so much bacon- . There was very little avocado and my main complaint was since they bagged my salad with hot fries- my salad was warm. Yuck! Hot food HOT- cold food COLD. All in all on site if that I thought everything was delicious and I would definitely go back.

UNBELIEVABLE!!!What else is there to say about Peppe's Almost don't want to write a review that may result in more popularity, to be selfish and keep this amazing restaurant to ourselves.Everything we have had at Peppe's is on another level, from apps to sandwiches to pasta and pizza.But the Grandma Pizza----- I can't describe.Literally. It's the most incredible pizza ever had.Please ask my fiancé, the pizza connoisseur, who could eat a slice a day- the Grandma he says is one of THE BEST! The crust is thin, crispy but enough dough to take the toppings. And the sauce- slightly sweet, no tomato burn. Delicious!We've ordered the fried pickles twice- light breading, not oily, superb.And an absolute standout-The seafood fra diavolo!!! Die Every piece of seafood was cooked perfectly.The mussels- THE MUSSELS!Never a better cook to mussels I've had before, basically didn't even have to chew them.Take-out and dine in has always been exceptional!Ok, parking sucks, but worth the challenge.Peppe's is a shining star in Italian food!Undoubtedly, one of our favorite local restaurants.

Takeout experience only. This place is quite popular right out of the gate. Fairly large parking lot to handle the masses. Everyone working smiling and happy to be at work. The Grandma pie was ready right on time and a sharp looking pizza. Cooked perfectly with massive slices. I ended up double cutting to make eating that much easier.Great balance of fresh ingredients and not oily at all. $21 and change. Well worth it.Pickup area thru the bar area and clearly marked. I can't wait to dine in and check out their craft beer and whiskey selection. Recommend!

Good Italian food, it used to be my favorite place in the area but the kitchen has gotten so busy that a lot of times the pizza or Stromboli is under cooked. It's a shame because they were one of my favorite places to go.

Worst shrimp scampi I ever had. Smelly, watery and no flavor. Skip this place. Packaging was poor liquid spilled in my car smelled.

We had the pesto with gnocchi. It was so good that we order it for take out regularly & split it at home. Garlic knots - very good!Chicken parm - really good.Enclosed deck is really nice! Looking forward to the additional bar on the deck too.

Pizza is outstanding and the Caesar salad was fresh and very tasty the service was impeccable the owner peppe and Kate were hands on walking around making sure we were happy with food and the ambiance was very pleasant and great atmosphere , strongly recommend the establishment very clean and great martini

This place is great ! Fresh delicious food and good desserts. The pasta dishes are a nice size.

Delicious and a lot of gluten free options. Safe for someone with Celiac. Our waitress Tina was awesome.