Sugar Shane's

Absolutely MASSIVE cookies. I was recommended this spot and decided to venture out on my way home one day. The location is really odd, as it's behind the line of restaurants and into a literal garage. However, once you find it it's very much worth it.I got the red velvet/vanilla swirl and the biscoff cookies, as it was my first time here. They were both served fresh and warm and gooey - basically to the point of falling apart. If you like cookies that are almost slightly raw and doughy, this is definitely the spot for you. The thickness of the cookies is great, and they are PACKED with chocolate chips / toffee bits / whatever is in the cookie you choose. They are certainly very sweet, but satisfy that cookie craving so well.This might be my favorite, or one of my favorite of the (literally) big cookie chains out there - think Crumbl, Levain, Chip, etc - be sure to check it out!

These were the besttttt cookies!!!! The lemon cookie was my favorite! The classic chocolate chip was also really good with crispy edges 10/10 Cookies and creme was also a must!

The location is a bit weird- it's in a garage behind subway. The workers were super nice and heated up my cookie for me. I wish I had asked them to heat it a little longer because the outside was warm but the inside was cold. The cookie was yummy and it was huge!

One of my favorite cookie spots in Atlanta, so good and great value for what you get. Mike is also a major Vibe, always so hospitality, makes me feel like a valued customer. I highly recommend, the banana pudding or the Betty white!

Great service! Not much of a sweet person but they were really good. I had the cookies and cream and the chocolate chip. They do have a good amount of specialty cookies that are worth trying. Would definitely be back!

Sugar Shane's is the best! I LOVE their goodies and how they frequently rotate flavors, providing a unique experience each time. I have a huge sweet tooth and this is the spot to treat myself to massive desserts. This location is a bit hard to find - there's no signage on the road, so you'll have to trust the GPS when it says to turn into a seemingly random driveway. There, you'll spot a small sign that'll direct you to continue down the driveway and around the corner. There's really not much parking, but people usually don't stay long so I've never had an issue with not being able to park my car.Sign up for their rewards program! They offer a $5 coupon on your birthday :)

Sugar Shane's Cookies ! These cookies were so heavy. Each cookies is $6 and I feel it's great for the price. The Banana pudding cookie didn't taste like banana pudding to me. It tasted more like a macadamia with small hints of banana. The fruity pebbles one was very sweet but the cereal on its own was sweet so I expected that. Taste was just overly sweet. M&M one was so nice it was my favorite one maybe bc I love m&ms and it had pieces in that cookie I went to the Ponce location and once again the worker seems like she had an attitude and didn't want to work. She didn't make my shopping experience amazing Ambiance umm it was a cookie location in a food hall so nothing stood out

Ordered through Uber Eats and it did not disappointment! We got the 4 cookie order and received the Strawberry Shortcake, S'mores, and Betty White. The cookies came warm and were extremely delicious. My friends and I didn't finish in one sitting, so we saved the rest for later. They came with reheating instructions that worked well too. I would definitely order from here again.

I'll preface this by saying I'm not the biggest sweet tooth. Especially when it comes to cookies - I'm more of a cupcake gal. I came here with the $10 for 2 deal offered by Yelp. It's in a reasonably convenient location but the parking situation is a little stressful due to the hill and limited space to back up.The staff was super friendly, helpful, and hardworking. I came in wanting the fruity pebbles cookie but they didn't have it this week so I got the snickerdoodle and red velvet cookies. I tried bits of both and have to admit I liked neither. The cookie was way too thick and it was hard to enjoy a full bite with the additional toppings baked into the cookie. On top of that, it tasted way too sugary!If the fruity pebble cookie returns, I may go back to try just that one but I don't want to be disappointed.

Came across the Sugar Shane stall at Ponce Market. I got the Cookie Monster and S'more's. Wow! These cookies were so yummy and gigantic! It took me two days to finish half of each one! They are pretty sweet so if that's not your jam, then you should pass. The size is also perfect to share, which is what it did with my boyfriend!