PJ's Pizza Co.

We love this cozy little family-run pizza shop with high-quality ingredients and friendly service! I'm a born-and-raised New Yorker and am admittedly snobby about my pizzas. This place passed my bar by far! Their fresh ingredients don't leave me feeling oily and bloated like other pizzas do. That doesn't mean they skimp on taste; our kids scarf down slice after slide every time we come here.If you have the chance, have a chat with Philip and Jennifer (P and J, get it? :D ). It's easy to tell how much love, care, and attention they put into their pizza when they describe how they source their ingredients.They are also very engaged with the community. Local schools and organizations always speak highly of PJ's because of their generosity and service to others. PJ's Pizza is a true neighborhood gem!

We ordered a family pizza (half combo & half pepperoni), came out fast and the quality of the food is sooo good! The service was amazing and so friendly, we're not from the bay but will definitely remember to come here when in town for pizza. They had some probiotic drinks that are very light to go along with the pizza, loved everything here. Thank you for the service & great food

Our family loves having pizza here at this family business. So, when we got together with extended family, we took a kit of dough, sauce, and cheese all made by PJ's! (Super easy to just call the day before) We had a lot of fun making our own pizzas. The quality of ingredients helped with our lack of experience :)

They used to be called Velo City Pizza, but we came in and they told us they're changing their name into PJ's so here we are! The owners are really kind and hospitable. They love their business and they surely love the customers. They explained to us their best sellers and how they made their own ricotta recipe for the lamb pizza. It's a small restaurant nearby our house, so they don't have a lot of seats available but it's cozy and comfortable place to visit. They sell a bunch of gelato on sticks and I would say that tastes a little old.. but their pizza are very tasty and we'll be back again for them!

Best pizza ever, also the allowed my pug dog into the establishment. Like who can beat that

Amazing thin crust gourmet pizza. Beer and wine. 3 delicious meat toppings homemade and also gluten free crust and vegan cheese are options.

Had calzone pizza dough was light had taste good ricotta cheese mozzarella was good ... nice place small pizza place not too many tables has barstool counter top...

I ordered a large pizza around lunchtime. The owner said the pizza would be ready in 20 mins. When I arrived there were no customers in the store. Unfortunately he had totally forgot to pass the order to the employees to make the pizza. I had to wait another 15 minutes for the pizza to be made as staff made it painfully slow. The shop itself has a nice ambiance with seating upstairs also. The pizza was very average and had very little red sauce. I usually will eat a good amount when eating pizza. However, I only ate two smaller slices and the taste didn't really satisfy my pizza craving. I would say taste was a solid 2.75. The large pizza was $38 before tax (pretty pricey) and the touch screen was extremely sensitive and I accidentally selected the incorrect tip amount.

Update 2/20: The business did respond to my review on 1/17. I'll leave my original response for reference.The business replied to my original review weeks later, claiming to have reached out to me. They never attempted to contact me. Please, don't lie to down play that earned 1 star review.

Love the family dynamic and what PJ's does for the community. The pizza itself and the sides were not for us. To us - the pizza has a subtle taste; almost bland.We were newbies to PJ's and wanted to try a new pizza and a side dish. We ordered a large half + half pizza and a side wings. The pie had very little cheese presence and the sauce did not give "pizza sauce". It was less herbs and more of a basic tomato sauce... not a pizza sauce.The wings/drummies were lukewarm (almost cold), as well as very dry. The wings came with a side of sauce but, did not assist in making them taste ANY better. We chose 'buffalo sauce' but it tasted more like a mild generic 'hot sauce'. So we ate the wings plain. Not a fan of the pizza and we will not be returning but, I like that it's a family affair and uplifts our community. Not for us.