Gotham's Deli
Gotham's Deli
Red velvet cake
Red velvet
outside
a sidewalk with tables and chairs
a man sitting in a stroller outside a deli
the entrance to gotham's deli
outside
a wall full of baseball memorabilia
the inside of a restaurant
a wheel of baseball memorabilia
outside
a kitchen with a lot of items
interior
interior
interior
interior
interior
interior
outside
interior
outside
Dark Knight
Menu
Dr. K
Ben M.
Aug 13, 2023
The Premier Sandwich shop in the whole county. I defy and man (or woman) to show me a better one! I'll wait. Outrageously good northern-esque big sandwiches, without the overbearing northern charm. (Sorry carpetbaggers, but I know you know...)Fast service, comfortable sporty surroundings, old style diner ambience. This is the midday eating gem of Smithfield and likely for a 50 mile radius.Gothams could increase their revenue by giving classes to all other small businesses. They do it right.I'm making myself hungry now, I need another trip!
Read More
Michael W.
Oct 13, 2024
October 2024. Recommended by a local. I'm not a New Yorker but I do enjoy me a good sandwich. Decorations were great. Lots of NY jerseys, flags, banners, etc. Ordered the chicken cheesesteak, chips, and a drink. Got a small or "regular" sub instead of the large. Sandwich was good and as ordered but wasn't what I had hoped. Local recommended it as a great sub shop and I got a rather "normal" sandwich. Sub was average both in size and taste, and meat insides was just okay. Don't get the chance to visit this area very often, if ever, so sadly it's hard to say I'll be back. If I'm ever in the area again though, I'll probably give it another go just to try and see if I get different or the same results.
Read More
Jason M.
Feb 3, 2024
Check This Place Out!!!!!! *sounds the trumpet* NY overload!! Haha, Love it!! This sandwich shop will bring a smile to your face. I don't know where they get, or if they make, the Rye bread but MANNNNN was it good; not dense and/or dry. The sandwiches are on point!! Great ratios of meat, cheese, toppings, and condiments. The selections of sandwiches are big as well, from Ham, Turkey, Veggie, Chicken, Roast Beef, Signature, Italian, Hot Dogs, annnnnnd Box lunches!!!!! Oh, they have a jar of huge pickles, too!!!! Today, we ordered the Dark Knight and Dr. K, which you can get with Chips and a drink. Both sandwiches were gone in a matter of minutes.Gotham Deli sits downtown Smithfield, with available street parking. Inside is long and narrowish with booth seating. They have a fountain drink station with the best Dr. Pepper to carbonation ratio, at least they did today!!! Oh my goodness, those 23 flavors were rich.
Read More
Rebecca M.
Aug 8, 2023
Gotham's Deli is a New York deli located in North Carolina. The deli seemed to have many regulars as they were recognized and the usual orders remembered. The walls are decorated in New York memorabilia; New York sports memorabilia; as well as down Smithfield memorabilia. I enjoyed looking at the Mets items.The deli has New York inspired themed menu items and there are a lot of options to choose from. I went with a half of Mr. Met which was roast beef, turkey, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato and mayo. You can dine inside, outside or order to go.
Read More
Alex K.
Mar 13, 2024
Fast, reasonably priced food with a NY twist! Service is attentive and they are amenable to changes with your order - especially with gluten sensitivities. Lots of sandwiches, salads, desserts to choose from! Portions are large and they *WILL* make you sleepy afterwards!
Read More
Tricia T.
Jan 26, 2024
Amazing deli located literally downtown Smithfield. You walk in and it's very much a New York delicatessen vibe. I placed an order over the phone and let them know when I arrived, and it was just about 10-15 minutes until I received my food. My party ordered a tuna melt, brass knuckles, Mr met, and the Hudson. The total was just shy of $57 for the 4 full whole sandwiches. I ended up receiving a tuna sub instead of the melt, but it was still delicious. Everything was flavorful, filling, and huge! I would love to come back again soon!
Read More
Helaina H.
May 2, 2023
Gotham's, formerly Gandolfo's, is just plain AWESOME. I've been eating here since 2005, and have never had an experience that was less than luscious. I use them often for catering my parties, including my wedding in 2006. The store's New York-themed decor is fun and their large menu offers a variety of hot and cold sandwiches to please the pickiest palate. My favorite is the Soho Chicken Salad and my husband's is the Reuben, although we've sampled at least a third of the menu through the years. Their cheesecake is sinfully good, and they make potato salad that's superior to Grandma's finest. You can get either a half or whole sandwich, and I recommend their budget-friendly combo, which includes a drink and a bag of chips.Gotham's caters at very reasonable prices. You can get box lunches for your business meeting and wonderful party trays of small subs, fruit and veggies. I ordered several fruit and veggie trays for my wedding and my guests were delighted at their great variety and fresh, cold, crispy treats. The sub sandwich trays are a seasonal fave at my annual Christmas Tree Trimming Party. The staff is friendly and greets everybody with a big smile no matter how busy the store is. Food Service can be high-stress and just plain crappy to work at, but I really appreciate staff who don't take it out on their customers. If you want a fast, quick meal that doesn't taste like fast food from a quick-serve deli, head for Gotham's. I have only one complaint: I wish they were open 7 days a week!
Read More
Dani H.
Nov 14, 2023
Great sandwich for an even greater price point. Cute little spot with a huge menu. Love the revolving desserts and pasta salads they have as well. Staff is always very helpful.
Read More
Chris G.
Feb 23, 2023
This is my favorite deli! I've been eating at this restaurant for over 15 years and haven't had anything bad. I usually get the Bauer Ave sub but I've tried just about everything on the menu. I highly recommend this place. Great food and atmosphere. Even being a Red Sox fan, it's still a great place.
Read More
Linda B.
Mar 26, 2024
My husband, daughter and I have eaten here a few times and every time we go the food is very well prepared and tasty. We got our orders pretty quickly and enjoyed looking around at all of the souvenirs in the place.
Read More
