Forever Yogurt

Felt like a kid in a candy store when I first walked in. This style of fro-yo by weight isn't too common anymore but this was definitely the most elaborate one I've been to. They had everything from cereal to candy to sauces and even had boba. There was a good amount of fro-yo flavors but German chocolate cake was my favorite of the few I sampled. Even though it was the best, the quality wasn't very good especially in consistency. Regardless of how tasty the fro-yo was, I came for the toppings. I went crazy with a mix of pb/ chocolate cups, cookie dough, brownies, brownie batter, hot fudge, marshmallow sauce, and Reese's sauce. Probably too much going on but I just wanted to try everything. It is impossible to take all those sweets and make something bad. The only toppings I don't recommend are the peanut butter and jelly cups and the cheesecake bites. Overall, this place is definitely worth trying just to make your own concoction but don't expect to be wowed by the fro-yo.

Took our toddler granddaughter here for froyo. It is a bit expensive for what it is but it's essentially the only ice creamish option in the near neighborhood. They have a large variety of flavors and toppings. I got peanut butter and pistachio froyo which were good. Hubby got birthday cake froyo with m and m's and chocolate pieces. Baby liked it all except she spit out the toppings since they were hard and a bit frozen. There are plenty of seats inside but unfortunately no booster seats or high chairs- would think they would want those since it is a good place to take kids. Anyway it served its purpose for us. Vacillating between 3 and 4 but I'll give them the 4 cause we need them to stay in business!

I'm trying to avoid a ton of sautrauted fat now, so was in the mood for a frozen yogurt place. I thought they were all gone now for Boba tea shops. So imagine my surprise to find one again! And we weren't disappointed. It was just like I remember Forever Yogurt being. Sure, there are a bunch of flavors of yogurt but there are toppings all over the store. It's actually kind of funny. Everywhere you look there's some other kind of topping. You look over there, and there's the second of cereals to put on your yogurt. Oh look over there its a salad bar of boba to put on. Wait, look over there, its vats and vats of warm sauces. Done yet? Nope, it just goes on and on. If you're a newbie your order is probably going to come out to be a million dollars because you'll dump all these delicious options into your cup. You'll get sick halfway through eating it and you'll cry that you spent 25 on a bowl of sugar pieces. Just now that, and hold yourself back a little. I recommend filling up the cup like a quarter with yogurt, and just pick a few toppings. You'll be surprise still how much that adds up. But you'll thank me for advising you on constraint. I do knock off a star because I added the yogurt pretzels and they were stale. I'm betting there are some other toppings there on the stale side since they probably don't get a lot of turnover. So plan accordingly. Maybe make a plan even before you go in :) That's what I think I'll do next. I'll ask chatgpt what they think is the lightest toppings there and use those since it's all done by weight. And I'll make sure to try and figure out out which toppings are getting the most turnover. Is there cereal? Probably not? Let me know what you find.

Immediately transport yourself back to the summer of 2012 when you step inside this joint. Self-serve frozen yogurt with toppings filled to the brim of each container. Fruits for the people who want to seem healthy. Candy for the chocolate lovers. Cereal for the kids who want to make the nastiest concoction possible. Everyone is happy. The Olympics are going strong and life is good. Forever Yogurt, you have my heart.

I have struggled to find self-service froyo ever since the Orange Leaf chain shut down, but this is a classic froyo spot that ended my hunt! They have a variety of classic frozen yogurt flavors and sooo many toppings to choose from. This was the first place I have visited that had dividers for your yogurt cup, which is great for someone who is indecisive and doesn't like their food touching like me. Everything was clean and organized, the yogurt was great, and they have a nice patio to eat on. I'm giving it 4 stars instead of 5 because they don't provide any sort of free tap water for paying customers when their prices are a little high for yogurt. We didn't even remotely fill 2 cups and hardly had toppings, but our order totaled to almost $20. I feel like water could be free given the high prices for a simple dessert. Also, they prompted us to provide a tip even though it's a self-service froyo spot. I don't understand what service they provided us that would deserve a tip on top of $20 yogurt, given that the only words exchanged were "you can tap your card."

What a great surprise! Came into town and saw this froyo spot and exuded to stop in. It was nice and clean and the person working there kept cleaning up after every customer that left. There were a ton of flavors and more toppings than most places have. I had a mix of cookies and cream and peanut butter with cinnamon toast brunch abs Reese's topping (delish!). Anyway, it was a hit with my whole fam. Definitely recommend for a summer day stop.

SOO MANY TOPPING OPTIONS! I have never seen so many toppings I was overwhelmed and so excited. They have like 6 different types of batters to put on the yogurt. This place also has a super fun vibe and touch tunes! Will be back!

We need to bring froyo back!! I was craving it the other day and decided to stop by after a run. They had so many toppings options and all the flavors I tried were really good. As always, it ended up being very pricey in comparison to what you actually get.

Forever Yogurt is BACK. TBH I thought this was the one on Belmont so I drove there, then realized that one did, in fact, close, but they now have this location in Boystown!It's pretty spacious inside - with tooooons of flavors of froyo and sorbet, and TOOOOONS of toppings! Holy cow I couldn't believe the toppings. They lost 1 star because 95% of their fruit looked pretty bad, but everything else was pretty dang awesome! My friend was mind-blown that they had so many options overall here! On top of that the design of the place is as cute as ever, bright, fun, and most importantly clean.There's a bit of seating inside, too, if you want to sit to enjoy your treat! :)

I was just there with my three little daughters. We had a $10 gift card but when we tried to pay the lady in charge called "Jackie" said their system wasn't working. In fact, when we walked in, before serving our yogurt I asked the dude at the register if they accepted that card and he said yes. The dialogue went exactly like this:-Me: "can you honor the $10? It's not the customer's fault that your system is not working"-Jackie: "do you have another form of payment?"-Me: "can you answer my question first?" -Jackie: "there is nothing I can do"-Me: "I even asked you before serving our ice creams if you accept these and you said yes!!" I saw my daughters faces but made the hard decision to tell her we were leaving. She proceeded to grab our cups from the scale to throw them away later (or to eat them later I don't care). There was a disgusting dude eating jimmy johns (??) at the only table for four so I thought we'd be better off at Jenny's or at home. What a great athletic experience and nonsense attitude. We were frequent customers but will NEVER be going back unless I get a huge apology from this Jackie person to my daughters for the frustrating experience. If so, I will consider removing the reviews I will be posting repeatedly on every platform.