Vinny's NY Pizza

First off pizza is gods gift to earth haha. I will always go for a slice of pizza! Today I decided to go to a small spot over in Ansley mall shopping center for a zoom meeting and we to Vinny's Pizza This is literally an in and out type of ordeal just like most pizza joints but they don't have some tables/booths if you want to sit and eat in (not many) so I decided to sit and eat while I waited for my zoom meeting to start. Pizza is known for being super cheesing and oily and that's what gives it the wow factor and Vinny's didn't disappoint! They advertise being a New York style pizza restaurant and yes the pizza is huge!! They make it to order so it's fresh as it can be and it was GREAT!! The only critique that I would have for this place is just a little better customer service. The girl at the cash register was very uninterested in taking the order. I actually waited about two minutes before she got up from the booth from where she was eating to come take my order , however, the guys in the back making the pizza talk to you're at the register and they were super nice so it wasn't as bad!I would definitely come back to get some pizza to go maybe not sit in again as far as pizza goes 9/10

One of my go to pizza spots. Growing up in NY I'm a picky pizza eater. I've been coming here for years and the pizza is consistently yummy. The core staff is kind and has remained the same over the years. The location is in Ansley mall. They have a great lunch special - 2 slices and a soda for a pretty decent cost. I usually grab a slice or two of pizza or the personal pie with fresh mozzarella. Once they gave me some garlic knots and I was in heaven. I see many people order their pasta, I have never tried it probably bc I cook my own, but it looks good! Inside you order at the register and take a number with you to a seat. They bring the food out and also clean off the tables once you leave. It's relaxed inside with TVs in case you are trying to catch a game or need something to watch while you snack. They also have a few tables outside for nice days. Highly recommend!

For the record, I have wanted to go to Vinny's Foreverrrrrrrrrrrr and just have never had the chance to stop in. Welp! That chance finally came and I am elated at the results. LoL!After leaving a small gathering I had the urge for a slice of pizza. As I was in the Ansley area Vinny's was at the top of my list... Though it sits in the strip mall Vinny's has the feel of a stand-alone restaurant when you walk inside. As it was later in the evening there were only a few people in line. The menu has an assortment of options, however, I only had cheese pizza on my mind. LoL! I tried to place the order on the self-serve screen but it wasn't working for me. The young lady behind the register was super nice. She took my order with a smile and provided a pleasant interaction. When my pizza was ready and he called my name you should have seen the smile on my face. LoL. I was super excited. Upon taking a bite of my pizza I think my entire body melted. Oh my goshhhhhhhhh. The fresh flavors of the well seasoned sauce and perfectly blended cheese.. whew. This pizza was exactly what I needed at the moment and any other moment. LoL!!Being from up North I am very hard on what is defined as a "GOOD" slice of pizza and Vinny's truly is a GOOD SLICE of Pizza. If you're in the mood for some good pizza, stop by and get your fix. You won't be sorry.

Outstanding, all the way around. Outstanding staff, outstanding salad, outstanding pizza, outstanding experience.

We decided to try this NY style pizza joint and will say it was ok. The 10" was $14. We had the margarita which was tasty but the crust was a bit too crunchy for my taste. I was hoping for a nice soft crust so I could fold it in half and eat it. The staff were friendly and the atmosphere nice and clean. Some may love their pizza but for me it was just ok.

First time in - got a slice for lunch. Good & one of the cheapest lunches I've found in ATL. As of 10/2023, a cheese slice is just $3.75. Add a topping for 75-cents & drink + tax & you're still out under $10.

Grabbed a slice of pepperoni to go. I planned on eating it at traffic stops. The tip was way too soft, super hot and flimsy. It was delicious!

Last weekend, my family and I decided to embark on a culinary journey to Vinny's NY Pizza, a place where the cheese stretches longer than a Monday and the dough is tossed higher than my ambitions.We ordered two large pizzas - one pepperoni, one mushroom - a veggie calzone, and a Caesar salad. The Caesar salad was a masterpiece, a verdant field of greens in perfect harmony with the dressing, croutons, and Parmesan. It was like Julius Caesar himself gave it a thumbs up from his salad days in the Roman Senate.Then came the veggie calzone. Oh, the calzone. It was like expecting a Shakespearean sonnet and getting a limerick instead. The veggies seemed to have come straight out of a time capsule from the Paleolithic era, and the flavor was as absent as my will to do laundry on a Sunday.Now, let's talk about the pizzas. The pepperoni pizza was like a Where's Waldo of meat - a sparse scattering on a vast landscape of dough. The mushroom pizza, on the other hand, was a fungal fiesta, but the cheese... ah, the cheese. It was tougher than a math problem on a Monday morning. Chewing it was a workout, and let's just say it gave our digestive systems a run for their money - quite literally.The pièce de résistance of this gastronomic adventure was its impact on my family. The cheese had a party in our stomachs and everyone was invited - including my soon-to-be 2-year-old, who is in the throes of potty training. Let's just say, Vinny's gave us a crash course in teamwork and bathroom sprints.In conclusion, Vinny's NY Pizza is the culinary equivalent of a roller coaster ride - thrilling, a bit risky, and you're not sure if you want to do it again. It's a place where the salad shines and the cheese... well, it binds. Would I visit again? Probably not. But will I forget this experience? Definitely not.Vinny's, you're unforgettable in ways more than one.

Don't fall for the "elite" 5 star reviews - these people clearly don't know good pizza. This was my go to for so long, the only place in all of ATL to get near authentic NYC style pizza. Sadly, while the crust and cheese are still what you'd be looking for in a pie, they've changed the sauce. It's got no herbs and it's so sweet that it ruins the entire thing. I have a feeling there was a change in ownership responsible for the difference, but I can't say for sure. May as well go anywhere else for a mediocre pie.

Really Solid pizza. Slices. Pies. All the good. Go to there without hesitation. We'll try the rest of the menu soon.