Breadsticks with Cheese
Cheese pizza & garlic knots
pizza, food
a slice of pizza on a blue plate
the interior of a restaurant
Delicious pizza! Tangy, cheesy, chewy and crispy... Yeah doggy!
a pizza in a box
a jar of nuts and a salt shaker
Awards and decor at NY Pizza
the interior of a restaurant
Pepperoni
interior
Strips and pieces for the little ones
Medium cheese
Where the magic happens...
Lots of tables
Stuffed veggie pizza - small - inside.
"Pastarotti" - pasta with cheese and meat sauce covered in crust
"Pastarotti" - pasta with cheese and meat sauce covered in crust. Look at that cheese!
Stuffed veggie pizza - small
outside
White slice
Eggplant parm pizza - small
Best Garlic Knots in Raleigh !!!
Clifford M.
Sep 28, 2024
Pizza spot on food every New Yorker would know pizza like this is just like back home
Read MoreRebecca P.
Sep 1, 2024
Still yummy after all these years just more $$$ though unfortunately. But for an occasional treat, by the slice, it hits the spot.
Read MoreChristie E.
Apr 24, 2024
So I found this place by accident and I'm glad I did was in cary for work and wanted something quick and close so I decided to try it anytime I see ny style pizza I laugh being from nyc the pizza never looks or taste like nyc pizza but I soon as I walked in the smell took me back home to the bronx the decor was also a great reminder of my city and somethings I miss about home I talked to the manager/owner for a minute but when I saw the slices I knew the pizza had a chance that first bite was heaven the cheese pull was awesome the crust was crispy it wasn't doughy the sauce was just right I really enjoyed my pepperoni slice at this gem of a pizzeria so next time I'm in cary I know where I'm stopping thank you for the experience oh sorry no pics it was gone before I thought about it Please check this place out if you want a ny slice
Read MorePatsy P.
Jun 15, 2024
I am done with these guys, spent way too much money for subpar pizza. They don't respond to complaints so why bother.
Read MoreKatie V.
Sep 8, 2023
I'm a bit disheartened to write a comment about our recent purchases. My half of the pizza always requests onion & I always add a note to request that it be THIN SLICES. Thick chunks of onion actually makes a pizza very unpleasant in taste, in my opinion. I feel if I'm paying nearly $40 for a pizza (plus tax/delivery/tip) that I should at least like my pizza. I'll stop asking for onion when I order from them again, and picked off the onion chunks that I paid for, of course - but would hope next time they'd take a moment to call a customer (before just throwing on whatever they have around) to see if they're ok with an alternate item than what the customer specifically requested.
Read MoreHeather W.
Dec 17, 2023
This is hands down our absolute favorite pizza place! We always head here when we want a pie. The owners are great to work with on events, and they are supportive of our community! Additionally, when we moved to Cary we were so worried about finding authentic NY style pizza with great flavor. This pizza is consistently the best! We love Original NY!
Read MoreRebecca J.
Aug 7, 2024
I got the almost everything pizza, and there was barely anything on it, especially not pepperoni. So disappointed. This has happened my last two times. I spoke with management and asked why it was different from two years ago when the pizza was overflowing with plentiful toppings. And by the way, of course the price has increased dramatically. I'm done with New York pizza.
Read MoreDixie D.
Jun 29, 2024
Great crust otherwise so-so. Looks like more take out business than sit down. Clean restaurant and pizza maker/server/cashier (all in one) was pleasant and accommodating.
Read MoreVanessa C.
May 9, 2024
The usual NY greasy 2 slice walk-in order. I'm sure it would be much better if I had ordered a fresh whole pie. But I was feeding the belly not the soul. Very convenient to Wake Med Cary- when you're tired of vending food.
Read MoreBethany H.
Apr 4, 2024
Great pizza! Fast delivery! We had an extra large pepperoni, a large cheese, small white garden pizza and Greek salads. Everything was delicious!! And truly like NY pizza.
Read More