Neighborhood Pizza Guy

If you're in Menlo Park and craving a slice of pizza heaven, look no further than Neighborhood Pizza Guy. This gem of a spot combines the warmth of a local pizzeria with the flair of a true culinary artist. The crust is perfectly crisp, the sauce is rich and flavorful, and the toppings are always fresh and generous. Each bite is a delightful explosion of taste that keeps you coming back for more. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere make every visit feel like a meal at a friend's house. Neighborhood Pizza Guy isn't just a place to grab a quick bite; it's a destination for anyone who appreciates the art of pizza-making. Highly recommend for pizza lovers everywhere!

My husband calls this spot a hidden gem. I was looking for pizza spots...something to go along with an exciting Lakers vs Warriors game. Came upon this spot and wow!!! This may end up becoming our regular spot now. The dough is delicious and I'm usually not one to eat the crust..but I added the garlic parmesan spread to it and that definitely leveled up the pizza. The pizza was custom with pepperoni, red onion, spinach and mushroom. Apparently when my husband went to pick it up, the person working was sad to see the pizza go Thank you for such a memorable pizza and we can't wait to come back!!

It's ok not a spit for toddlers to get pizza the cheese becomes extremely hard. It's a dry pizza too. It's ok not great. Didn't want to order such a big pizza but Omgosh 21.00 dollars for this. No thank you. Kid barely could swallow it. Not a place to eat at lease for young ones

Was looking forward to trying this spot, however our first experience wasn't the greatest. Maybe it was an off day? I love to support small businesses and I really don't want to write a negative review but shitty service can ruin any good establishment. Kid at the counter was less than friendly and seemed like he didn't even want to be there, although the gentleman that brought out our pizza was pleasant. The pizza itself was pretty good - I'm a fan of the crust. They were only offering cheese and pepperoni slices at the time, I'd like to come back and try other options. I don't want our first experience to deter us from coming back but I do hope to see some improvement at the register if we do decide to revisit.

Man, I love their pizza. I order one almost every Sunday and pick up right after church service with the family. I like their pizza labs and my 5 year old daughter likes their cheese pizza. We switch it around for fun. Please try them out!

You know this pizza sucks when you realize the box is way too light when you walk out of here but you still hold out hope thinking it will still be good from reading the reviews here...Overrated, dry, disappointingly thin pizza. This pizza is so thin and insubstantial that it doesn't seem to retain heat. The colder this pizza gets, the harder it gets, and when you try to re-heat it, you loose what little moisture it has. If it weren't for the pepperoni grease, this pizza would have almost no moisture in it because it has very little sauce, very little cheese and a floppy, barely-there dough that gets drier as you get to the crust. The sauce is good but not consistent, the cheese is ok but barely there, and the topping are the only good part of this slice, but the overall slice is so mediocre, dry, and hard as a finished product that you can't help but be disappointed. The pizza here feels like a ripoff. Some people might like how thin this pizza is, but I just couldn't enjoy it and other people eating it with me couldn't even finish their slices.I don't know why this place has such good reviews. I've never had such a disappointing pizza in my entire life. The reviews here make you think this place is a hidden gem, but it's the most mediocre local pizza you will ever have. I should have known from the fact that this place was almost empty on a weeknight. The place was nice, clean and the service was fine, with good online ordering using Toast, but I will never, ever come here again considering the pizza was so dry, cold, thin and only above average in flavor. Better slices: Golden Boy, Slice House by Tony, A Slice of New York.

Best pizza around here. Enjoyed some live music to boot. The Pizza lab was amazing. Perfect NYC style crust.

Our first visit! Five Stars, as expected. [ No more needs to be said (except that Yelp requires a minimum-length review). ]

Thin and light, excellent crust, sauce has a great taste to it. Little bit of flop, hard to beat a standard issue slice here. Best pizza in the area at a great price. Will be coming back!

Excellent food and service provided by the entire staff. First time customer who is embarrassed to admit that I ate the entire large build your own pizza by myself.