Goodfellas Pizza & Pasta

Great local spot for beer, appetizers and pizza! Chill atmosphere and great service. Consistent quality whether ordered for dine-in or takeout.

1041 Terra Nova Blvd Pacifica, CA 94044Goodfellas Pizza & Pasta is located in the Park Mall Shopping Center. It can be found at Terra Nova Blvd & Oddstad in Pacifica, CA. The other night my job finished up nearby, and I was really hungry. I looked over the mixed reviews for this place on Yelp, but decided to try their pizza anyway.I walked in just before 9pm, and ordered a medium Combo Pizza. The lady at the register said that's a Medium "Da Godfather." The names of the pizzas are related to the names of mobsters and gangsters of the movies, TV, and history. Okay, this was my first time here. I believe I was overcharged for a 16" Medium Da Godfather Pizza. The menu says $22.50, and she charged me $27+. After I got home, I looked at the online menu. Same price, $22.50. So how was the pizza? No flavor and not enough cheese. I wasn't sure what was wrong with it. All the ingredients were there. Why does the sausage and pepperoni have so little flavor? Was the pizza undercooked? When I went to pull off a slice, there was no "cheese pull." There wasn't strands of melted cheese streaming off the pizza. That means there's not enough cheese. When I got home, I put two slices in my air fryer. I did 375"F for about 10-mins, and it tasted a little better. So let me get this right. There were three guys in the kitchen, and nobody knows how to make a pizza ? Would I return? No thanks

Crap, orderd Plates and utensils for salad, none of wich showed up the good fella pizza had no sauce.. I called after it was delivered and the guy on the phone basically said ohh well so I had to eat the salad with my fingers and a credit card... I guess you have to just pack Plates and plastic wear when ya have delivery from here. Thanks guys, crap service

Spent $70 on two pizzas and wings! The wings were so dry and inedible, Barely any sauce! The pizzas were bland and had zero life. Needless to say, I will not be going back!

Great meatballs. I put them on my pizza since we had to get a veggie pizza for my sister. Now, my dinner party did have some difficult customers, but the service was pretty poor. I don't usually go here but decided to come by since it's closer to my house but will avoid in the future. I much prefer Luigi's pizza in Linda mar.

Have gone to Goodfellas at least 10 times.Always order the cheese pizza, either the whole pie or by the slice. DELICIOUS...like New York Pizza (sicilian), it's the best Bay Area Pizza I've ever eaten!! Nice relaxed atmosphere, friendly service.

This feels like a Pacifica landmark. The ambience is great for kids. The food is reliably solid. The spicy seafood pasta is one of my favorites. The spinach salad with shrimp is also excellent. I almost rated at four stars just because nothing ever changes or improves. It's solid. You can still buy pizza by the slice which I really appreciate in terms of the cost.

Just very inconsistent. Sometimes it's good , other times inedible. It's not like the owner just started this business. This place should be terrific. It's just not.

Pizza is mid. They are not very generous with cheese or toppings. Surprised they stayed in business this long. Crust is good for like 5 seconds after coming out of the oven.Wouldnt spend money at this place with those prices.

Had a bittersweet experience at Goodfellas pizza. We had my son's birthday there and honestly everyone was great during the planning and also on the day of. The big disappointment was that their website is completely outdated and they've recently almost doubled the pricing on all of their items. We thought that the price advertised on their website was the price that we would have paid and we're disappointed to pay over $600 for 8 pizzas and 4 pitchers of beer without be in told or having it clearly in writing on their website. At the counter, they pointed to a random printed out piece of paper stating they had a price increase. Would unfortunately not recommend goodfellas unless you are comfortable paying around $45 for a large pizza that is pretty average.