Long Island Mike's Pizza
Long Island Mike's Pizza
Buffalo chicken pizza
Margherita
Buffalo ranch and meat lovers pizza, side of garlic knots
I always try the crust first so I can taste the dough, and this pizza delivered!!!
12/05/2020
Half white me pie for me. Mushroom momma for the momma. Half cheese and pep for the kids (and me).
Half Cheese / Half Buffalo
Grandma Pie
Look like quail wings. SO small! Lol
Meatball Calzone
8pc buffalo wings
Tiny little wings/legs. Not worth it
18" cheese pizza
20 pc. BBQ Chicken Wings
Grandma's Pizza
pizza, food
pizza, food
Authentic New York Style pizza!!! Meat lovers
Italian flag pie w/ pepperoni
pizza, food
White Meat Pie
Jack M.
Dec 28, 2023
I like Long Island Mike's Pizza, but I was very sadden to learn that they stopped offering pizza by the slice. That was my go to every time I visited. I really hope they bring it back in the near future. Two slices and a beverage was a great way to roll for a quick lunch.
Read More
Nicole S.
Nov 13, 2023
Love that this opened right in our neck of the woods. It's super cute and vibing on the inside. The gal that works the counter, she is bilingual, has to be as nice as they come. She is genuinely happy when you walk in!! They are friendly and welcoming. We ordered take out. It was made fresh so took a few minutes. Bubs got the cauliflower and said it was very good. All in all we will definitely be back.... The reason for 4 stars is they are definitely priced higher than other local pie shops and more limited hours of operation.
Read More
Jason H.
Jun 18, 2023
It's no secret that a good pizza is hard to come by, but this local pizza place is an exception to the rule. In a sea of pizza joints, this place stands tall with its perfect balance of tradition and creativity, creating a pizza experience that's nothing short of extraordinary.Every pizza here tells a story of fresh, high-quality ingredients, expertly handled dough, and an authentic passion for pizza-making. Each bite promises a burst of flavor, from the tangy, well-seasoned sauce, to the perfectly melted cheese, and the wide array of toppings that are as fresh as they are flavorful. The crust deserves a special mention - crisp on the outside, chewy on the inside, it's a testament to the pizzaiolo's skills and dedication.But it's not just about the pizzas. The staff adds to the charm of the place, their service is friendly and prompt, and they make sure every visitor feels welcome and satisfied. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this pizza place is an absolute must-visit. I can't wait to return for another slice of their superb pizza. This place, without a doubt, earns a well-deserved five-star rating!
Read More
Nellie T.
Jan 7, 2024
Yummy pizzas and the garlic knots are a must- Only downside sometimes it closes early - Never have eaten there though. Seems quite large establishment for a pizza joint but none the less the pizza is great!
Read More
Corey R.
Sep 25, 2023
This is easily one of the best tasting and bang-for-your-buck, pizza places! Especially if you're wanting that NY style bigger slice, slightly thinner crust, but not cracker thin where it breaks apart. The cheese and sauce ratio is always well-balanced, I've waited to do a review just to test the consistency here a few times and I'm officially impressed and satisfied every time. Great friendly service, solid prices compared to the competition, and never too busy that you're waiting an unreasonable time for a pizza.P.S. TRY THE GARLIC KNOTS!
Read More
Elizabeth C.
Nov 14, 2023
Love this place. They are located in a bit sketchy location and parking lot is horrible but their pizza is worth it!. The crust isn't hard like a lot of pizza places do. Their toppings are yummy. Most of all the staff is amazing!
Read More
Robert B.
Jul 4, 2023
We are lucky to have this pizzeria in our neighborhood.We order from them all the time and they're pretty good. But we recently put them to the test ordering 11 pizzas for our daughter's birthday party and Mike's totally crushed it!We got so many compliments on the pizza and the pesto over was a huge hit! We should have gotten more of that and the pepperoni jalapeno. Those went quick with the parents! Everyone loved the pizza and the customer service was terrific. The pizzas were ready on time exactly as ordered and the lady even helped me out to the car.We'll be back soon! Especially for that pesto pizza!
Read More
Riley L.
Jul 28, 2024
Great white pizzas taste amazing love this place food is always quality! & quick thank you !
Read More
Michelle f.
Jul 26, 2024
Love this local pizza place! They have amazing quality food for affordable prices. The gluten free pizza is super delicious as well. The service is always amazing as well, everyone is always so friendly.
Read More
May A.
May 8, 2024
Great pizza, kind people! We like the Grandma's pie but everything we've tried is good.
Read More
