Randy's Pizza

They have really big slices which I love and just a solid pizza slice. Nice crust nice flavor sauce isnt sweet and if you get your pizza hit you'll always have a cheese pull. I made the mistake of ordering a pie in one of the lower sizes and won't do that again. Unless it's a specialty pizza only order 16" and above so you can get those big slices. Love the overall standard pizza joint feel from this place and in being in NC for 2 years I only have 2 pizza restaurants menus and they are one of them.

Favorite pizza spot in Durham since growing up so now every time I come home to see my family, we have to order Randy's at least once!! Always great customer service, can't beat the NY style pizza and the sauce is just right - not too heavy but tasty however not over powering the toppings even with a good ol' plain cheese pizza which is what we ordered tonight! This location is right in the shopping center on MLK with plenty of parking and easy access stop right after going to the grocery store or even the movie theater next door! May not look too fancy on the outside or inside but it's your local pizza place, what matters is the food, speed of readiness and the overall quality experience from the staff!! Check it out, I've never been disappointed and have been going here for 20 plus years!!

Local chain - this store seems to be well-loved in the neighborhood. People entering were sometimes greeted by name. I ordered a calzone and two pies for a family event. Found the crust to be very limp and the sauce to be almost nonexistent. Toppings were mostly clumped in the center, so there was a full inch or more of crust with no cheese or sauce around the outer rim. Meh.

Randy's is my go to pizza place! Everything is amazing. The pizza, wings, garlic knots, and salads are all great. The employees are super friendly, and everything is done quickly whether I order for pickup or delivery. Their rewards program is also really great. I feel like I always have a reward for free garlic knots!

While visiting my aunt in Durahm/Duke, NC, my aunt brought us to this cute, little, pizza restaurant. She wanted to share one of her favorite pizza spots, that come close enough to remind her of home (NY). She says (It's the closest thing to NY style pizza out here). After devouring a large slice of the cheesy, pepperoni, and sausage, I agree. It comes remarkay close to the famous NY pizza's. All the ingredients including the spices are freshly cut, and never frozen. The freshness of the ingredients really does make a big difference, on how delicious the pizza turns out. I'm saddened that we only bought one, because after we got back to her place, the three of us ate the entire box in about thirty minutes.

I'll start positive. Pizza looks good, nice and hot, great presentation. I won't go back though because The pizza was tasteless. Barely any sauce if any. Waaaaay too cheesy. Customer service was horrible.

Our family loves Randy's! They are always super quick but quality, and you can tell they use fresh ingredients. Since we're regulars we've gotten to know the staff a bit and they are really sweet and welcoming. Our go to pizza place, we wouldn't have it any other way!

There are 6 entries in Yelp for Randy's Pizza. I am writing specifically about location on GUESS ROAD, on the edge of the defunct Northgate Mall. The Northgate store is a lot cleaner and cheerier than the last time I was there in 2021. The sit-down area is newish but still basic and boring. The menu board is electronic which means you have to wait for screens to flip in order to see the whole menu (or ask multiple questions of the cashier). Menu has expanded to include more pasta, salad, and dessert items. Sicilian thick crust is listed right up with the thin NY crust, no longer hidden as a footnote.True to online advertising, this location did serve the largest slices in town (photo). Crust was chewy but did not have that fine crackle that arises when coated generously with olive oil before baking. The sauce and cheese topping was rather bland for my taste, but at least it was low-salt and not excessively greasy. For the price, the slices were good value.Good neighborhood joint for bringing kids or coworkers for a quick bite.[ An employee there told me that 2 Durham locations are not part of the Randy's chain, even though they use the Randy's name (??). In the past, I had noticed a difference in recipes and pricing depending on the location. ]

I am originally from NY, and nothing comes close to authentic NY Style pizza like Randy's! The food is excellent-- my go-to order is an 18 inch (yes, 18 inch!!) Elia's Classic Greek pizza, garlic knots, and a Caesar salad with grilled chicken! The friendliness of the staff, fresh food, and consistency of the food quality makes Randy's the best pizza you can find in the Triangle. During the weekend evenings in the summer, you can sit out on the Randy's patio and enjoy live music performances while enjoying your dinner-- perfect for small get-together's with friends and family. Be sure to call in your order in advance! Randy's is a popular spot, and you may need to wait a while if you walk in during the dinner rush.

Randy's is a Durham gem and this specific location is The Original. I've been coming to this Randys since they opened and the consistency of the food and familiarity of the staff says a lot about Randy as the owner. We typically get a combination of pizza, boneless wings and their subs. Love them all and it's a weekly staple for our family.