Pie-Eyed Pizzeria
Pie-Eyed Pizzeria
Summertime Chi Pie
After dinner slice
Perfect thin crust pizza. Pepperoni and jalapeños
pizza, food
Want some cheese on those meatballs???
Fully Loaded Chicago Style Pan
Meatball Mondays!
Monster Pie!
pizza, food
Butterfly Fried Shrimp
Fresh and delicious side salad
BBQ chicken pizza-not only beautiful-but a symphony of flavors and perfect crust
Fresh Garden Salad
Pepperoni and sausage 14" classic thin
1/2 Tomato 1/2 Green Pepper & Onion
pizza, interior
a hand holding a piece of pizza
Hot Wings
Spinach & Mushroom
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Elote style
Voted Reader Best Pizza 2010
Anuj S.
Jul 30, 2023
Recently did a pizza by the slice tour in my neighborhood of West Town and Pie Eyed Pizza was a cool though unplanned discovery. I was driving by towards another pizza slice place and happened to see the sign for Pizza slice.The pizza here was decent. Nice and crispy crust, which is my style of tavern pizza. Good stuff, although they didn't have enough sauce in the pizza. I think if they had had more sauce, this would've been a really good pizza. No other complaints. I'd give it 3.5 if I had that option.Price-wise at $5.75 or so for the slice, the pricing was just in-line with nearby pizza joints. I'm willing to give this place another shot in case the less sauce thing was a one-time miss. Love when you find something unexpected, though.
Read More
Samuel M.
Jun 15, 2023
I totally agree with another yelper in here that the Pizza tastes like Chuck E Cheese pizza. The crust tastes like day old flatbread. The sauce tastes as generic as Chef Boyardee. The only thing that was edible was the cheese and pepperoni. Plus, they say they're open at 11am, but they'll shoo you away bc they say they're not actually ready to open until 11:10am. And the people working there aren't too friendly.
Read More
Seth A.
Sep 17, 2023
For $10 for a slice & fountain soda, they could really be making a better slice of pizza. As a matter of pride, guys, make a better slice of pizza. It's fine; it could so easily be better. You're charging $10 for a slice and a fountain soda. Surely could make this slice better.
Read More
Cassie E.
Jan 21, 2023
Very good pizza! I prefer thinner crusts so this wasn't too thick, so I really liked it!
Read More
Mick S.
Jul 10, 2023
Best slice in Chicago, great family business where it's fun to catch either the owners or their mom for a quick chat for grab and go.
Read More
Christina S.
Jul 4, 2020
Pie-Eyed Pizza is one of my top 5 pizza places "for delivery" I am in love with their Thin Crust-Pepperoni, Sausage, Red Onion, Red Pepper and Mushroom, and Tomato Pie! Their Perfect Crust-holds up the sauce and toppings, is soft and evenly cooked!!!The cheese is authentic shredded whole milk mozzarella which makes all the difference for leftovers being heated up!They also sprinkle pizza seasoning on the finished pie!Oh My Pizza Pie- I have ordered a pizza every week for the last 3 weeks! Love it!!!!!!!
Read More
Wendy H.
Mar 30, 2020
This is how I imagine pizza would taste like if I successfully made it at home. There was a lot of tomato sauce and it moved the cheese around. I didn't like the crust so glad there wasn't much of it. But I felt that it could have been more crispier. The pepperonis was the only thing making it tasty. This is an 18" pizza so there was definitely enough. The price was average after a discount.Then again, I am a fan of Domino's and their garlic crust so maybe I'm not the best person to ask for pizza advice.
Read More
Jen M.
Jul 19, 2024
I just ordered a full pie for the first time as I usually stop in for just a slice and WOW not only did the pizza look delicious it is the best pizza in Chicago! Order thin crust pizza you can thank me later! Perfect pizzas I'm so happy I ordered! Thank you!
Read More
Natalia C.
May 4, 2024
This is sad to say because Pie-eye Is my neighborhood pizzeria, but this is the worst pizza i have ever had. Frozen pizza from CVS tastes better, to be honest. I do have to say, I have only had it at night, so maybe its not at its prime.. but its not good. Do try for yourself, please, and give me your thoughts.
Read More
Foodie W.
Aug 9, 2023
Horrendously bad. Horrendously overpriced pizza. Hard to tell which is worse, crust or sauce. $6.25 all in for a cheese slice. If this was a 99 cent slice place it would be overpriced
Read More
