Piccola New York Pizza

Stopped in for a takeout large pie for lunch. The Good: The pizza was very good. 7.9. Nice and thin and the way I remember from home. They are putting out a nice product. Super nice people too. The Challenges: There were none with my experience except if the pizza stayed in the oven another minute it gets into the 8's. I'll be back. Good pizza in GA. Thank you!

So this is a very Small shop, only about 4 to 5 seats on the inside and a couple of picnic tables on the inside. No signage but there are small menu's to look at (I tried to take a pic for y'all lol).The service was good. One of the chefs hooked me up with a slice just because. He didn't know me so that was mad cool of him! Fries were pretty good. It was odd because the seasoning on the fries or if there was any legit seasoning it was only on the top, they didn't actually shake the fries in the seasoning so I noticed that. So you would get fries that have something on them and then you get fries that are pretty bare so that was something I noticed.Meat lovers slice was Good. Didn't have as much sauce that I would have liked to have, but it had a lot of meat and it was placed with plenty of flavor. It was kind of like a calzone situation because the bottom and the top of the pizza had crust. I guess they said they were going to do that so they would have to worry about something falling off while you're eating it. We'll just cover it lol.White slice was actually really good. Didn't have meat on it, but it had a very mild but pretty good flavor profile to it. So if you dont eat meat, this may be for you.Lemon pepper wings were Good and flavor but my only grip was the fact that they were very small. Comes with carrots and celery and your choice of ranch and blue cheese dressing. You get about 10 wings, well I did, but again, they weren't the biggest wings.This could be a decent go to pizza spot for me. It didn't miss on flavor. I wish that everyone back there had on gloves, which was my only thing. Is that going to be something that stops me from trying it again, no, but I would have liked to see all employees doing it.

I can't believe I haven't written about this place yet.This is a pizzeria of any NYC kid's life pre-2000s. The only thing missing are the percolating tank fountains of purple and red drink. This is the kind of pizza I grew up with and thank god it's close to where I live because I get homesick a lot and this helps during those days.We've had almost everything on the menu and besides really good pizza, I love the philly chicken cheesesteak and my wife loves the baked ziti and the regular philly cheesesteak. The cheesesteaks are one of the best that I've had and definitely the best in GA. I also really like the chicken roll, but I do wish it was more like the chicken rolls back in Brooklyn; smaller and no cheesy butter topping. Again, it's a great chicken roll, just sometimes I crave the more simple version of it.This isn't a place where you sit down and eat. It's just a counter and a few stools next to the window bar. There is a table or two outside when the weather is nicer, but ultimately, expect this to be a place where you place and order and pick it up.

Great pizza!!! We always order mushroom pizza slices. It's reasonable and delicious! After Piccola, we stopped ordering chains.

I have placed to go orders from here twice in the last two weeks and both were very good. First time we ordered a white pizza with pepperoni and a supreme pizza. The garlic knots were amazing. The second time we called and ordered a Sicilian Nona Deep Dish pizza. Highly recommend. Cannot wait to try other offerings.

This is a small place with a couple of bar seats which is clearly geared towards takeout. It took a minute for me to be greeted resulting in some good-natured ribbing (I think) between the staff.I'm always skeptical of places that say "New York Style"; of course you'd want to associate yourself with the pinnacle of the cuisine you're doing, but it's often just a cheap marketing trick. My Sicilian pizza, however, was quite impressive. A distinctively textured crust was browned deliciously at the edges while being soft and relatively light inside, making for a satisfying crunch. Mushrooms and peppers were helpful toppings, and while it is a $30 pizza, it is also enormous and will be good for multiple meals.They didn't have much besides bread and cheese, but the picture of a salad they had up kind of made me wish I'd gotten one. Regardless, you'll be hard pressed to find a better pizza of this sort in the region.

Great little place to checkout if you love pizza! The service is quick and oh so friendly! The pizza is incredible! They also have rolls that look and sound delicious so we'll definitely be returning to try some more things off their menu!

OMG. The food is delicious. I'm originally from New Jersey and it's really difficult to find New York style pizza in Georgia. Piccola's has changed my view. Their food is amazing. Great attitude too.

BELIEVE THE HYPE!!!! This place is AMAZING!!! We've been twice and the second time sealed the deal!The service is fast and easy! Call-in, ready in 15-20mins. Boom!It's a real deal pizza shop and the accent of whom I assume maybe the owner is real deal NY style of Italian. There are soda cans for sale that are apart of a deal which is two slices with a soda; take about super nostalgic!First time we ordered a medium white pizza with mushrooms, black olives, and bacon added to half the pizza. The original pizza made was wrong so they made us another right on the spot and sold our pizza by the slice because they sell slices of pizza which is rare but awesome. Long story short, the pizza was piping hot and ABSOLUTELY delicious!!! Oh em gee! We finished it in one night and didn't leave leftovers.Fast forward to the second visit which prompted this review, it was pizza night and we wanted to try this place again since it's not far from us. We ordered the veggie with half having pepperoni. I also ordered A Sicilian Nona slice because I love deep dish pizza and wanted to test it out for next time. When I picked the pizza it was super hot! There was steam coming from the box. The Sicilian slice came in a brown bag with a paper plate and I couldn't wait to eat it so I ate it right on the spot in the parking lot lol! It was soooooo flavorful and cheesy and bigger than I anticipated. Definitely will be ordering a whole pizza next time. I saved the rest for my partner so he can try it.The pizza was everything and we finished it in one swoop! So flavorful, so hot, and nice sized slices.This place is a 10 out of 10.

I heard their pizza was great but I tried their calzone. Oh my gosh!, it was delicious and huge. Now, I can't wait to try the pizza.