Old Hickory Barbeque Inn

Kids chicken strips cooked in old grease- all the black specs look like it could be seasoning but in actuality it was not. Throwing it straight into Styrofoam made it burn holes and made everything be greasy in the bag. My son could stomach eating the potatoes. My baked potato did not have real bacon bits that they advertise. The meat seems like the kind you heat in the microwave. Nothing about it struck me as fresh. There were very few green onions and the meat was thinly spread across the top to look like the extra meat I paid for. I'm sure I wouldn't feel comfortable ordering again. It's super crazy to see places not think about their customers and it's so disgusting and inconsiderate. A medical condition is why I had to order- I will definitely get somewhere else next time.

Ordering at the drive through could most definitely use improvement, the young woman who's at the window was very sweet but the ones who take your orders had me questioning why I came initially before I got to the window. Anyways, I ordered the loaded baker with sour cream on the side and also peach cobbler. The potato was good but doesn't compare to others I've had, lack of sauce just felt like I was eating a plain potato after the few drops of bbq my order received were gone. The peach cobbler was one of THE worst I've ever had. I couldn't do more than two bites, it was literally undercooked, the "crust" melted right in my mouth and overall just horrible flavor peaches are most definitely canned they had a dusty scent to them. Wouldn't return and I definitely don't recommend the cobbler I threw it away could only enjoy half of my meal since it wasn't good with sauce so threw that away as well.

The stuffed baked potato I ordered came out fast, hot, and PERFECT!....and the service was excellent. The young lady working the counter was so courteous and prompt. My only regret is....I inhaled WAY too many calories in one sitting. I ate the entire potato and that thing was gigantic! Oh well, life goes on...

I have been a long time customer for years. The baked potatoes are better than a major bbq chain in the city.However, that's where the end of the road with this place begins. Since COVID19 , I have noticed much thinner ribs and the chef salads are abysmal! The lettuce is fresh, but the stingy portions of tomatoes and the meat is not worth the money they charge! Don't bother looking for cucumbers, onions, generous portions of shredded cheese because you won't find any in their chef salad. In addition, they didn't provide croutons or crackers which is something they use to do back in the day.It's as if I have to play I Spy while searching for meat in my salad. Pappas BBQ charges just $2 more than this place and includes three bountiful portions of meat. It's unfortunate that this business is cutting corners at the cost of losing customers because I'm done unless it's for a baked potato.

Brisket and sausage were very good. Sauce was good. Mac and cheese was ok. Mashed potatoes were bland. Baked potato was excellent.I have no idea how the desserts were, because I was full. They looked good.Great service. Big flatscreen to watch the game on.We had a good time.

I was craving Barbecue and have been here before and enjoyed the food even though it's a bit pricey. I ordered a chopped beef baked potato and a sliced beef po boy. I received my food decently fast and went home and that's when I discovered that I was missing my po boy in the bag. I called the restaurant and spoke with an employee who immediately remembered the order and apologized and took down my name and number and offered to replace and give me a fresh po boy to make up for them not giving my complete order. I went back about an hour later even though it is fairly close and picked up the sandwich and was even given a free drink as compensation. I'm leaving a 5 star review because, 1 the food truly is great and tasty but also 2 the customer service is great. I will also say this is why you should treat your server nice and not yell or belittle them for a mix up. If you can calmly explain the problem, more often than not both parties can come to a satisfactory solution. I will still come back and order from this establishment again.

The food is overpriced with no flavor. The staff has no idea, culturally how to prepare the food they are making because what the serve and the taste don't make sense. Year's ago, this place had good food but they fell off in the past 4 years - it's literally disgusting now

The food was good. It isn't anything wrong with a decent bbq place that can deliver the basics in a nice way. The areas that I was impressed with were the potato salad, mash potatoes, and jalapeño bbq sauce. The catfish could've used more or better batter. Green bean were from a can and there is nothing wrong with that. Just add your own touch of flavorings. The macaroni was on the too soft side for me, but is a good option. The brisket Was cooked well but was better with the bbq sauce than without. The turkey was really good. The meat was room temperature unfortunately. The interior of the place is charming. The staff was very helpful and offered quick service! Great job to them, especially the new guys that were just hired.

Service was horrible. They can take orders but not follow them. First i told the cashier I wanted a chopped beef but not in the sauce. Behold my food comes out with sauce mixed in sauce then another cashier tells me well when you say chopped beef no it comes in the sauce. I am aware but I told the previous cashier how I wanted it. So they remake my potoatoe wrong again now I am missing bacon bites. Like for real I am over it at this point and didnt waste my time ordering again. The workers interaction with someone of a different demographic veses their own demographic is pretty obvious. They enjoying speaking in their native tounge with thier peers while demanizing others...

Food is good. Service is horrible. Packaging spilled immediately of me getting into my car and my 2 different sides were not separated ... beans with coleslaw. Beans tasted pretty sour as well.