Nicky's Undefeated

Parking is a bit tight in front of the store but if you go around the block to the back, there might be more parking spots. Their cheesesteak is solid! Fresh hot melted cheese on proper cooked beef and good bread. Simply tasty. I do wish they have mushroom as an optional topping but that doesn't affect the quality of the cheesesteak. They have a window for togo order if you don't want to dine in. You can also just walk in and place the order for to go. The restaurant is nice and clean. The staffs are friendly and helpful. I will try the ice cream the next time i stop by. Definitely should give it a try if you're in the area!

I have been looking forward to trying Nicky's Undefeated for awhile now. I had a rough day at work, didn't feel like cooking, so I picked up hubby and we moseyed along in traffic and headed downtown (Tucker) to try the Philly/Jersey sandwiches. I ordered the beef cheesesteak "Wit" (with onions) and provolone with the seeded bun, plus fry combo and added cherry peppers and banana peppers. Hubby ordered the Italian hoagie (Philly Way) on a regular bun, plus pasta salad combo. Both sandwiches were stacked with meat!I wished there were a bit more onions in my cheese steak, but I'm not complaining because of the amount of meat - it was a perfect ratio of bread:meat (tipping heavier to the meat side just as it should). I really enjoyed that the meat wasn't chopped too much so you got nice big chunks which kept it from getting over cooked and dried out like many places do. I'm going to try the Cooper cheese sauce next time instead of provolone. I had eaten half my sandwich before I even noticed I didn't get the seeded bun like I ordered. I was enjoying it too much to realize. Once I did,though, I was disappointed because I can just imagine how that would have nudged the sandwich even higher on my taste scale. Oh well, just means I have to go back sooner so I can try it. {I'll make sure I get the right bread BEFORE I start to devour it, though.}Hubby really enjoyed his Italian hoagie, he loved the seasoning/oil/vinegar they used as part of the "Philly Way." He said the dressing was better than [the chain Jersey sandwich place] - Shocking!!! {he loves that other place}. He also raced about the pasta salad which was well seasoned and dressed. He thoroughly enjoyed being able to order a side other than a bag of chips.For dessert we opted for peach ice cream (for me) and lemon water ice (for hubby) - hubby definitely made the better choice! We had never heard of water ice before - it is a creamy refreshing not too sweet delight. So how long will it be before we return? Knowing us and our enjoyment of great "sand-ditches" - and knowing how bad I really wanted to try that seeded bun - it won't be very long at all.Edit: I'm thinking I got sliced jalapenos, not the cherry peppers I ordered...another thing to check next time.

Finally made it to Nicky's Undefeated in downtown Tucker. Their cheesesteak is one of the best I've had in the Atlanta area; high quality ribeye, really good provolone, grilled onions, all on a proper roll. The service was quick and friendly. And I like the fact they have a full bar with draft beer and spirits. Great spot, cool dining room and vibe....we'll be back.

We were very happy to see this new addition to the Tucker culinary landscape. As we walked in, the space is impressive--clean, spacious, and not crowded. There are large TVs and get this--a bar--a full bar! But I digress...We ordered cheesesteaks, of course. I got the Founder's sandwich and my wife got something that was basically just beef and cheese on bread. We were both pleased with what we got. Lots of meat on a nice roll. It needed more cheese, but I'm not going to hold this against them, yet. Staff was very friendly, considering we walked in with less than 30 min to closing. But they took our order at the counter, and they served us with a smile. Next time we'll do our best to arrive early. Holler if you're coming with.

I went here on 8/19/2024 for the first time. I got some chicken wings 6 for $12.00 I wanted lemon pepper flavor they had Garlic Parm instead they are delicious! The cheesesteak is really different from others I tried before the copper cheddar is creamy in delicious and you taste it the whole time you eat this sandwich. I also got a lemon water ice delicious.

I. Can't. Even. If you long for an authentic sandwich from the South Jersey/Philadelphia area, Nicky's in Tucker GA is your Nirvana. They've even got Cooper Sharp Cheese. IYKYK.we had the chicken cheese steak and chicken cutlet sandwiches. Both awesome. Get yourself a wooder ice on the way out!

Well, I will say Tucker can add another great resteraunt to the city. I had a 6 inch Philly. That sandwitch was nice and flavorful and cheesy. I especially loved the bean salad. The bean salad had a nice vinegarette taste,with just the right amount of onion added in. The service was a little slow,around 25 minutes. However, the quality of the food and tastes was exceptional. I will certainly be back again and advise you do the same.

I've been very excited for Nicky's to open. Tucker has some great little food spots but I'm always happy for more. And it would be great to get a cheesesteak from somewhere that's not a national chain. Inside: Very nice. Clean, not crowded. The decor is super nice, and seems like more is coming. Large TVs and a good sized bar, could see coming here to enjoy a game. Lots of nods to (what I assume is?) Philly, even down to the table numbers. Food: Food came out pretty quick. Fries are solid. Well seasoned. Didn't strike me as like the best fries ever but very good. The cheesesteak is AWESOME. Great bread, lots of steak, delicious onions and nice melty cheese. My favorite thing about the sandwich though is that it wasn't super greasy. It didn't feel heavy or oily. Really loved the sandwich. The cherry peppers... a little weird? Not sure if it's a Philly thing but they were just 4 whole cherry peppers in a deli container and cost $2. The counter worker told me they'd be on the side, but I assumed they'd be chopped and something I could add on to my sandwich? Again, could just be a regional thing that I'm not aware of but I wouldn't order them again. They were good! But just snacking on peppers was a little weird. Service: not much to say here. Order at the counter and take a seat. Service was fine. Worker was friendly and nice, asked if I had any questions before ordering and walked me through the sandwich selections. Overall: 5/5. Even though Nicky's is still working out some kinks - they were assembling kitchen tables while I was in and they're Coke machine didn't want to cooperate 100% - I'm so excited to have it in Tucker. If the cheesesteak is a preview of the quality of their other menu items, I can't wait to try their hoagies and ice cream.

Perfection! Such fantastic cheesesteaks, we plan to slowly make our way through the whole menu.

I have been eager to try this place since I saw news of it opening and it did not disappoint! I am constantly in search of good sandwiches down here (originally from NY) and these tasted like home. I got 4 half sandwiches, fried mozz, and pasta salad. The only thing I'll say I could pass on is the pasta salad. It was fine, but overpriced. Now, to the good:Italian sandwich: removed lettuce and tomato, added hoagie spread and mayo. I enjoyed this one - actually more so after it sat a half hour or so. I do wish there was slightly less mortadella and more of the other, but still a solid choicePhilly: beef. Cooper cheese. Enjoyed this one as wellNick Foles: awesome sandwich. Generous chicken portions, flavorful broccoli rabe, just enough drizzle, sharp provolone worked well, didn't overpowerRocky balboa: I love a good chicken parm and this was solid. I do prefer 1 large cutlet and not pieces, but that's being nitpicky. The cutlet breading and flavor, enough sauce and mozz. Bread help up but easy to bite into. Finally a good parm! Prices are fine with me - you get way more than your average subpar sandwich spot. Ordered takeout during prime lunchtime and it was ready and waiting for me. If you want a good sandwich - go here!