Colosseum New York Pizza

I recently started coming here, and since my first time a month ago, I keep going back!! Originally came for slices, they have pizza ready and quickly warm it up. One time they only had cheese slice and added pepperoni since that's what we wanted. Slices can be expensive, two slices and two pops costs $18. I finally grew a brain and got a large half cheese half pepperoni which has 8 large slices for $33, so I recommend doing that. One thing that also made me want to order a full pizza is that the slices aren't evenly cut. One time I got a slice and it was huge another time I got a slice and it was smaller than the first one. Ordering a whole pizza is the way to go! It's a no frills kinda place, seating on the inside, parm & red pepper shakers for you to bring back to your table. Some TVs and a Statue of Liberty to remind you of NY hehe. Overall, I love love love this place!!! I love how thin the crust is, it makes it so easy to eat, I ate up my portion of the cheese half no issue. Just writing this review is making me crave it so bad. Highly recommend this for NY thin pizza! Not doughy and you won't be weighed down after eating it!

Is this solid NY Pizza for the Bay Area? As a native New Yorker (from Brooklyn), yes. I'd say so.Flavor and texture aside, I paid $8+ for a single pepperoni slice.... which is insane!!! And the fact that a regular cheese slice is $7!! How?! Crazy prices for single slices - next time id go for an entire pie.

My company catered Colosseum NY Pizza. The thin style slices of NY looked so appetizing. The quality of the pizza with fresh ingredient. My favorite have to the Long Island, Cheese, and Margherita. I heard the canoli (free with check in) is pretty popular on the menu. I read on YELP they only accept cash. It's too bad.

There is no more many pizza places that sell by slice.Great place to stop when you have no much time. My favorite is actually the cheese pizza.

I was out doing some house shopping and got really hungry in the process and landed up here! I was craving a yummy delicious snack (which I know pizza might be heavier than that, but this was great!) This spot has been on my list for some time, and since I went at a weird time it was relatively empty and got quick service. The ambiance is pretty casual here, so definitely a good spot for takeout.For food I got:* Pepperoni pizza slice - this was yummy and definitely a well made New York style pizza - I did find it to be a little salty though, and which the crust was a little chewier*Garlic knots - I definitely really wanted this and although it was yummy and had fresh garlic and a nice marinara sauce dip, I do wish it had a little bit more flavor. Overall though it came with multiple pieces and I could tell this was fresh which I appreciatedOverall, the food is good and worth trying for takeout if you are in the area!

Wow I can't believe this was my first trying this place! Such a hidden gem located in a really run down plaza. They serve true NY style pizza. The taste and quality is great. $38 for a large pizza with half margarita and half pepperoni. cash only! The slices are giant - 8 slices in a large, but you can ask for double cut if needed! I placed my order over the phone and it was ready in 15 minutes. I will definitely be back.

New York style pies... maybe the pandemic has changed this to be more of take outs & delivery pizza. They folded most of the tables and left with 2. No AirCon in the summer may not be comfortable. It's got lots of pictures of New York City which is a nice touch.Order up front and friendly staff patiently explains their limited menu for this 1st timer.The main event... pizza came out hot !!! Nice!!! The crunchy thin crust with bubbling edges. Very NYC style. Food is definitely 4 stars but the eating environment is a 3 star.Not as good as what I had back East, but good enough for getting something locally.

Absolutely love this place! The pizza was perfectly crispy and just the right ratio of sauce to cheese. The philly cheesesteak was sooo yummy! Not too soggy or salty and the perfect amount of onions. The store itself is very much new york with fun decorations. Owners are super nice, they asked if we wanted our pizza and cheesesteak together at the same time. Food came out really fast and fresh, I burned my tongue because I couldn't wait for the pizza to cool down

Colosseum New York Pizza is located in a small strip mall with the soon-to- be Lee's Sandwiches Market. We've been here a few times, but glad I was able to visit again.The service is nice and friendly. Inside dining only. The restroom was out of order.Sausage & Mushroom Pizza - crispy thin crust. The slice was loaded with crumbly sausage, which was slightly spicy and flavorful.

The pizza here is delicious. 100% tastes like NY pizza!However, I'm kinda iffy writing this review because although the food is great, the hours are not accurate. The first time I tried to come here, they closed an hour earlier than their posted closing time (10pm). Now, this is the 2nd time they closed early (8:45pm) when again it says they close at 10pm.. Be sure to call in advance before you set your heart out on pizza, unlike me right now :( lol