Buffalo Bill's Brewery

Whoa, my last review for this place was back in 2008, that's 17 years ago yo, WTF. Lol. Since then long tenured Buffalo Bills changed hands a little past the pandemic. Like many other owners, not many wanted to stick around in an already hard business. New blood had to enter the equation and good for Hayward, a local empire took over. Owners of the Metro Taquero chain and Casa Del Toro next door bought the business rights to this old time brew pub and Hayward classic. Much of the inside is the same, but honestly it's been so long since I've been in, I can't really tell. But the overall vibe is the same, very urban yet industrial vibe. The food and drink, albeit more expensive due to the times and inflation, is even better than what I remember so let's jot down an update.4 beer Sampler ($12/4*) A little pricey for trying to find out what they have but at least their beers are pretty good. I hate paying for a sampling and the beers suck. Like any where else, they have multiple IPAs, but they are on the lighter side but still quite balanced. These aren't the thick and heavy ones like Fieldwork and Drake's. I really liked their Hazy (juicy and fresh) and their Double Standard which has a stern hop finish. I also liked their Blueberry Oatmeal Stout which was smooth with just a faint blueberry hint, not in your face or artificial tasting. Half Club/Half Soup Combo - lunch special ($16/4*) You can pick between like 5 sandwiches or so, and between 2 soups. The sandwich was really good but at 3 layers can be a bit tough to bite into. Good toasted sourdough, turkey, bacon and avo slices. And the kicker I liked which you don't see often was pickled jalapenos which made it zing. I could eat pickled jalapenos on any sandwich, you just don't see it enough. I chose minestrone soup and it was hearty with big chunks of veggies and swollen shell pasta. Loved the taste of the broth and seasoning, just thought it was a bit skimpy of a portion (like cup was only filled half way) and the soup wasn't hot, barely warm. Still delicious just an observation noted.Combo Pizza ($22/4*) In my original review I was amused at how the pricing for pizza or burger was around $11 bucks. Now they are both over $20, weeeee! About small pizza in size about 8 small slices, good for 2 peeps as an app. Crust nicely charred on the edges edges but reamins soft and droopy in the center. I think the amount of cheese and sauce they use keeps it from getting totally crisp. But there is a good meaty and melty bite. I actually liked the slices cold the next day, as everything was stuck as one. Service at the bar was good, spacing was kinda tight. But I'll definitely be back and won't hold off as long as I did for this return. I'm just glad a successful local group took over an old institution to keep it alive. It's a model I can root for and support. Cheers!

We had been going to BB since the late 80's. After Covid they just couldn't get their magic back. We were there for the third time since the new owners took over and I am overjoyed to say it was amazing. We had a bit of everything- Gorgonzola garden salad, combo pizza, BB cheese burger and fried zucchini. A couple different beers and soda. The food and drink were outstanding. If you were an old time buffalo Bill's customer the beers were distinct. It's the same if not better. Our server was fantastic. He had been with BB since 1999, left and lucky for us returned. We will be back... soon!! Run don't walk you won't be disappointed.

I've been here before for a Yelp elite event, so it was great coming back for lunch with my coworkers! Or a great low key place to hang out with friends. I loved that the brewery has some of its equipment for display. Parking is super easy, there's a parking lot behind the restaurant.I ordered their fried chicken sandwich and it was super crispy and juicy. The fries were cooked perfectly. I didn't try any of their beers but it looked refreshing!

Stopped in for a bite to eat after golfing nearby. Even though it was not busy it took a while to get service and since we weren't drinking beers, we waited a long time for waters. Maybe under staffed at the time. I had the PestoChicken wrap, which was pretty good. I saw some pizzas and wings that looked good too. Overall it's a good gathering place in downtown Hayward if you want a beer and some good food.

I did not really impressed with the quality of salad and steak.Steak was fatty and not really like the salad , it was a bit wilted.One of the good parts was the beer. Super fresh and yummy . We ordered hazy style which got me after 2 sip.Service is fast and attentive. Ambience also is warm and cozy . This location has patio for nights that are quiet and not warm to enjoy.

Well, history alone says you NEED to come here......The FIRST Brewpub in America.....look it up! Anyways, they closed after Co-Vid, but were bought out and reopened. They have done an excellent job of keeping what was familiar, while elevating what was needed. Their food is now amazing! No longer " pub food", you will get a culinary experience! Their Happy Hour menu is AWESOME! So many good choices! I recommend one of the 4 slider options they have.....OR all four! The staff is attentive and awesome. SO friendly! Manager Alex knows how to staff appropriately for sure!Buffalo Bill's has been here since 1983. If you have never been....GO.....if you've been before, PLEASE go back and try them out again! The beer AND the food will have you coming back in for sure!

Buffalo Bills has been a staple in our family's repeat of local restaurants since its opening. I was thrilled when Alex opened the doors again, however the last few times we have visited have been disappointing. I make arrangements for several luncheon/dinner and book club gatherings, the last two times we've been has been a disaster. The staff surly, the music so loud that we couldn't hear each other and the food inconsistent in quality, serving portions and temperature. I live locally and want to support local businesses however it will be a while before I enter BB again. I have worked in the restaurant business and do not criticize easily because I know what it takes to run a business, but I also know that I would rather have a truthful critique than lose good customers.

What a great place to enjoy delicious burgers (sliders) and beer! They brew their own beer which was very tasty. Came here for happy hour and the price of the sliders/burgers and beers was only $5 each! Definitely coming back when I'm Hayward.

Chill spot, good brew, and the specials started at 2:00, we walked in around 1:40 - I appreciate that he let me know if he entered my order before 2:00 I wouldn't get the discounted price. Nice customer service.

We have been here a handful of times now, and it's been great! Ivan is suuuuuper nice and such a great bar tender!If you get the chance, just chit chat with him! He's been working here for a long time.I like that it's a local spot to chill and eat and watch sports! Their beers are good and the happy hour is FANTASTIC! Food is delicious and we always try something new every time. Again, HAPPY HOUR is worth it!