II Supremo

First visit: Pizza was sold out after the One Bite review hit the web so went with some garlic knots and pasta. I wouldn't say that I settled for it either because the flavors are off the charts and the pasta fresh and made in house. Second visit: Finally sunk my teeth into a cheese pizza and was it worth the wait. Try to pre-order online as early in the day as possible. They are working on getting another oven to increase production capacity so be patient. With the new publicity, they are firing on all cylinders and still putting out good, flavorful, quality food. I imagine with the new oven and more staff, they will be able to keep up with the demand. I love the retro style of the dining room with a small arcade for kids and kids-at-heart. And makes me wish I still lived down the street from this neighborhood pizza joint. Definitely will be back...this Saturday in fact.

Finally we're able to try this place after weeks of anticipation. I don't love their pop up approach so much since for pizza it's usually a day of decision. That being said, my BF ate his whole cheese pizza because he loved it so much so perhaps it was worth the wait. I got the spicy Steve (I think this is the name) with jalapeño and hot honey. I couldn't taste the honey a ton but overall it was still good. Love the amount of bubbles in the crust. Will definitely get pizza from here again!

I usually like a basic pepperoni but the jalapeños and hot honey adds a nice touch. These pizzas sell out fast and are only available certain days of the week. The service through the app was great. They actually texted me and told me I could pick up earlier if I wanted with my preorder arranged time. I did not see inside the restaurant.

Pizza and pasta were amazing, specifically the house made pasta, perfectly al dente. Wonderful experience overall.

Delicious pizza! My favorite in Metairie! I love being able to call in now and service is always great. Our go to is the spicy Steve with basil pistachio ranch!

Excellent pizza and pasta! Roberta is my favorite with sausage, jalapeno, bell pepper, whipped ricotta, and hot honey. The crust is the best with just the right amount of chew. I also was never a pizza dipper until I tried their basil pistachio and black garlic + miso dips. Love that we can eat in now. The booths and nintendo games bring back those 80s pizza join vibes! Great ambiance and very friendly service! For pasta - the Alla Vodka is a shoe-in!

The red sauce on the pizza and garlic knots were off. And the garlic knots were drowning in oil inside garlic butter. Not my preferred pizza.

Best Pizza and Handmade Pasta in the Greater New Orleans Area!! Absolutely delicious food and very kind staff.

Best pizza in NOLA. Cool little dinning room with friendly service. Pizza is all about the dough and sauce and they nailed it.

This review is purely for their pasta... specifically the fact that you can purchase their fresh pasta raw. Oh my god. I think you guys ruined grocery store pasta for me forever. Thank you for offering this and please keep it going!!