Dimartino's Famous New Orleans Muffulettas

This was our first time to this tucked away restaurant off the beaten path. Was impressed by the selection of daily specials. Service was friendly and polite. Ambience was spot on not over or under done had the right balance of decor to give a warm dining experience. This establishment was super clean. We truly enjoyed our dinner and the experience of fine dining at a reasonable price. We even met the owner Mr. Pete a fine gentleman who really caters to his customers. Mr. Pete thank you for the great experience of dining at your restaurant.

I love this place. Been coming to DiMartinos for decades whenever I am visiting NOLA. This week I had the roast beef po boy combo (fully Dressed) with potato salad and gumbo. So delightful as roast beef had just the right amount of gravy to be just a bit messy but fully coated the tender beef. Potato salad like my momma used to make and the gumbo was tasty. I'm coming back for my very favorite, the Muffuletta!!!! Most of the wonderful staff have been here for years so you know that says a lot about DiMartino's.

It looked closed from the lot, but inside was nicely decorated restaurant. I decided on a 5" combo to try the gumbo and the salad. The po boy was about 3" long, a few bites worth. But it was very good, thin crispy bread- had sesame seed - and chewy. Roast beef was good with enough gravy thinly sliced meat. Gumbo was also good with plenty of shrimp and crab claw, but felt few more hours simmering would make it better. Potato salad was also satisfactory with good balance of egg yolk and dill taste. All great except for the portions, it was much to be desired.

Used Uber to get a buy one get one free roast beef sandwich. I understand about the weather, but if you can't deliver what you normally do, then you should let the customer know. $31 for mediocre sandwiches is not buy one get one free. I'm so disappointed.

What a great little place. A locals spot for sure but if you're looking for a little hidden gem, this is one. Take the ride and have a dressed roast beef po'boy. Take extra napkins to the table. The service was friendly and happy. A true NO style.

Here's the updated menu Post-CovidPhoto was taken on 8/23/2023Don't get fooled like me looking at their old menu pricing.

I write this with tears in my eyes and a regretfully fast changing pallet, knowing I just had the best poboy and gumbo since moving to New Orleans mid 1995. LET ME TELL YOU, this shit saved my life. I was gonna end it all (unless the West Bank did it first). Im so happy. The sky is blue, the grass is green, and my pants are creamed knowing that this restaurant exists. Honestly, if you only have one meal left in New Orleans, and this restaurant isn't it, you're 100% an Atlanta Falcons fan. Do yourself a favor, and PLEASE check this place out. My only regret, is not bringing a change of pants. Yours truly,Big dick DaveP.s. the tiramisu melts in your mouth and is reminiscent of a first kiss.

Didn't try the muffalettas :( however, the other food here is great, and the serving sizes are plenty for the price! Beef roast poor boy combo, comes w/ half a poboy, potato salad, and gumbo. Loved everything! There is so much flavor and the potato salad was a good contrast to the sandwichEggplant sticks: better than I thought they were going to be. Fried yet almost refreshing? Comes w/ a marinara sauce that complements the eggplant wellThe atmosphere of the restaurant is very cute and relaxed, they were playing piano versions of ABBA :)

The best place to eat a Muffaleta in town! Delicious potatoes salad. Terrytown location is nice and clean with professional staff.

Always on point !! Why they discontinued the shrimp potato salad !! Muffuletta always a favorite! it's in my top 5 in the city! eggplant parmigiana is great also!