Banana Foster
Shrimp scampi with angel hair pasta
Lemon drop martini
Filet Mignon*
Main Dining
a view of the bar
Cozy fireplace
Entrance
Secondary dining area
The Mill Room
Main dining room fireplace
drink
Dining room
Main Dining
50 oz. Tomahawk Ribeye
Mahi Mahi with Mac & Cheese
Bar area
Upstairs parlor
Patio seating
Menu
Fresh water for dogs on the patio!
interior
David G.
Aug 24, 2024
Exceptional service and outstanding menu choices not to mention the atmosphere was perfect.Being in a wheelchair presented a small challenge but does not take from the experience
Read MoreLaura M.
Jun 17, 2024
Certainly the best steakhouse in Randolph County. The restaurant has high back booths and it's nice to feel the privacy they provide. The service was good, the waitress seemed knowledgeable about the menu choices and drinks but never brought the bread. The Mahi Mahi had a hollandaise sauce which was slightly bland but the fish itself was good. The Shrimp Scampi and Steak tasted great. However the steak was served without any frills and the plating looked basic, the Mahi Mahi did also. The Banana Foster was really a nice ending and enough to share! The Lemon drop Martini was yummy, totally recommend! The bill was slightly under $150 for 3 people. Honestly Hamilton's is doing a lot right, it's a nice restaurant with a calm atmosphere.
Read MoreTravis S.
Jul 23, 2024
My wife and I tried Hamilton's steakhouse because I wanted to try the Beef Wellington. It was delicious! Just make sure you call ahead to reserve one. The Mac n cheese was also very good. Can't wait to go back!
Read MoreLena L.
Aug 22, 2023
Absolutely loved this place. Happened upon it because it was the right distance for a stop on our road trip and was dog friendly. They weren't too busy for lunch outside given it was 90+ degrees out so we had the whole patio (which is fenced) and the dogs were able to just chillax, they even brought us a dog bowl and there is a spicket right there!The food was just as good as the hospitality and they had an amazing lunch special of a 1/2 sandwich and 1/2 salad which we each got in some combination. The Caesar salad was tasty and perfectly dressed. My French dip was delicious as was my husbands reuban and daughters BLT. I would definitely stop again if I find myself nearby.
Read MoreAlissa V.
May 31, 2024
I got the NY strip with bacon gooda mac and cheese, and a Cesar salad. Well the steak tasted great, but 40% was fat, the Mac and cheese has no flavor except the bacon. But the Cesar salad with dressing was great. Service was great, nice workers. But food was okay. The restaurant is beautiful and have lovely music.
Read MoreJim K.
Aug 17, 2023
The best steakhouses are the locally owned ones and don't find locally owned steakhouses much anymore. Hamilton's is a throwback to those great local steakhouses. They are known for their 50 oz. Tomahawk Ribeye, though I've never known anyone to actually order one. I had their 12 oz Ribeye and it was great for me. Everyone loved their steaks which were cooked perfectly. The sides are rather amazing as well. I especially recommend the homemade mashed potatoes and gravy although the Bacon, Gouda, Macaroni and Cheese was pretty awesome as well. You have to save room for dessert! Seriously, get the Bananas Foster. The four of us shared one and it capped off a great dinner.The service is excellent and the prices are very reasonable, especially given the quality.
Read MoreDarius S.
Jan 28, 2024
I tried this place a few uears ago. I ordered a burger and my wife ordered the stuffed salmon. The food was good and the atmosphere was nice. Make sure you arrive early before closing because they didn't offer us any bread.
Read MoreTonya C.
Mar 19, 2023
The ambiance is definitely a steakhouse vibe. It's very cute outside with the blooming flower pots.Inside is mostly a dark brown wood. There's a nice fireplace in the back of one of he dining rooms. The booths are high back, so that gives each table a nice amount of privacy.The menu has a lot of nice choices. Since I was there for lunch, I only ordered from that menu.Our waitress was very helpful and personable. We never had to ask for anything.I ordered the half sandwich and potato soup special and my friend ordered the tomato bisque soup and wedge salad. It was a hard choice for the soups because we both like each type offered. We tasted the other's before trying our own. Mine was the best!!The tomato bisque flavor was good, but it was not hot as you'd expect a soup to be. The shaved parmesan NEVER melted. That's not normal for a "hot soup". My potato soup was very hot and delicious.I chose the half chicken-a-plao with chips. It was wonderful!!!!From this experience, I gave them 4 stars because of the cool soup.I would return again if in the area.
Read MoreJackie E.
Jan 6, 2024
Food is delicious Love sitting near the fireplace and enjoying the Bananas Foster after a nice steak
Read MoreMike P.
Aug 10, 2024
My second time there and the steak does not disappoint. If your order bananas foster make sure you have some help eating it.
Read More