Edgewater Inn

I've been to Edgewater in a couple of times never sat down and had a full meal inside but several times eating appetizers having some beers and taking pizza to go always great company and good quality

It's a bummer to see this local business engaging in price gouging via fees. We paid $50 for a pepperoni pizza and small salad due to both takeout fees and auto gratuity, which were not disclosed and we tipped on top. I love our community and supporting local, but not when I'm being taken advantage of. Pizza is decent, salads are not.

Wow, what a total hidden gem. How have I lived a mile and 1/2 from this place and never been? Super old school cool decor and building. Reminded me of some of my favorite neighborhood bars back in Chicago. Delicious pizza. Super friendly and attentive service. Cozy and friendly vibes all around. And so affordable. Can't wait to go back!

Cold schooner of beer, delicious pizza, great service surrounded by locals? Yes please! I have been here several times since the new owners took over. The decor is pretty much the same, the food vastly improved and the vibe is chill. Try the caprese appetizer or salad. The pizza is so good!!! You won't be disappointed.

Oof. Had high hopes with the ownership change. It was easy to get in on a Saturday night and service was fine but the pizza was a miss. We got the garlic cheese bread to start - which was good. Crusty and a little gooey salty with some sweetness. We got a large howdy pizza to share between 2 people. Thought we would be able to sub the olives for red onions and got a $2 charge. Okay whatever. The sauce is so bland, the pizza is way too floppy for all the ingredients on it. We added all the crushed red pepper Parmesan and ranch ($0.75) to the pizza. The ranch was delicious but the pizza was seriously lacking in flavor and quality. Not sure if it was an off day or what. I was hoping to love the place since we live right around the corner!

Got to love a place that has a small town charm outside the big city. Pizza is fresh and delicious. Beer tastes awesome when it comes in a schooner. Classic establishment!

It's unfortunate that it's not the same Edgewater pizza I remember... we were in the area so I decided to bring my fiancé in because I talk about it all the time The service was awful, halfway through dinner we realized it's because the two waitresses were too busy taking shots instead of checking on their tables Food was decent, not great like it was, but I hope you like balsamic because they put it on EVERYTHING We probably will not be backSad!

The food has improved 200 percent since new ownership!! Ordered the Howdy pizza and Beet Salad. Excellent.Plus they now have outdoor tables, which are great for these pleasant summer evenings.

AMAZING NOW!! Congrats to local 46 for the new acquisition. Wonderful new menu and expanded space. Wish you had ditched the 46 theme and called it local 25 or whatever since you're now on 25th st.

We have loved this place for years. However, was truly devastated when they changed the ingredients on the Howdy Special pizza. Any chance you could go back to the old recipe- please??!!