Mermaids Bakery
Mermaids Bakery
Cupcakes by Mermaids
a dozen cupcakes with white frosting and red sprinkles
Variety 2 dozen
the front of the building
Custom Funfetti Cake - $135
Carrot cake had to order a dozen to get this flavor
food
Chocolate mousse cake :)
outside
Cupcakes Cookies
Cupcakes by Mermaids
Counter
Neapolitan cake!!
food
food
Best Graduation Cake Ever
Strawberry Cheesecake Cupcake
Assorted cupcakes!
food
Half sheet of carrot cake
Counter
Coraline 'Welcome Home' cake
Welcome Home!
They make cakes too
ReviewHaiku F.
Aug 5, 2024
Ordered a dozen For a party for pickup Seamless and tasty**ordered chocolate sea salt caramel from nyc, picked them up in Denver, all was good!
Read More
Brad B.
Dec 21, 2023
I ordered 3 dozen cupcakes and 3 dozen cookies for my office Christmas party and everyone LOVED them!!I really liked the red velvet cupcake and the Carmel cookies. Can't wait until we can order for our next event :)
Read More
Aurelia R.
May 12, 2024
I had an absolutely wonderful experience with Mermaid Bakery for my birthday celebration! They baked a half sheet of carrot cake that was truly the highlight of the event. The cake was moist, perfectly spiced, and the cream cheese frosting was divine. My husband ordered this for my doctoral celebration, and I couldn't have been more pleased with how it turned out. The staff at Mermaid Bakery were incredibly accommodating and made sure everything was perfect for our special day. Their attention to detail and exceptional customer service really stood out. Highly recommend them for anyone looking for quality and care in their baked goods!
Read More
Anrana S.
Nov 18, 2023
I was looking for something sweet after lunch so stopped in at mermaids. I can't eat chocolate - it's a migraine trigger. Their selection of non-chocolate cupcakes was pitiful. Strawberry cheesecake or vanilla salted caramel. I went with strawberry cheesecake. The strawberry on this cupcake looked like it was a couple days old. Dry and leathery. There was no strawberry flavor. The cupcake was dry. Overall a sad excuse for $5
Read More
K S.
May 8, 2024
Bought a cake (and with the tip) for $194 for a big event. The name on the cake was misspelled. Really, really embarrassing. And very expensive mistake. While this person has an unusual name, Mermaids could have called or emailed to confirm. In fact, I was there for a 9 am pick-up (and it wasn't ready even though I confirmed). They could have asked about the name or had me look at it. They did not and I didn't think to ask because I had to wait for the cake and was then running late to the event.I won't be ordering here again- no matter how good the cake is.
Read More
Christina S.
Aug 13, 2023
My experience with Mermaids bakery was pretty lackluster to be honest. I called a week in advance to order Red Velvet cupcakes for my husbands birthday as they are his favorite. I requested they say happy birthday and they assured me they would look like birthday cupcakes and say my desired phrase. Well I pick up the cupcakes and they don't say anything special, they don't look like birthday cupcakes, I mean they honestly look like I made them myself at home. I was hoping at this point that they would at least taste phenomenal, but they were average at best. I honestly felt like I should have just bought cupcakes from King Soopers because they would have tasted and looked the same and probably been about $45 cheaper lol I was hoping Mermaids would be great and I could use them for our son's first birthday smash cake but I have no desire to order from here again. And a side note; they somewhat hassle you about your pickup time. My pickup time was 12:30 on Saturday and I got a text as 12, and a call at 12:22 to remind me that they close at 1pm. I arrived at 12:24 (6 min early) to get them so I didn't really appreciate being harangued when I wasn't even late. I would recommend to the business owner to at least wait until someone is like 5 minute late to start calling.
Read More
Ilana S.
May 28, 2023
Delicious cupcakes!! Not only are the cupcakes beautiful aesthetically, the taste is spot on! The best part is they're not too sweet!! They also freeze and defrost really well! To help you prepare for your visit, I'll say the location isn't ideal for picking up unless you're already downtown. I so so luckily got a street spot right outside. Just be prepared to look for a parking spot downtown which is never fun.
Read More
Erica S.
Dec 15, 2023
This cake was amazing! It was super moist and my family from Kansas City loved it! The icing is whipped and has a very light, fulfilling texture.
Read More
Jeremy T.
Mar 22, 2024
3.7 star average for this place is not remotely accurate. I'm not really in to sweets but this place is fantastic. I frequently bought mermaid cupcakes for my team for birthdays etc, never had a bad experience. When you walk in it smells so amazing, they should bottle the air and sell it.
Read More
Adrian G.
Oct 7, 2024
This cake truthfully came straight out of a dream. The cake was perfect in every way possible. Including the flavor and moisture. 10/10 Service communication was perfect and very engaging. Ambiance was 10/10. Do it.
Read More
