City Pizza
City Pizza
Pepperoni
Margherita and sausage slices; about $3.50/slice (February 2024)
"Waffle fries"
Cheese Pizza
Margharita Pizza
a menu for a pizza restaurant
Buffalo Chicken
White pizza with spinach
Sausage pizza
menu
menu
menu
Jessica W.
Apr 19, 2024
City Pizza is conveniently located in Old City on 3rd Street near CVS. The staff is really nice. Their pizza slices are super affordable, at about $3/slice. I opt for the Margherita almost every time. They also have delicious cookies and a fridge full of affordable bevvies (think Jarritos and $1 bottles of water...hard to find that kind of deal in Old City). If you're a local or a tourist looking for a quick bite under $10/person, def stop in for some City Pizza. They also have a fun mural of pizza wings, so remember to snap a photo and tag them on socials (and upload the pic to Yelp!).
Read More
Eli T.
Jun 10, 2023
Amazing margarita pizza, I'm from Chicago and this has to be some of the best pizza I've had. Great service, great prices, great food what more can you ask for!
Read More
Yasser H.
Jul 21, 2022
We stopped here for a quick bite but regretted it. We ordered a cheese pizza and waffle fries. To this date I cannot figure out, what the pizza was. Is this how phila style pizza is? With sauce splattered All over the pizza and cheese that looks like it has been scraped off?? So disappointing. The pizza looks like a crayon/coloring photo of a pre K elementary or younger kiddo that's starting to learn how to draw and color. The pizza itself had no taste whatsoever. The fries were listed as "waffle fries on menu@. I'm thinking it would be something like chick fil-a but these were what we call crinkle fries. They Probably came off a bagged bag as I could still taste the freezer burn taste that lingers onto food. Plus they were put in the oven, so weren't properly fried but rather baked. Will not be back here ever.
Read More
Cindy M.
Jun 14, 2023
This is a nice neighborhood place. It's open late and the employees are super nice. The pizza was not bad. I am a plain cheese pizza girl and that is what I am reviewing. The pizza again was not bad, but not as good as I hoped. It was average. But give it a try, support your local independent business and you may find for you it's delicious.
Read More
Ade B.
Nov 19, 2022
I decided to try the slices here for lunch on a work from home day. This place is now known as Olde City Pizza, not to be confused with the other pizza spot nearby with a similar name. I kept it simple, ordering two slices of pepperoni pizza. The slices were big with plenty of pepperoni. I was pleasantly surprised when I lifted up a slice to see that the crust had no flop. The crust is firm and crispy. The pizza tastes very good but not quite at the level of the very best pizza. But for a quick slice of pizza, it's as good as it gets in Old City.
Read More
Josh L.
Nov 9, 2023
There is an advertised special, two slices of any pie and a drink for $10. The only thing special about it is nothing. That seems like a regular price for this pizza. Everything about it is best defined as, nothing special. The specialty pie was pretty good, almost four stars, but the vegetable slice right next to BBQ Chicken, and there was spillover that spoiled it. I can't fathom who thought that was a good idea. The restaurant is not overall well kept, but you won't starve is my best summary. Apparently, you shouldn't confuse this is Old City Pizza as there is some drama surrounding it.
Read More
Eric T.
Apr 14, 2022
Had a good experience then had a poor experience. Food was good. Prices are cheap. The poor experience: ordered food at 1pm. I asked for Margherita pizza and chicken fingers from the menu. The woman on the phone said, "chicken cheesesteak?" I said no, chicken fingers. She said there were none, but then allowed me to order up to 10 when I said I have the menu from their store in front of me. (Menu says says it comes in one size: 3 with a sauce). I asked for honey mustard sauce. She said "mustard?" I said no, honey mustard. Anyway, I have someone go pick it up for me 25 minutes later. When she gets there I get messaged that and the woman at Pizzarama was being rude and said "we don't have chicken fingers" and "we don't have whole pizzas, only by slice." So, they didn't bother to make the order or tell me it was canceled. I don't understand.
Read More
Amanda H.
Jun 27, 2023
We were staying in the building next door to City Pizza. The service was fast and friendly. The food was good. Loved the chew of the crust. We ordered a medium pie which easily made 4 servings and a Caesar salad. There was seating inside as well as bistro tables outside.
Read More
Art S.
Jul 31, 2022
Happy to see a pizza shop back in the neighborhood. Even better since their pizza is really good! The pizza crust is a perfect thickness, the sauce is nice and flavorful and it's topped off with the right amount of cheese. Definitely recommend if you're looking for a great pizza in Phila.!
Read More
Esther H.
Jun 14, 2024
They were awesome in communicating and taking care of a big order and delivering on time!
Read More
