Carlo’s Pizza

Best NY/NJ style pizza in Atl, hands down. Being from New York, we know our pizza and these guys are legit. Can't find a crust even close to theirs anywhere I've been in the southeast...The tiramisu is also very authentic. Light and flavorful.

Saw the review on barstool sports and had to order some. Possibly the best frozen pizza i have ever had, tasted like i was eating it there even tho im sure that is even better. Sauce and cheese are delicous and the crust is incredible.

This is real Jersey shore pizza!! Literally, the owner's father had a pizza joint Wildwood and they use their original ingredients and father's recipe!! As a Jersey kid I didn't expect the best pizza In Atlanta.. come to see Atlanta is so diverse it even include delicious Jersey pizza. It's in a little square- market.Support real entrepreneurs like these four young brothers. We should all learn about working in collaboration and teamwork from them.

One of the better plain slices I've had just over priced I was really expecting the older place, it possible was sold or it's subleased to who ever thinks Pizza in a cheap easy sale. The previous please had 3-4 types of pizzas. This is just "new jersey style" pizza! Health department says A-

Just have to say Carlos was MEH good crust but the good ended there because the sauce and cheese were bland tasted like a whole lotta nothing good in a pinch tho service was good

The absolute BEST!!! Their meatball subs, pizza, wings !! Anything you order is Amazing. Then you have the Best service you can ask for, these guys aim to please!!! You won't be disappointed!

Best NYC pizza in the city bar none. Crispy crust, high quality olive oil and cheese baked perfectly. Owner is beyond nice and it's clear he is passionate about his work. This pizza is on par with what I had growing up in Boston. Just wish they would open in Grant Park...:)

This is the best pizza spot in ATL. I'm from up north and there are good neapolitan places in atlanta to get fancy pizza if that's your thing. But if you want a really good slice, you know the kind ya get in NYC or Jersey. This is the place you wanna come to.

Not your typical sit down pizza spot, but the testimony of any family legacy like this pizzeria has, says volumes about the founder. Families that stick to traditional core values and original recipes are a staple you can count on. The food is well prepared before your eyes and taste amazing! The family that runs the shop are kind and cordial. They make it a pleasure to be served as well as converse with you about their little slice of life. You won't be disappointed by their recipe. Your belly will definitely thank you!

I was expecting like an amazing addicting sauce or something. Got the frozen pizza in, it's ok at best! Not sure what Dave is talking about on this one.