Brothers of New York Pizza
Brothers of New York Pizza
Cheesecake
Half NY Supreme Pizza half cheese
customers at the counter
customers at the bar
double doors with graffiti
customers working in a restaurant
Menu as of May 2024
View from their back patio over the water
Cheese slices
Half Buffalo Chicken Pizza Half Cheese Pizza Pie
a man in the kitchen
Awful, way over cooked, dry, hard chicken
Brothers Salad
chicken bacon ranch
interior
Garden Salad
NY Supreme Pizza
menu
Menu
menu
menu
Menu
pizza, food
Just like being home waiting for the subway
Evan F.
Jun 11, 2024
Very good American-Italian food!Extremely friendly service and fair price $ Chill NY & lowkey ambianceReally beautiful outdoor seating area nearby water
Read More
Sarah K.
May 30, 2024
Ordered the NY supreme under gourmet pizza ($29.95 for a large). Fresh ingredients and a nice cheese pull when you take a bite while it's hot and fresh. The dough had a good thickness.A family friendly vibe with booth seating. Quick service on a weekday night. Patio seating outdoors as well.
Read More
Dana V.
Apr 30, 2024
We are from New York and Brothers of New York Pizza is very close to the pizza we grew up with. We have ordered their plain large pie, and it's really good and consistent every time we order. We aren't in this area of Cary often but when we are, we get pizza from here. I also wanted to point out a 1-star review by "Rosalind A." Note that this Yelp user should be flagged. I looked at her profile, and she had just left 92 consecutive 1-star reviews for small businesses in the area. This destroys businesses, and it's not fair for our local restaurants to be treated this way. Report and flag this user to Yelp.
Read More
Virginia B.
Aug 19, 2023
An impulse decision on the way to Publix brought me here for a late lunch. Not much seating inside but the have outdoor seating too. Walk up and give your order, no table service. Half of the small place is set up like a bar, the other part some booths. They have a special for $9, two cheese slices and a drink so because it was my first time here, thought I would start with the basics. There's cheese, garlic, oregano and red pepper on the table and I sure am glad. I added a lot of garlic and oregano and still found this pizza lacking flavor. The crust was ok, but the sauce and cheese was just not up to the quality I get at other places. I will not return.
Read More
Remy R.
Jul 20, 2024
Brothers of NY Pizza is a rare find here in NC. Truly authentic NY pizza. They are not just trying to capitalize on the "NY Pizza" name. All of the food created here is 100% on the mark. In addition to the great food, customer service is top notch. The environment is fun and nostalgic for anyone from NY as the restaurant is decorated with familiar NY items. Prices are absolutely reasonable, and the Garlic Knots are chef's kiss! This is it friends, travel if you need to, this is what you have been looking for. You won't be disappointed.
Read More
Michelle G.
Dec 14, 2023
I've been searching for an amazing buffalo chicken pizza and this by far has been the best I've found in the area! I've seen most places sprinkle plain chicken on top of regular cheese pizza with a drizzle of hot sauce which is disappointing, so I'm happy this place got it right.
Read More
Lane G.
Sep 29, 2023
Food is always hot and fresh. Employees are nice, just a tad expensive but great overall.
Read More
Jeff F.
Jul 28, 2022
Back home in Pennsylvania we had a local chain of pizza restaurants called Brothers pizza, so I had high hopes that maybe, just maybe this place would have legit tasting New York style pizza. They have a special for lunch, two slices and a drink for $7.99. the pizza certainly looks the part, but it was very bland, I had to dump half the container of Parmesan cheese on it to give it any sort of flavor. Maybe I should have gotten some toppings on it but I feel a good indicator of good pizza is how it tastes with nothing on it. And the plain pizza here is exactly that, plain!
Read More
Catherine W.
Oct 13, 2024
found a hair in my boneless wings, mozzarellas sticks weren't cooked, and terrible, fries were bad too. cost 28 for food I had to throw out. I could have gone to public's and bought frozen.
Read More
Jordan B.
Jul 26, 2024
The Customer service here is outstanding, makes me want to put an application in here to work these awesome group of people, food was great I was wanting a homestyle pizza parlor absolute overall great place to eat prices are very reasonable! Can't wait to come back!
Read More
