Buffalo Chicken Slice
Hand comparison
Double Cheese Burger with French Fries!
Slice of pepperoni pizza
Haiwaiian pizza slice
Chicken wing plate with fries and onion rings
a pizza in a box
Second half of the large Italian sub. Soft bread
interior
interior
Boneless buffalo chicken tenders So good even without sauce
Fenway calzone withe sausage and sauté mushrooms peppers and onions
Pasta (fettuccine) Alfredo with broccoli and chicken breast
Large chicken parm sub
menu
Cheesy garlic bread
pasta dish, pasta, food
pizza, food
Large margarita pie
Large margarita pizza $18
food, pizza
Cheese slice $3.25
pizza, food
The Honey (Pepperoni, jalapeño and honey)
Jake A.
May 31, 2024
I've now visited Papa's pizza twice, both times to grab some slices from the Too Good to Go app. The restaurant is a cozy hole in the wall near Brigham Circle, but it does have a small amount of seating available.The cashier/server was pleasant and quick, and he grabbed three still warm slices of pizza to give me on my way out. I had a cheese slice and a veggie slice. Both slices had good flavor, but they were slightly more greasy than I expected. They could have used a bit more time in the oven to crisp up.Overall, though, I found this place a pleasant place to eat and a good deal for a night time snack. I'd definitely visit here again and recommend it if you happen to be in the area. I'll be sure to try something besides pizza the next time I visit.
Read MoreAndrea D.
Aug 17, 2023
Today I decided to get a slice here due to good reviews and it was tasty! I ordered the Buffalo Chicken & it was good and it had a mild spicy taste. My only suggestion would be to add some more scallions. That aside it was still delicious! I plan on returning to try more!
Read MoreAshley J.
Aug 20, 2023
Usually not too many people here, so service is super quick especially if you're just looking for a slice. I love their Buffalo Chicken slice and Chicken Bacon Ranch, always hits the spot and I've gone 4+ times in the past few weeks. Obviously super casual atmosphere, good for a small group or eating by yourself. The slices are so big and super cheap. Specialty slices (aka not cheese or pepperoni) are $4.55 with tax currently. Right next to the green line, great convenient location. They also sell sandwiches, wings, and desserts (cake slices, tiramisu)!
Read MoreYaritza D.
Dec 1, 2023
I will never order from this place again. They tried charging me for full price for a small box of fries that were not full to the top, when I inquired about it to the manager, he said that's how they come, meaning they're overcharging customers and playing in our faces. Staff is rude
Read MoreJustin L.
Sep 21, 2022
I'm not a huge fan for pizza, but this place serves the best pizza I've ever had! For just under $5 you can get a nice big thin slice of pizza that is so good you want seconds! My favorite pizza here is the chicken bacon ranch because it's unique and it's a popular choice!The chicken wings & chicken Alfredo here is pretty yummy too, but you should probably make a phone call because you can be stuck waiting 15-20 minutes for your order there
Read MoreNick N.
Sep 22, 2021
Staff was really friendly and fast! This was my first time here, but definitely won't be my last. They've got a whole menu of specialty pizzas, calzones, wings, fries, etc. I was in a rush so grabbed a slice of pepperoni and Hawaiian. The individual slices are HUGE. Bigger than my head, and only costs $3.50 for single toppings and $4.00 for specialty slices. If you go for plain cheese it's $3.00 a slice. The only reason I knocked off 1 star is because they wasn't as much pepperoni or ham + pineapple as I would've liked, but it definitely hit the spot! Looking forward to ordering a calzone and their meat lovers pizza next time.
Read MoreShia G.
Jun 20, 2021
Buffalo Ranch and Broccoli Ricotta pizza slices were so good! Hot and fresh. They are open later than most places and the lady that gave me my order was friendly.
Read MoreRebecca R.
Jan 8, 2020
Super Satisfied!!Our first time here and we can't believe we have been missing out on such great food!!We ordered the Chicken Gyro plate, pizza and a steak and cheese...Sooo perfectly delish!! Not greasy and great flavor.Can't wait to go back!
Read MoreJonathan K.
Sep 17, 2024
I worked in the Longwood area for almost two years, and it took me until my last week there to finally try Papa's Pizza. Why I waited so long? I have no idea, but I seriously regret not checking it out sooner. I ordered the Buffalo chicken pizza, and it was incredible--classic New York-style with a thin, crispy crust. The slices were massive, but honestly, I could have gone for a second because one just didn't feel like enough!The service was fast and efficient. I picked my slice, they heated it up, and in no time, I was enjoying my meal. The place has a few tables, but one group had taken all the chairs, so my coworkers and I ended up standing at a table. No big deal--it was still worth it.I'll definitely make a point to swing by whenever I'm in the area again.
Read MoreLove Y.
May 2, 2023
Best pizza best ingredients wow keep the good work very good people 5 Stars BBQ Chicken In love
Read More