Antico Pizza Tucker

Classic Margarita PizzaDiavola PizzaHemphill Location..Lasagna PizzaNeapolitan PizzaSan GenaroSan GenaroSan Genaro!!!Tiramisu looks good White Pie too

I was excited to try this place out because of all the good reviews, but honestly, I was disappointed. The pizzas are a little pricey but are huge and match the price. They have a kind of small menu, and it isn't super customizable, but if you like simple choices, it is a good choice. I chose a Margherita pizza, which is a classic flavor, and I was really disappointed with how it turned out. It wasn't at all how I expected a Margherita pizza to be. It was more of a cheese pizza with basil on top and wasn't sauced enough to be a margherita. It was also super greasy and had a ton of oil. The person I was sharing it with was okay with it but just didn't meet my expectations. My table also had the Diavola, and liked that one; it definitely had some spice to it. The service was fine, and the pizza came out relatively quickly. I probably won't come back; with so few choices, I feel like each one needs to be really good, and I wasn't impressed enough to come back.

Wish I took note of which pizzas we ordered but honestly, all were amazing! The margherita was definitely my favorite! Simple but packed with flavor. I also love the toppings bar because the dried chilis and garlic+ olive oil was good. All the pizzas were flavorful and delicious. The pizza also came out pretty quick!

If you love thin sliced pizza, this is the spot. Great for family, date, lunch, networking spot. Located in new plaza in the smoke rise area. Pizza, calzones, salad, dessert, alcohol, juice. The best part is the addition self serve. Fresh garlic, pepper, oil the spicy oil was amazing. Very pleasant staff.

This pizza was absolutely delicious! Great serving size. Amazing customer service and best of all fresh ingredients. They gained a returning customer for sure!

This pizza is horrible. I am not sure what I was expecting but it's tasteless, big, and thin for no reason. The texture is weird too. It was giving Your Pie but not really, your pie is good. It seemed dirty in there as well. They only serve large full size pizzas. You cannot buy a slice. I like this complex, lots of businesses around I remember when it was in development, and I took this day to try it, it was a $23 fail. I wouldn't recommend. Countless pizza places that are cheaper and taste better.

Yuck. Lasagna pissa. Yuck. Didn't taste fresh, smelled bad tasted like it smelled. Bad. House salad a joke. Yuck. Do yourself a favor and walk to the Publix, get a frozen red baron, tombstone whatever, save $20 and get more flavor. Yuck. That place won't make it another year

Maybe I'm old... no my 35 year old daughter had the same opinion.Or Maybe I miss Everybody's in Decatur ( back when they had Pabst Dark draught and the high back booths and ALL fresh ingredients)Or Maybe I'm just too pedestrian in my pizza needs....Nah!The pizza is great, best thin crust EVER!Our issue was the fixed, and I mean inflexibly fixed, toppings:My daughter had her 3 yo with us and granddaughter loves pepperoni.Cool, one pepperoni pizza please. My daughter asked can we add mushrooms?Ans: No, it's one topping. Daughter stifles a WT_ "I can't add mushrooms for the upcharge"? "No. It's a one add on for $4 only pizza." paraphrased but the delivery of that info was deadpan, like a robot could have done it.So I guess I am saying I have no apology for our very polite incredulity. The pizza though was excellent, daughter & I never had better crust. the condiment bar was nice. I had water ( free, cooled with ice in the dispenser but no ice for cup available)I've been to THE Chicago & NY pizza places... it's not like I prefer pizza hut folksIn summary, maybe we aren't fancy enough, not Neapolitan aficionados - I mean I don't care for Neapolitan Ice Cream either.I asked the daughter, will we come back? Yeah maybe, but can we do Mellow Mushroom NEXT time? My answer, No problem.Well the 3yr old Loved the pepperoni - she had a blast and the adjoing table thought she was adorable!!! Nice clean, modern atmosphere

Everyone raves about the pizza. I mean, it's the fabled Antico establishment, serving pizza with ingredients that were imported directly from Italy and stacked in the store-room by Papal adherents dressed in crimson robes. Or maybe at least, some dude named Sean. The place is packed. Tables are hard to come by. And the accoutrements are tucked away not far from the counter behind the crowded tables. And people look at you funny when you scan the room looking for a vacancy. Like they're the Cathartidae enjoying their meal wondering just where you (the Gypaetinae) came from and if you're going to chase them away. The pizza is good. Maybe the charm of all things Antico have worn off for me. But I wasn't as floored as I was by the original Antico experience. Something was different--I don't know what. I deferred to my wife, as this was her first-time Antico:Me: What do you think?Her: It's good.Me: You like it?Her: Yeah.Me: Good enough for a return visit?Her: Yes, I think so. It's different enough from the "standard" pizza we get at...

Have you ever been so hungry that you forget to snap a picture like you originally had planned? I'm guilty! I ordered a pizza online and headed out to pick it up. It was ready when I arrived and the employee who helped me greeted me immediately my arrival and handed me the huge pizza box. I took it home and started eating right away. I was amazing! The pizza was fresh and smelled amazing. Each bite was even more delicious. Glad this location is closer to me because I used to drive to Alpharetta for this amazing pizza. I definitely will returns plan to eat there next time.