Anna Maria's Pizzeria
Anna Maria's Pizzeria
the entrance to the restaurant
The half-eaten slice of Anna Maria's pizza and the roach it harbored, 12/1/2013. Avoid this restaurant!
A pepperoni calzone with ricotta and mozzarella cheese fresh out of the oven.
Mushroom and spinach slice
Roma pizza and another vegetarian type (I forget the name!)
A fantastic vegetarian slice loaded with good veggies
Katie P.
Oct 3, 2022
Stopped in after a football game at about 8:30pm. It was not very busy, which we found surprising. The pizza was good though. Came out pretty quick and we all enjoyed it!
Read More
Glenn G.
Feb 3, 2020
Stopped in with a large group after a UNC basketball game. You order at the counter and they'll bring the food to your table. Besides pizza, it looks like they have calzones, strombolis and pasta dishes. The food was decent and this seems like a reliable pizza joint but if you're looking for more upscale pizza, Chapel Hill and Carrboro have plenty of options. One of our group said this is her regular spot for takeout pizza, so she is a fan.
Read More
Julie M.
Aug 29, 2022
We loved the greek pizza. Fresh veggies and flavorful Best we've had in a long time.
Read More
Laura L.
Jul 28, 2024
We order takeout from here about once a month. We love their lasagna, manicotti, garlic knots and pizza.Always on time and very friendly
Read More
Kristin U.
Oct 14, 2023
Who knew! $2 for a slice of cheese, tastes like anything you'd get on a NY corner. Reminds me of a pizza place we'd go to back in my hometown.
Read More
J W.
Feb 10, 2024
They always have good NY style pizza. Decently priced and good for the size. Always a go to pizza place.
Read More
John A.
May 26, 2023
I'm from NY, and I love pizza. I ordered the NY white pizza for here and it was absolutely fantastic. There are a lot of places that claim they have NY pizza... This one actually does. From my first bite to the last I was taken back to NY. Also, you can order by the slice. While there I met the owners who were attentive and friendly. This is a must go place.
Read More
Jeff R.
May 25, 2024
DO NOT GO HERE. I wanted to try out a local place for pizza and based off the reviews, thought this would be a good place. I was wrong. They have a website associated with them with a menu and prices. I ordered based off those prices. I was not given a total over the phone and they charged me $5 more than I expected. It was a classic bait and switch. They have a different price menu in house than their website. Do NOT go here, absolute scumbag behavior
Read More
Johnson C.
Jan 4, 2024
I tried this place because of the positive reviews. I ordered a NY Sausage Stromboli. What I got was a bread roll with some cheese and exactly TWO pieces of sausage and THREE pieces of pepper. I have never been so disappointed in a local restaurant. They will never have to worry about getting any more of my money. If I could give less than a 1-star rating, I would.
Read More
Richard C.
Apr 28, 2023
Best pizza in the area... large w extra mushrooms my personal favorite! Great eggplant subs too! Pizza Slices Carrboro Pizza
Read More
