Yo Pauly's New York Pizza

Top three pizza in all of Phoenix The most consistent pizza - every visit has been a home run.New favorite - DA MIDTOWN MELTDOWN pizza.Also first time - got the THE NEW YORK GIANT cheese with crispy crust The staff is attentive and they listen

First time at this neighborhood pizza place. Traveled 20+ miles to try the New York Pizza. Friend was from New York and recommended it. Ordered a large Greek Salad and large pizza, half cheese and have meatball and pepperoni. All good here. Nice family restaurant. Good service and good food.

1st time trying this restaurant and I've wanted to do a review for the longest time so here goes.Called in a to go order for the family which was a diverse selection of food from the menu. After calling in the order, was only 20-25 minutes before it was ready and lead foot drove down to the restaurant to pick up dinner.Small but well layer out seating with television's on 3 of the walls to entertain for those dining in. Very friendly and attentive staff that greeted me. Clean and well kept front desk and kitchen from what I could see and the wait staff didn't wait long before tables were vacated to clean them up for the next customers.The aroma when I 1st walked in the door gave me hunger pains (not really but you get where I'm going with this) of garlic, pizza dough and that heavenly sauce. Paid the bill, received our goodies and headed home pronto to keep everything hot and fresh for the family. Chopped saladSide of manhattan meatballs StromboliCalzoneNew York PizzaMy 1st selection was the Stromboli and they included sides of sauce to dip in. * It's been a while since I've been to NY / NJ but this was just as good as they make in the motherland. 2nd selection was the Little Italy Calzone and we really enjoyed (we, because everyone wanted a bite) the fresh ricotta and sausage they stuffed inside. Perfectly cooked, not doughy or wet inside like some other places we've had from. Brushed with a light oil and seasoning / herbs atop and again with sides of sauce. 3rd selection was the New Yorker Pizza. Have to say this was our least favorite, because it had little to no flavor which surprised us due to the toppings they included. Crust was on point (as Dave Portnoy would say "good under carriage"), wasn't chewy and had good flavor. 4th selection was the large antipasto salad. When they say large they aren't lying. This was enough for 2 people and some for leftover the next day. Lots of fresh veggies and their balsamic dressing is "drink worthy" IYKWIM! 5th selection - Last but not least the side of manhattan meatballs smothered in their signature sauce we've come to love now and they didn't disappoint. Only thing I wished it had included was garlic bread to soak up any leftover sauce. All in all Yo Paul's exceeded our expectations and I'm so glad I finally got to have a delicious dinner from here and give my review. Thanks Pauly, we'll be back to have a pie in person next time. You know I used the excuse of doing a review so I could get a bite or 6 to make sure I gave it my all

Great spot for authentic NY pizza. I had the one of the lunch specials for take out and it's nice that they offer a whole variety of single slices, salads, and sandwiches. Since I haven't been here before, I asked the register lady to walk me through the different flavors and she was very sweet and helpful. I ended up ordering the bbq chicken pizza and the sausage ricotta slices to go with a drink, all for about $8.50. Can't beat the price with inflation being so high right now! The flavors and crust were spot on and slices were on the bigger side too. Can't wait to be back to try some more of their items. The NYC themed decor was really cute too :)

Stopped in for a quick lunch and we were pleasantly surprised. We loved that they offered pizza by the slice combo's I ordered one of the lunch specials - chop salad and a slice of the lasagna pizza. Both came out very quickly which was great! The salad was served with ranch balsamic dressing which was delicious. The pizza was good, just not very warm/hot which is why I can't give it 5 stars. My husband ordered a different lunch special - 6 Buffalo wings and a slice of pepperoni pizza. The buffalo wings were made to order, the sauce was delicious and the ranch to dip them in was also wonderful. The pizza was much warmer/hotter than mine so maybe my slice was just sitting under the warmer longer? Overall, bummed my pizza wasn't super hot, but my husband loved what he ordered, so it was worth the visit!

Came here with a buddy after a recent afternoon round of golf in the area. Was really jonesing for some true New York style slices, and this place delivered the goods!!!We ate in and ordered a few items to split...salad, sub and a pie. The house salad was piled high with greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, green and black olives and served with a tangy Italian style dressing. Then came a meatball sub brimming with tender meatballs, marinara sauce and baked mozzarella cheese. Finally, we tried their Ziggy's favorite pizza pie with had a perfectly chewy thin crust topped with marinara, mozzarella and both pepperoni and disc-sliced sausage. Perfection.Glad we decided to eat in, as everything came (and stayed) piping hot, making for a great meal experience.

Closest to back east pizza I've been able to find so far! Crust and sauce are just right.

Very unfriendly staff that needs an additional training in basic costumer service skills. Long wait for pizza to be made certainly does not help an overall experience. It took them 45 minutes plus to make a simple pie. Once the pizza was out it was a sad glycation mash of burned crust which is a clear formula for atherosclerosis. This must be the worst pizza and the worst costumer service of what usually is well known area for good food and good pizza especially.

I love their Garlic Knots with cheese! I don't really buy much else. Lol. Friendly staff. Quick service.

I found this pizzeria by accident and it was a good accident. The pizza is excellent. They are the only ones that knows how to make an upside down Sicilian pizza unless you're from New York you wouldn't notice excellent pizza as far as the inside well as a little worn and torn, but this place is great.