The Woodshed

So, I was reeeeally close to giving this place a 5 star rating, but there was a couple of things that kept me at a 4. The EU Burger was OUTSTANDING! Such an unusual combination of flavors that I absolutely loved. The Strawberry and Pecan Salad was also great, but was extremely difficult to eat because of the size of the lettuce. Not sure why restaurants don't either tear or cut the lettuce into smaller pieces? And the Bloody Mary was very uninspiring. Not bad per se, but definitely didn't measure up to the food served . Service was VERY good and the ambiance (OLD historical building) was to die for. Would definitely would come back, but would hope they'd step up their game behind the bar...

This is my favorite "go to" local restaurant for a casual Friday night (thank goodness their hours have extended again!). It's located in the back of an art gallery on the square in Carthage so you know to know what you're looking for. It has a great bar and a basic menu with just a little variety but not extensive. Probably one of the best steaks around, Cherry doesn't mess around with her quality of meat! I also love the chicken sandwich, it's ENORMOUS! The burger is also very popular and my husband loves the Reuben. It's worth calling ahead because they regularly have private events so you might wind up showing up and they are closed.

Menu has changed so I uploaded relevant content. It's the more limited menu. What we had was good (catfish platter and Maple leaf burger). If you're in to supporting local. Give it a shot!

Maple-bacon jam cheeseburger The burger is made from ground brisket. This is seriously % greatness‼

Wow is the best word to describe this place. It was so good!! I've never tasted better fries in my life.

Place started by framing pictures. Then started selling art and opened up the restaurant when they moved to this location. People working there were very attentive and had some good conversations. Wish all restaurants had folks like that. French fries were a good pre-seasoned variety. Good cornbread. Tartar sauce was a good crunchy scallion variety. Fish batter was more of a panko style vs cornbread. Went well with the sauce. Chicken sandwich was good. A bit over cooked. Beautiful old building. Estimate 150 years old. Nicely restored floors and walls. Americana on the square. Come here to shop the square and eat here. Restaurant is in the back of the art work store. They also have a lot of great bourbons and cigars. They will pour samples of some of the more interesting flavored whiskies. The food is good but I pushed it to a 5 because of the people and the interesting ambience

We had the party melt and the maple burger. Both were very good! Our server was awesome! Highly recommend!

We tried the Woodshed early this evening. The food and the service were excellent!! I highly recommend this place.

Absolute AWESOME place. Food was GREAT, service was Spectacular and a GRATIFYING experience. Just a really COOL place just to hang out. Lots of Art, unique Spirits and all kinds of other things.

This is a quaint little place in back of a historic building on the Carthage square. They host local artists and have extraordinary choices on their menu. I'd highly recommend visiting this place.