Calamari
Spaghetti & meatballs with spicy marinara
Chicken Parmesan
Tricolor Tortellini
Spaghetti with Bolognese
Cannoli
salads, food
Sicilian Shrimp Scallops Pasta
Creme Brulee
Calamari Strips
Tiramisu Cheesecake (limited item)
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Carbonara
menu
Linguine Chicken Pesto
menu
Chicken Carbonara and Linguine Alfredo with broccoli
Bruschetta
Excellent Expresso martini
Sicilian Shrimp Scallops Pasta
Stuffed Mushrooms
Menu
menu
pasta, pasta dish, food
Twinkle K.
Feb 7, 2025
Great spot! They have good food and ample seating. The service staff was accommodating. I had creamy pesto pasta and salad. 1/4 is a good portion.
Read More
Jonathan D.
Oct 13, 2024
Great atmosphere, smooth jazz. That's what I needed after my Wingstop troubles. (Check that review out it's fun)I was greeted when I walked in, given a menu and I chose to sit at a very nice bar. The food is great. I got takeout because I'm a bit sick, and the shrimp diavolo is perfect. Just spicy enough to clear the sinuses. The garlic bread could use some work though.
Read More
Laurel S.
Oct 21, 2024
Salad was delicious. Bread came with margarine...... which blows my mind!!!! We ordered chicken fettuccine Alfredo which came with no chicken. And we ordered carbonara which was actually just Alfredo again. It was a game day so little crazy so service wasn't great but giving them a pass. 3 stars because the Alfredo was pretty good and salad too.
Read More
Trenton P.
Jan 22, 2025
Nico's is great. The food is wonderful and prices are very reasonable. We have always had great service there.
Read More
Shay L.
Oct 5, 2024
The service was great this places is a great spot to go in have some great Italy food very clean great places for groups and date night
Read More
Tim C.
Jun 7, 2024
Stopped by here for dinner yesterday evening and got very good service and a nice Italian type old style atmosphere and the food was great very good price.Would definitely recommend
Read More
Alex W.
Mar 23, 2024
This place could not get better if they tried. Food was absolutely insane, we got 2 quarter sized entrees, 2 mixed drinks, 2 desserts and one appetizer all for around $75. More than enough food to share and keep ourselves full. The service is absolutely impeccable and I've probably never had better service in my life. The waiter, Caleb was extremely attentive and knowledgeable about the dishes being served!!! Thank you Caleb. The taste of the pasta was extremely rich and everything was very satisfying. I hope they keep the cheesecake tiramisu on the menu as they said they were just testing it. Another thing to note is that My wife said the creme brûlée was the best she'd ever had! We will certainly be going back as this is now our new favorite place in the Manhattan/JC Area
Read More
Colleen O.
Feb 2, 2024
Food was good with plentiful portions. Reasonably priced. Serve was Excellent, the waiter was attentive, friendly and gave solid recommendations with the menu. My dessert was outstanding, I ordered the crème brûlée. Good wine, and drink selection as well. my only complaint is the Frank Sinatra music on repeat, lol. However, the decor is the best part about the restaurant. Can't be the location. I will be a returning customer. thanks
Read More
Dri N.
Nov 17, 2023
What an adorable atmosphere. I was welcomed with happiness and smiles what a warm feeling the staff brought to my heart!! Food was absolutely delicious. I didn't give much standard being in a small town but they did it great tasting food with the right amount of flavor. The wine that my server recommended for me, Sean Minor Cab Sav was oaky full body and smooth. I ordered the meat baked ravioli and the meat was just so flavorful with the crunchy buttery ravioli. Quarter spaghetti with 1 huge meatball. I was nervous... Last time I've seen a meat ball like that was at Bucca de Pepo.. or however spelt and I never went there again. Not Nico's! I will definitely be coming back when craving Italian. Thank you all for the great experience and allowing me to do my studies here too !
Read More
Kevin L.
Dec 28, 2024
Good food. Nico's doesn't have the same atmosphere as its sister restaurant in Salina, but they certainly share the same menu and recipes. Good sizes portions, even for lunch.
Read More