Carriage Crossing Restaurant and Bakery

The all-you-can-eat family-style meal was highly recommended, so we got that. It's individual dinner salads, bread, fried chicken, roast beef, mashed potatoes and white gravy, green beans and corn, with a slice of pie at the end. It's a lot of food, and it's all served in bowls to pass around the table. The thing is, it's $16.99 per person and everyone at the table has to get it, otherwise, you can't get it. All of the good was good, especially the fried chicken and mashed potatoes. But what really stood out was the pie. You can choose from over a dozen different flavors of pie -- everything from peach and pecan to sour cream raisin and chocolate peanut butter. I chose a slice of blackberry, because I love a double crust fruit pie. The crust was flaky and buttery, with just enough fruit filling. My table didn't need refills on anything except the fried chicken -- that seemed to go fast. The servings that they put in the serving dishes were huge and more than enough.Someone at my table was freaking out over the salad dressing that they serve at Carriage Crossing. It's called Dorothy Lynch, and apparently it has a cult following. It's not particular to this restaurant, but this restaurant serves it, so you can find it here. Honestly, it tastes like French dressing to me, but people love it and it's one of the salad dressings they offer with your salad!Carriage Crossing is in the heart of Amish country in Yoder, and some (most?) of the people who work here are Amish. It's kind of neat to see Amish people in the wild, dressed in traditional Amish clothes. So if you're into that sort of thing, you will find that here.

Probably the best cherry pie I've ever had in my life! The perfect crust and sweetness. Could have done without biting down on a couple cherry pots but still worth it!! The cinnamon roll was huge and very fresh.... And my small slice of apple pie was great!I highly recommend this restaurant and bakery!!

Chicken fried chicken was great, honestly. I was super disappointed that we weren't able to get breakfast since we were after 10:30 on a Saturday but that's alright. Service was good. She was sweet.Coffee was honestly super bad. Colored water, lol. I'm sure they have their best picks on the menu, chicken fried chicken might even be one.. I just wasn't super impressed. Actually a little disappointed.

My second time here and just like the first the food was great. Nothing better than a family style dinner with business associates!

Such a great suggestion from our hotel in Hutchinson. Was the small hometown not chain restaurant that I was looking for. Had the chicken and was so moist and the breading was very light.

As a place known for its pies, I would expect nothing but an amazing product. We recently were passing through and bought a peanut butter pie. It looked fantastic! But we couldn't see its hidden secrets until we got home to sample it.....It tasted fresh, crust was decent, no issues there. But the two best things of a peanut butter pie were dismal. The custard tasted ok, a little bland, but the main problem? It was full of lumps. Like grape-sized little dough nuggets. Yuck. On top of that, the taste of peanut butter was all but non-existent. Upon closer inspection, I think I spotted some peanut butter underneath everything. Like, maybe an 1/8" layer underneath it all. Overall, the pie tasted like barely sweet meringue. It was uninteresting, and even nasty as you encountered lumpy custard. Save your time and money, find one of the locals who set up during the fair season or just go to Spears. Kinda bums me out, because stopping by here on the way home from the fair was a tradition, but no more. Tsk.

This was my first meal visiting Kansas for the first time. I knew I had to manage my expectations. I'm super bougie and am used to living and visiting cities with vibrant culinary scenes. I knew I had to manage my expectations but I was pleasantly surprised by the food here. Do I truly believe that everything is made from scratch? Absolutely not. However, the combination of items made for a satisfying meal that left me pretty full for the rest of the 2 hour long car ride from the airport to the small town I was visiting. The hot roast beef sandwich is a carb bomb that will satisfy the glutton living inside of you. Was the roast beef the best I've ever had? No. It was a bit dry and bland but it was sandwiched between amazing homemade bread and doused in brown gravy. Serving mashed potatoes with this is something I can't comprehend but hey it's the Midwest, so I just went with it. My bf loved his chicken fried chicken. It was perfectly cooked, seasoned and the white gravy was pretty good. We had pies and they were so-so. I don't believe the crust was homemade and while they tasted ok, there was too much. They are so rich, I couldn't get through even half of it. None of us did. The three of us could have shared a pie. Service was good, even if the servers are a bit short. Still friendly but not lingering if that makes sense. More what do you want, good, ok, bye. Was good for us though as we had to get on the road. The dining room reminds me of food halls from the 80's. Not my scene but again, I wasn't expecting much. I will say I though the place was a little dirty but we may have come after a big rush so I won't hold it against them. I subsequently noticed that a lot of restaurants that we went to on this trip kept their dining rooms in the same condition.

I came here as a recommendation. It's right off the freeway. This place is huge and very busy. The people here are so nice and customers service driven. There are real Amish people who work here and live in the area. There is a little store attached to the restaurant. We had 7 people in our party and they were able to put two tables together. We ordered a family feast. You are able to order refills of the food. You can tell they make everything fresh and portions are very generous. The fried chicken was very crunchy. I really loved the overall experience. We were visiting family and it felt like we were at a family member's house. They have a rule you can not take leftovers home. I really don't know why but that's the rule. They do let you take your dessert a piece of piece home. Everything is amazing here highly recommend.

I've always had great service and food but today was awful. The waitress took our order and never came and checked on us to see if we needed refills which we did. Food came I asked for mustard she said ok filled our cups but never saw her again. I finally got up and asked another waitress for mustard. The food was ok and the baked potato was hard so I was very disappointed

At about noon, my wife ordered a chicken dinner and I the smoked ham dinner; the food was hot and delicious!