Tony’s NY Pizza
Tony’s NY Pizza
Cheese (16")
Donut with Cannoli filling
Donut with cannoli filling
Tiramisu
Ziti Pie
Antipasto Italiano
Sfogliatella
Veggie
Fettuccine Mediterraneo
Garlic Bread
Linguini Posillipo
Chicken Brunello
donuts, dough desserts, food
food, pizza
Ziti Pie
pasta dish, pasta, food
sandwiches, sandwich, food
Cannoli
Fettuccine Mediterraneo
pasta dish, pasta, food
Couldn't even eat around the burnt parts lol
Sicilian Pizza
Burnt pizza
Alex M.
Dec 16, 2024
Every meal at Tony's is worth it! Updating my review because I always order their pizza and this week marked the first time that I tried their pasta and I was equally as impressed.We ordered their ziti, garlic knots, and Cesar salad. The ziti has just the right amount of sauce and cheese to compliment the pasta. These days, I find that many restaurants try to be conservative with their ingredients but Tony's remains exceptional - the sauce and cheese were generous.The garlic knots were tasty and not too garlicky. The Cesar was super fresh and each bite of lettuce came with a crisp crunch.Once again, Tony's for the win!
Read More
Tim L.
Jan 9, 2025
Uhh... what are we doing here? Just look at the pictures. Been a long time customer of Tony's - hit or miss on many menu items, but the pizza has always been consistently good. Pizza was burned to a crisp - kids wouldn't even eat it. Their wings have always been small... but this (for $13 an order) is just pathetic. Called to complain and asked for a refund on the wings - was told repeatedly "we haven't changed our distributor, we get them from the same place we've always gotten them from". Repeatedly. Hopefully will see the refund soon...
Read More
Eydie Q.
Feb 15, 2024
Really fast and quick service. Ordered the hot Italian sub. Their bread is so good warm. I dined in and this is weird but I loved their mixing of the soda fountain. Perfect ratio of carbonation and syrup. Will definitely come back.
Read More
Mily L.
Jan 21, 2024
This is a solid neighborhood spot. I think it deserves more love than its 3-star rating at the moment. Planning on visiting again whenever we want non-delivery pizza in Oakton. Food: BNew York style pizza and the usual menu items from a casual Italian restaurant. We ordered mozzarella sticks and a whole pepperoni pizza. I had low expectations but the mozzarella sticks were very good! Coated in batter, not bread crumbs. The outside was crispy and flavorful and the inside was perfectly gooey. The tomato sauce for dipping was clearly freshly made. Pizza was good. I wasn't expecting Wolfgang Puck, and it hit the spot since it was right out of the oven. Service: BCashier was a nice guy. Stood by the cash register patiently as we perused the menu. Brought out our food promptly to our table.Ambiance: BClean and basic. No frills, charm or character but fits the bill of a basic pizzeria. Seems that given the decor, this is probably mainly a takeout place.
Read More
Chuck H.
Nov 13, 2024
Food is terrific and service is thorough. Take out items were checked in my presence.
Read More
Grace S.
Oct 9, 2023
The pizza here is just OK. I wouldn't call it NY style, I'd call it just regular ole pizza.we really, really enjoyed the zucchini fries with ranch. Those were amazing.The pizza itself was just a little disappointing. I've been searching for a true ny style pizza joint, and this didn't make the cut. :(
Read More
Natalie O.
Oct 22, 2024
Tony's does it again! We usually eat pizza there but got it delivered this time - the pizza arrived quickly and held up great. Fresh premium ingredients, very generous toppings, and their signature chewy but still crispy crust. We'll definitely be adding this to our regular order in rotation!
Read More
M M.
Oct 17, 2024
I used to be a regular customer of their pizzas, but they recently raised the price too much.......a regular 16' cheese pizza is now $17.50, up several dollars from before. You can't do that and keep your customers.....so I simply quit buying pizza there. The only thing I get there now is the Thursday special for the ziti-pie, when it is about half-price. One of the night-managers I spoke to about this said I was right, and he said he tried to convince the owner that he would lose customers with the round of price-increases, but to no avail.
Read More
Deb L.
Dec 24, 2024
Tried it for the first time today. Enjoyed the wings, pizza, spaghetti, and garlic bread. It's a super casual sit-down spot and the food was pretty darn good. We had the margherita pizza, another pizza whose name I can't remember, wings, and sausage spaghetti. All were delicious. The garlic bread was buttery and the outside was nice and crusty. The folks were nice and professional. I'm sure I'll eat there again when I'm in the Oakton area.
Read More
Diana R.
Dec 22, 2024
The pizza was just okay. Greek salad was disappointing. Made with bland iceberg lettuce and no option for greek dressing. I also ordered the garlic knots which implies plural garlic knots but it was one singular knot that had absolutely no garlic on it and was hard.
Read More
