The Haymaker Bar

Came here for drinks last night and was pleasantly surprised at how quickly we were able to find a seat. Someone came to help us fairly quickly, and since the kitchen was closing soon we put in an order for wings and truffle fries-- both were delicious! Our table also tried a few cocktails, most of which the names I cannot remember. But I will say, they all looked and tasted delicious-- no one had any complaints. The bar itself is fairly dark, and there are a few tables and seating at the bar. I imagine it can get packed fairly quickly. Overall had a great experience and would come back to try more drinks and snacks!

Annie is a gem and 100% the reason why I went back two nights in a row. The dumplings are excellent and bursting with flavor. The nachos are also very good. Wouldn't necessarily get the tots again, but the portion is quite large. It's a cozy little spot with attentive servers and great drinks.

I made sure I checked in here to get the reminder to leave the review. Honestly was just walkin around and stumbled on this bar. Seemed cool so walked in. Bar was packed but there was seating elsewhere around. Simply asked the female bartender if they had a happy hour menu as most bars do..I didn't think it was that far fetch of a question...but she did. She made a joke about me inquiring about happy hour as if I couldn't afford a regular priced drink. I was overdue for a drink so I brushed her unprofessionalism off and ordered a drink ..it was basic but ehhh ..she def will ruin your customer retention with such ill behavior Signed,A person who will not be returning

Please do yourself a favor and get the truffle fries here.We also got high noon and a beer here. Service was friendly and vibe was chill :). No happy hour though nice nice drink selection.

Annie literally remembered us from more than 2 years ago!!!!!! Still my fav painkiller - tasty and strong. Service is obviously impeccable. Ambiance is changing - the menu is new - feels a bit more boogie and I'm not mad about it :)

I actually stumbled into this bar late on a weekday night. They were the only bar only on the block and ended up being the perfect after-dinner spot. My date and I sat at the bar and ordered drinks. There were only a few other patrons so the energy felt relaxed and intimate. We were able to catch a few minutes of a Women's World Cup game, which was awesome since it didn't feel like a traditional sport bar. The lighting was low, the bar was backlight with greenery, and the cocktail selection was unique. I liked everything about this bar and I'll definitely post another visit when I'm on H. St.

One of my favorite places to grab an old-fashioned in the city. Always great food, drinks, and service. A nice place for an after-hours drink or a date.

Loved these cocktails, especially because they had green chartreuse which is hard to find at a bar. They made amazing cocktails with it and had creative options you don't find most places. Definitely will go back.

The bartender/servicer was by himself but he made sure everyone is served with great services. Five stars for him. We order mess totes, buffalo wings and hot honey shrimp. All delicious. Nice small bar, with good atmosphere.

Service was amazing when I went. I arrived literally at 10PM when their kitchen closed and my bartender still let me sneak an order of dumplings in. It was so worth it! My first time here and glad I found it. Cute cocktail bar with speakeasy-ish vibes with reasonable prices. Will def be back!