Slice & Pie Pizza

Oh the wonderful pizzaplaces in DC I love gourmet pizza and I love their pizza sauce and their Detroit crust my new favorite Detroit style pizza place but This is a $55 pizza restaurant And you will want the whole pizza ! My favorite Detroit pizza is meatball garlic oil basil burata , sausage hot honey pepperoni is diabolically delicious

Yesterday was my first time visiting Slice & Pie Pizza. I ordered a slice of Sicilian pizza and a Hawaiian slice. Between the two, I really enjoyed the Hawaiian slice. It had the perfect balance of sauce and toppings. However, I wasn't a fan of the Sicilian slice, as the cheese was very dry and tasted as though it had been sitting out for hours.The ambiance was pretty cool, although seating was limited. The staff on the other hand, wasn't very polite. They were pushy and curt in their responses. Despite there being no line, I felt rushed when placing my order and didn't get a chance to look at all the options available.

This was my first visit, I'd dropped in for a quick bite because it was in the right spot on my way home, & the sign piqued my curiosity.I was hoping to see a pie / slice with a little bit of green - veg on it, but since they didn't have any of that I was waffling between the burrata and what turned out to be the Sicilian.The guy at the front was giving "manager who resented having to fill in at the front due to a call out." Just a hunch. Maybe he was in foreclosure or his dog died, idk. He seemed impatient and completely disinterested in me or other guests. He never noticed, never asked, nor seemed to care that it might be my first time there... or that people return and recommend businesses to others when they have a good experience. I was visually perusing and reading everything and looking inquisitive as one often does on a first visit, in addition to asking questions based on the poor /nonexistent signage.I pointed & asked what ingredients were in one pie & he said "you want the Sicilian?" rather abruptly. There was no language barrier. So it was awkward having to ask him *again* what was in the pizza. He provided no explanations or recommendations, just silence and watching me vacantly while I struggled to make a choice... again, because the pizzas weren't labeled or apparent on the awkwardly positioned menu screens high up on the ceiling directly above the pizza.I didn't notice the menu screen until just after I asked for the pizza I pointed to but couldn't name -since there were neither labels nor words coming from his mouth. When I started to read the menu directly above me, "croquettes" caught my eye. And I said "oh I didn't notice those up there right above my head."Yet another awkward moment of silence while I waited for the way too quickly wiping menu screen to reappear so I could catch a split second glimpse of the price and description.The screen flashed away so quickly I only caught a glance of the croquette description - something about potato and maybe sausage... I've been craving croquettes so I switched my order to that. Still no recommendation from the guy waiting on me to order.Clearly, the guy was not interested in explaining, introducing, or upselling me anything so I decided not to ask about beverages and just got for a bottle of water.The croquettes, aka glorified tater tots, had a decent flavor, and a nice little crisp on the outside, but the inside was kind of liquid like cream of wheat. At least they looked and tasted like sweet potato tater tots. The white dipping sauce, which was a mystery since there are no descriptions on their yelp menu, tasted really good.The ambience was clean, fine , up-to-date, adequate, functional .

We were craving pizza and noticed that Slice of Pie Pizza offers gluten free options. I called the restaurant to confirm that they take the necessary precautions to avoid cross-contamination, and they reassured me that they clean and bake everything separately. My husband really enjoyed the Hawaiian pizza, and I must say, the GF Hawaiian pizza was pretty good. The dough was amazing--it wasn't overcooked and was soft and delicious. I do wish my pizza had a bit more cheese. Next time my sister's in town, we're definitely going to dine in.

I felt like I was back in NY when I walked into slice and pie. They have lots of options and I like that there is such a variety of pizza here. The prices are great as well, it's no surprise they are ranked as high as they are! The Hawaiian slice was really delicious, tons of flavor and just the right ratio of sauce to cheese. Their garlic knots were good too, staff raved about them which is always a good sign! I wish there were more searing options, but I also understand the demand for space in the area. Looking forward to coming back soon.

Slice & Pie is 2nd place for "best pizza slice in the U.S.", so I had high expectations, but had a very underwhelming experience. Staff were not very friendly or welcoming either. We ordered the burrata slice (Cali tomato sauce, mozzarella, fresh burrata, basil, Parmesan) mushroom slice (Parmesan cream, mozzarella, mushroom, garlic, truffle oil, parsley), Detroit style slice (tomato sauce, mozzarella, provolone, hot honey, pepperoni), and truffle fries. I appreciated how thin and crispy the burrata and mushroom slices were. The slice of burrata pizza was a bit too salty, and could've used more tomato sauce. The slice of mushroom pizza was quite unflavorful, which was disappointing. The Detroit style slice was also underwhelming, and the slices of pepperoni weren't even crispy. Each slice was $5.50. The truffle fries were also very mid, they weren't even crispy and didn't even taste like truffle. The fries honestly tasted like cafeteria fries. Overall, pretty disappointing experience with the pizza and service. The space inside is very small, but has eclectic decor. Given our experience, I'm not too inclined to come back. I think Andy's Pizza is superior in terms of taste, menu options, and service.

Really good gluten free pizza. I did grubhub and was curious if they put a sticker on the box and was really happy they did - so it felt safe. It had an airy crust and was light and thin, but not the crunchy thin we gf folks often get. Got the pepperoni and the meat lovers - no complaints!

Best gluten free pizza in DC!! This is not that typical round & crunchy GF crust that seems to be the only option everywhere else...It's soft, fluffy, and the closest thing I've had to a real slice of pizza in a long time. I ordered the GF cheese for delivery. Highly recommend!

The best slice of baratta I've ever had. Dana hooked us up. Love Lucy's too. I would eat this pizza if it were my last meal on death row. Not fucking kidding

This place couldn't be any better. The pizza is amazing and everybody who works here is so nice! Actually the best!