Church Street Pizza

The pizza tastes different than I remember. The crust and dough tastes breadier and might be because they toss it in more flour. It is less oily because I remember the pizza boxes and plates would be stained from the grease which doesn't seem to happen anymore. Perhaps they're using less cheese and not baking the pizzas as long? (When cheese overheats the fat separates)I've always loved the sliced sausage here. I do think the toppings are the strong point here over any chain spot. I think if you end up getting the 1 topping deal then it's a fair price. I used to think very highly of Church St Pizza and I know Lombardi's is essentially the same... it doesn't exactly taste the same for some reason to me.

The closest to a decent NY style pizza I've had in a while (Fairfax area). Pizza sauce is mild and the cheese distribution is excellent. Would love to see the pies in the oven a bit longer to get that crispy bottom, none the less wasn't bad. I ordered a half pep and cheese as well as a white pizza. Both were savory and hit the spot. I'm going back.

Ordered a pizza for carry out (since they don't deliver) and it said 40 minutes until it was ready. Super long but ok, I can deal with that. I get there right at the 40 minute mark and they tell me it will be 5 more minutes. 20 minutes later, my pizzas are ready. This isn't a one off thing. This place is a mess. They go out of business every several years and somehow come back worse. They have a good product but are absolutely terrible at getting it to their customers.

It's nice to have an independent pizza place that actually has quality pizza in your neighborhood. I've wanted to try Church St Pizza for awhile but did not get the chance until today. It's really good NY style pizza that reminds me of Lucianos at Tysons (RIP). I got a single pepperoni slice for a decent price. Not too greasy, cheese tasted great, crust was perfect. Very foldable which is important for me. I'm looking forward to coming back again when I'm in town. The trick is remembering that it's not actually on Church St. it's on Maple Ave.

This is a very nice and very simple pizza place! I had one slice of cheese pizza and one slice of pepperoni pizza, which were both good, but I think that the cheese could have been more tasteful. I also think that they should bring in a recycling bin for recyclable items, like plastic soda bottles and plastic carry out containers. Other than that, all was good! The people here are nice, the decor is cute, and the cannoli tasted great! I would come back even just for the cannoli.

The best NY style pizza in Northern VA. Their sister store Lucianos does deliver. At church at you can buy by the slice, get a cold beer and garlic nots. The pizza is above and beyond delicious

My fav pizza spot! Always get a whole cheese pizza whenever i go. Never disappoints Service 5/5Food 5/5

Good pizza. The crust was very thin and crispy, but soft on the inside. They have high quality ingredients, and big pizzas. Delicious.

These people are not serious about their "business". No deliveries on weekends, menu online does not match their mobile app menu. No idea what the pizza tastes like because their horrible business model and service me never want to go to this fatce.

Just left the restaurant without getting our pizza or a refund. To be fair, we were so confused/unsure what to do we didn't ask for a refund. Took a while to find the place since the signage is poor but we walked around a bit and got there. No sign on the building is wierd though theyve been open a while. We walk in and it's empty, maybe a sign or maybe it's meant to be more of a takeout joint? We order at counter and I start to notice a terrible smell and how hot it is inside. We take a table and the smell is worse at that end and I'm sweating now it's so hot. We play a quick phone game while I wonder about the smell and why it's so hot. Then the host brings our drinks which are marginally cold cokes in bottles, no ice. Disappointment but oh well. Then I made the mistake of looking up. Spiders and spider webs full of eggs sacs all over the ceiling and wall. I don't mean a stray web or two. I mean everywhere and full of spiders and eggs. We were sitting right under them so we jumped up and said we had somewhere to be and left. If that's what we can see and the place smells bad what is the kitchen like?!? What's in the walls and in the back that we can't see? I'm amazed it's still open. Wish I'd had the prescence of mind to ask for my money back. I was just so surprised and uncomfortable I panicked. Go somewhere else for your pizza craving!