Captain Cookie & the Milk Man

A fan favorite! The Chocolate chip, sugar cookies, and peanut butter are among my all time must haves! Throw in some of their creamy vanilla ice cream and I'd gladly indulge every day. Fun to know: this location switched to a much larger storefront and the new store is spacious, fun, and perfect for those desiring to have a seat and enjoy their treat.

Really great place! It's a small little shop in the corner of Western Market, so it's in a great location and a great place to stop for some dessert.I had a cup of birthday cake ice cream and a snickerdoodle. Very big portion for a good price! Honestly, it was a bit sweet and too much for me, but definitely would be good for anyone with a sweet tooth. They don't have a lot of flavors for ice cream, but they still had a good selection. The staff was also very friendly.I liked this place and it's pretty well priced for something in Western Market! Would recommend to anyone looking for a sweet treat.

I was visiting with my partner. Staff barely wanted to acknowledge a large group ready to order and we felt rushed to pick what to get. Not many ice cream flavors as you'd think they would have. We ordered the cookie sandwich chocolate chip cookies with vanilla ice cream. A classic, but the cookies weren't anything special. The ice cream was solid. Not a place you'd want to sit down and it's not very inviting either. The coolest part were the spoons that changed colors, other than that it's over priced and I would say to go get a sweet treat elsewhere.

This place is perfect for a late night cookie craving. The cookies are nothing crazy, just simple flavors and simple cookies. Especially for the price, it's not bad! There are also milk and ice cream options if you want to spice up your order. When we went, they had a limited amount of cookie flavors available (maybe because it was slow? Or late?). I'll be back if I'm ever in the area crazing a good, classic, warm cookie.

Always great to have a spot that is open late when you have a sweet tooth. They had about 8 different cookies to pick from and very good prices. The cookies were really good. We got the half dozen cookies with a variety of flavors. We also got the ice cream. I had the butter pecan ice cream. It was more butter than pecan. Extra sweet too. Not like others I have had.

Good cookies but nothing special - it's your standard array of 6-8 cookies without any real standout flavors. The double chocolate chip cookie was good but a thinner than I prefer. Not a bad stop for a late night cookie craving but it also wouldn't be my first choice - which is a shame since I love the name!

Late night or mid afternoon sweet tooth this place has some exciting cookies to share with even the most picky of eaters.

Wasn't familiar with the area so didn't realize this was actually inside Western Market. There is no signage to indicate that it's Captain Cookie from the inside.There were only 2 employees working when we went, wasn't impressed with the customer service or the food.We got the strawberry ice cream sandwich and it was too gooey, meaning the cookie was soft but the ice cream wasn't hard. The ice cream sandwich itself was meh, could barely taste the strawberry.

I've known about this place for a long time, but for the first time, I tried the ice cream solo (I always get the ice cream sandwiches), and it still tasted delicious. There was a bit of a line when I came in, but the young lady behind the register got through each person very quickly. I've had their milkshakes before, which are also a must try, especially with the cookie crumbles. If you have a sweet tooth, this is the place to go!

If you are sharing, do yourself a favor and at least get the bakers dozen, these were delicious. I only got six, walked around and ate them and came back for six more. Try and get them when they are making a new batch they are amazing warmOut the oven. I tried the chocolate chip , snicker doodle and oatmeal raisin and they were all really soft and very tasty. Service was friendly and made our orders with a smile.