Andy's Pizza - Old Town

Andy's Pizza lived up to the hype. I did a lot of research on having pizza (in the DC area) and we were staying maybe a mile from here.Pros:- Fresh. All the toppings tasted high quality- The flavors: We got the Pepperoni House Special and that's quite the fun combination of flavors.- Crust. The crust had a good "crack" to it when you fold it.- The sauce. I really liked the pizza sauce. It wasn't too sweet or bitter. Just right.Cons:- Seating is TIGHT. There is maybe three or four booths and a communal table in the middle. I'm not big on eating beside strangers, but luckily we were able to get a booth after waiting just a bit.I'd absolutely recommend Andy's. It lived up to the hype and was a fun little hole in the wall place. Every slice had plenty of toppings and was great leftover at the hotel. Just make sure to grab a booth in time.

I can't believe it's taken me so long to not only learn about but try Andy's Pizza out! It's a quality pizza by the slice joint that you can also get full size pies, chicken wings, chicken tenders, and salads from.Nobody told me about the lemonade situation. I ordered the strawberry lemonade thinking nothing much of it and was shocked with pure childlike delight at the sight of the lemonade in a 24oz plastic kitchen storage container! It was a feast for the eyes and for the tastebuds as well since it tasted perfectly balanced in terms of sweetness and tartness.Don't sleep on their Old Bay Fries. They are crisp, seasoned well, and massively portioned for the price - great for sharing.I'll stop in to get a slize of pepperoni, but I much prefer to be able to get a whole pie of the Diavolo. Their generosity in the calabrian ricotta make this a unique tasting pizza that's good fresh, reheated, or cold.The ceasar salad isn't anything over the top, but it is a large, reliable salad if nothing else to help balance out the heaviness of everything else on the menu.

They have very friendly staff and the lady who helped me was very kind.I had the margherita slice 5/5

Craving pizza? This is definitely the spot. This was my first visit and won't be my last! I ordered a slice of buffalo chicken and a slice of pepperoni, along with a drink. I appreciate the combo/menu options that are available for customers who don't want a whole pie. Between the two slices I ordered, the buffalo chicken was my favorite and I was kind of kicking myself for not ordering two of those. The balance of sauce was well done and I appreciate Andy's for not having the buffalo be too overwhelming. Although it's a small location, there's decent seating options and you're not bumping into a lot of people.

In a world of pizza spots boasting about a NY Slice , it's nice to actually have a flavorful, thin crust pizza with fresh toppings and making that perfect fold. The old bay fries are a sweet nod to the MD area . Hot and covered in that great seafood seasoning. This pizza has kind of ruined me from my domino's or papa John life lol Again an amazing slice that will satisfy any pizza lover.

Originally from NY, I am constantly looking for pizza that lives up the my expectations! Andy's is as close as it gets. I love the pepperonis cups they have on their pizza.

Our go-to too lazy to cook spot! Super casual and well-priced especially if you come in on one of their special nights. They have deals like if you buy a bottle of wine you get a pretty good free slice.

Seriously though, everyone that works here seems to have the BEST energy!If you've had Andy's before, then you'll know that across the varied locations there if a lot of consistency in the food - delicious, thin, crisp pizza (that you can get by the slice!)However, this location blends in perhaps a little too much into the neighborhood because I've never ever noticed it driving by. Heck, even when I searched "pizza by the slice" I was shocked to see Andy's was just a 4 minute walk from where I was. And even with directions I second guessed them when I first turned onto the street because there just isn't a ton of signage. But as soon as I walked in I was greeted genuinely and enthusiastically by a number of different employees so much so that I told them they have amazing energy! But as always, the pizza hits so I'm glad to know I can easily grab a quick slice whenever I'm out in this direction!

Andy's pizza is amazing! I think one of the best in the area imo and I've had my share! :-) Great texture, robust flavor, and very thin like NY pizza. So good, I ordered two pizzas! I went with the white pizza and margherita.

So.... After much anticipation and solid recommendations from friends I have to say ... we were disappointed. I can see how this style of pizza is favored in this area because we don't have any other decent places that serve NY style pizza near us. That floppy, thin ooey gooey pizza just wasn't that for us. It was lukewarm, and with little to no cheese. Even our 5 year old asked "did we get sauce pizza" when we opened the lid. (See pics for reference) The flavor was good but it just didn't have enough cheese. It was also pretty toasty. I don't mind a well done pizza but friends at Andy's this pizza was borderline burnt. Again see pics. This was a real disappointing miss for us. We will likely give one more try but I'd rather go to fairlington a little farther away for a delicious guarantee. ESP at $23 a pie.