pizza, food
Pepperoni and sausage pizza slice
Entrance from the Western Market
interior image
Half of a mushroom and onion, couldn't get a photo before digging in
Patio
Beverage cooler and wine options
Choices, choices...
One beautiful, delicious pizza
Mushroom and Onion Pie Pepperoni Special (House Favorite) Pie
Making pies
Margarita slice
Coming in from the food court
Pepperoni Special (House Favorite) Pie
Restaurant entrance
Bar area inside
Mushroom pizza and margherita
Mushroom and Onion Pie, Buffalo Crispy Chicken Pie, Pepperoni Special (House Favorite) Pie, White Pie, Pepperoni Pie
Layout
pizza, interior
outside
Pepperoni Pie, The Carnivore Pie
three slices of pizza
So many options!
Evan F.
Jan 26, 2025
Located within a food court style area in the Foggy Bottom location, this NY style slice shop really does a good job with their pies. Plenty of options to choose from, along with beer and cocktail choices as well as pre-packaged salads and the like.I ordered two slices to try...a white pie and a pepperoni. Both had a great thin crust with a slight char to it, but the cupped pepperoni slices and a tomato-forward, bright (red style) sauce was the better of the two.This is a great option for a quick meal.
Read More
Jordan N.
Dec 23, 2024
Andy's serve some of my favorite pizzas in the DC area. New York style, good tomato sauce, and good dough - everything that makes a hallmark of a great pizza.I haven't found another non-Neapolitan local pizza chain that matches up to Andy's, despite living here for years in DC - but pizza in DC in general isn't that great even if the city is famous for the Jumbo slices.Service here was friendly and they seem to cater more to the college crowd with some slices ready to go.As for ambience, it's nice - they even have a bar seating area inside the Western Market location.
Read More
Samina M.
Oct 17, 2024
Got two tasty slices from this Andy's location! Really enjoyed their BBQ Chicken - very flavorful and cooked to perfection. A classic is always the cheese and mushroom - filling and toppings pair perfectly with one another.I appreciate this Western Market location when I'm on the go and am in need of a quick lunch. They have a very cute space with plenty of menu items and drinks to go with your slice of za.The service was speedy and friendly! Would definitely give this location a try if you are in the area.
Read More
Joshua K.
Feb 19, 2025
Andy's is great for what it is-solid pizza that's relatively affordable, good-sized slices, and fast (I got my order within five minutes of getting in line). I got a slice of the White Pizza and the Margherita pizza, both of which were warmed up (although not fresh) and tasty. I would recommend if you work or go to school nearby and want a quick bite to eat.
Read More
Nigel M.
May 18, 2024
As a native New Yorker with a deep appreciation for pizza, I recently had the opportunity to try Andy's Pizza and wanted to share my feedback. Being someone who enjoys comparing pizza from different regions across the country, I was excited to give Andy's Pizza a try, especially on a rainy day when pizza cravings are at their peak.Service, the guys behind the counter were pretty friendly and the ambiance was chill, this location is inside of Western Market. One of the first things I noticed about Andy's Pizza is their thin crust. While thin crust pizzas can be a delightful change of pace, it's important to note that this style may not be for everyone. Personally, I enjoy a good thin crust pizza, and it certainly added a unique touch to the overall experience.Given my hunger, I decided to order a full pie instead of several slices. The pizza looked incredibly appetizing in the window, and I couldn't resist the temptation of trying a whole pie. Typically, I opt for the classic pepperoni topping, but on this occasion, I decided to be adventurous and try something new - the Buffalo Crispy Chicken pizza. This particular pizza featured a combination of mozzarella, provolone, ricotta, crispy white meat chicken, and buffalo sauce.Overall, I found the pizza to be good, but there were a couple of areas that could have been improved. Firstly, I felt that the pizza could have benefitted from a bit more cheese, chicken, and sauce. While the flavors were enjoyable, a little extra cheese, more chicken, and sauce would have enhanced the overall taste and texture. Aside from the pizza, Andy's Pizza also offers containers with freshly squeezed lemons for making shaken drinks. I decided to try their fresh lemonade, and while the concept was refreshing, there were a few aspects that could have been better. The container provided ample lemonade for several glasses, but I found that it needed to be sweeter. Additionally, an excess amount of ice was used, which ended up diluting the flavor of the lemonade to some extent.
Read More
Eid F.
Mar 28, 2024
I'd come back for a slice. Located inside the Western Market on/near GW University. A little hard to find, yelp map doesn't match actual location (used google maps instead). Ordered a half margarita half pepperoni pie. Was hungry so ordered a slice of margarita pizza while we waited. The slice was awesome!!! The crust was crispy airy and delicious. Disappointed a little with the crust on the whole pie... it wasn't crispy at all... a little chewy. Tasted like two completely different pizza spots. Service was friendly. There was room for small or medium sized groups with seating in the back or out in the market place walk way. They had a large selection of drinks including beer/wine/etc.
Read More
Adriane L.
Feb 9, 2024
Very nice place! I arrived at western market too late for the place I wanted so a friend recommended Andy's pizza, and I had a blast. John was my bar tender and kept the harvest margaritas flowing! He is also hilarious and super kind. All vibe checks passed. They have a pretty decent playlist of music going (it's my first night and it's Friday so idk if this is an every day thing or if I'm just lucky).The pizza is also very delicious. I will absolutely return!
Read More
Bo K.
Jan 10, 2024
Delicious NY-style slice. Thin and crispy crust with a great amount of cheese to sauce ratio. Fairly priced. We tried 5 different types and loved all of them. The crowd favorite was burrata margherita. The drizzle of hot honey and the generous portion of basil was fantastic. You can't go wrong. Not pictured is the carnivore which is sausage and pepperoni.
Read More
Ryan B.
Dec 14, 2023
This place is elite. Finding good slice of pizza in DC is so hard but luckily Andys is always consistent and delicious. The people are extremely nice and helpful and the restaurant is very clean. Go to Andys if you want good pizza.
Read More
Daniel C.
Jan 27, 2024
Andy's Pizza is a beloved DC gem, and for good reason. Priced at under $5 a slice, their large, hot, and crispy slices are DELICIOUS. There are a variety of toppings to choose from here.Alcohol is also available. Mondays are a win with a free slice when you buy any drink. There are other specials available throughout the week. This pizza shop is clean and casual. The staff members are quick and friendly, making the experience even better.
Read More