Tony & Milena's Pizzeria
Tony & Milena's Pizzeria
Prosciutto artichoke and eggplant SALTY PIZZA
Freebie bread knots with sauce flavors that didn't merry yet.
Menu
Menu
crepes, food
Menu
Menu
Menu
Pepperoni with garlic and olives SALTY PIZZA
Both sides of the Stromboli were 1/2 bread. First side shocked me enough to take a picture of the second side. Not worth it!
Fried zucchini
Mushroom ravioli
The food was excellent . These are garlic knots
Calamari
Special: Stuffed tortellini
Margherita Pizza
Capriciosa Pizza
Menu
Menu
Margarita pizza.
Menu
Gnocchi
Garlic knots
Italian Sub
Sari S.
Dec 12, 2024
First time coming here but the food is not as satisfying as I hope. Started with a calamari, pretty decent considering its hard to mess this up. But the portion? Speechless. Either add more calamari or downgrade to smaller plate. My hubby wanted pizza so we ordered 2 pizza: pepperoni with garlic and olives, and prosciutto artichoke and eggplants. BOTH ARE SALTY! I love salty food, hence, have hypertension issue. But these are far saltier I could handle. Disappointing to say the least. We prob return one more time to try non pizza dishes.
Read More
John B.
Sep 28, 2024
This seemed like a nice place, but it was a troubling experience. Ordering a house salad initially got me a salad with meat in it. The menu didn't go into detail on this so I was genuinely surprised; this does not happen to me often. They said they could fix it, but even the second salad I was sent still had a tiny piece of meat in it. Not wanting to create any more hassle, I had already eaten the actual lettuce and such before I got to it, so I just let it go at that point. For a place that has a vegetarian pasta section on the menu, apparently they need a vegetarian salad section. Clearer labeling and less sloppy execution.Otherwise, my stromboli looked better, but was a bit too heavy on cheese and light on sauce for me. It certainly was a massive portion size and I was not the only one with leftovers. Getting some free garlic knots (not special for me; everyone got some) also helps smooth things over. They had an extensive and impressive dessert spread, but I could not have gotten one down.I always find it tough in these sorts of cases, because I think their actual level of quality is good (better than three stars) but my actual experience was upsettingly bad (worse than three stars), so I split the difference. Maybe I'll find my way back.
Read More
Brianna M.
Aug 19, 2024
The food here is fabulous and authentic Italian! I had the spaghetti and meatballs with fresh bread dipped in olive oil and it was amazing! Our server was a very nice lady with an Italian accent. The decor is really cool with photos of Sophia Loren and The GodFather movies hanging on the walls. It is a hidden gem in Gloucester Point. If you're in the area definitely check this restaurant out! It looks like a pizza shop on the outside, but there's definitely so much more of a food experience on the inside.
Read More
Chris R.
Feb 16, 2024
My favorite favorite favorite Italian place near Yorktown/Gloucester area. All their food is spectacular from the salads with house (Italian dressing) to the garlic knots, to ALL the food. I have not had a dish I did not enjoy!They just expanded their dining area, so no fear in waiting forever to get a table. I usually never include service in my reviews, because service is so subjective. But....their service is awesome. All the servers monitor each others tables and quickly offer refills or whatever else you need. Definitely try this place, you will not regret it.
Read More
Mike V.
Dec 11, 2024
Excellent food,service and ambience. Some of the best Italian I've tasted outside of New England.
Read More
Audrey D.
Jun 18, 2024
The service is great! I LOVE the food too! My daughter is the reason we went here. It's her birthday and she chose this restaurant we live in heathsville so it was quite the drive! But worth it for sure! My daughter had the kids Alfredo, my husband had spaghetti along with me. My son had ravioli, my stepdaughter had the chicken Alfredo with mushroom and artichoke, etc. they were delicious! I would add photos but we immediately digged in when we got it I forgot! But they looked great! The area is fancy but casual. Perfect for date nights, I have a family of five and we immediately got seated without a reservation! Totally recommend and we had to drive 1 hour to get there, but after all of it, it was worth it! They have beautiful Italian accents too!
Read More
Weston H.
Jan 24, 2025
Food has gone up in price, but the quality has definitely gone down. Ordered a philly cheese steak and a Stromboli to go. Got home and found they are basically half filling both.$17 for a Stromboli called the works and $15 for the Philly. Sad that half of both were basically just bread or dough. Used to be able to count on a great meal from Tony and Milena's, but those days are obviously gone.
Read More
Steve D.
Dec 23, 2024
Reminds me of frienze the food is as close to Real itialian as i have found here in the states
Read More
Michele M.
Dec 26, 2024
We do take out. Always great food, but this time they failed to add the sausage for the sausage marinara. Didn't find out until I returned home. Marinara is the best I've had, and I've eaten it in Italy! Garlic knots are excellent and decadent.
Read More
Nathaniel P.
Sep 30, 2024
The service was great; the gentlemen serving us always checked in, asking if we were enjoying our meal and drinks, which we were! The food and especially the pizza was TOP notch. The ambiance/atmosphere was so calming and quiet with great music playing and quiet respectful conversation all around. This is the Italian place to go to in the area.
Read More
