a view of the water
a pier with a boat dock in the background
people ordering
a view of the water from a dock
Menu board at Sunset Ice Cream
a woman in a striped dress
Exterior of Sunset
hand holding ice cream cone
Sunset cross from the ice cream place makes for a great end to the day
Pretzel cone with (caramel ribboned) cookie dough ice cream is one of the best combinations I've ever put my mouth!
outside
Birthday Cake ice cream.
Enjoy outdoor seating on the boardwalk!
Although the ice cream was great, the service could improve.
outside
Parker V.
May 21, 2023
The ice cream is good, however the new ownership has torn the soul out of this little shop. Before, there were games and toys stacked anywhere they could fit, and now it looks like a bland little shop with no atmosphere or sense of identity.Also, it still takes forever to get your ice cream.
Read More
Lora S.
Jun 21, 2023
Absolutely great ice cream!!!! Got the chocolate peanut butter cup and it was fabulous!!!! So much peanut butter!!!!
Read More
Sarah G.
Nov 13, 2021
We went here twice while on vacation - tasty ice cream and fun location! You can sit in the benches by the pier to enjoy your ice cream.
Read More
Paul S.
Sep 8, 2020
Their smoothies are really good! Great flavor and lots of fruit that you can taste.
Read More
Troy S.
Jun 16, 2021
Espresso Shake with some chocolate ice cream. Delicious as was some of their other drinks. This is a perfect afternoon ice cream spot.
Read More
Eden R.
Sep 25, 2021
Been a few times. Slow service and not particularly happy to serve their customers. Ice cream is decent but nothing special. Not worth the trip.
Read More
Katrina L.
May 25, 2019
I got a double scoop birthday cake ice cream. It was delicious! Order it in a cup so you can enjoy the waterside view without worrying about your hands getting dirty. They also accept credit cards now.
Read More
Donnie W.
Aug 2, 2018
They seemed nice but they are cash only. I had 8 people there for ice cream and shakes but they lost about $40.00 in sales and I am assuming because of a $2.00 credit card service charge. They also didn't know where the closest ATM was??? But wait, if you do want great ice cream and they do accept credit cards go across the street behind the Duck Deli and there is a place called the Ice Cream Shack with cozy seating outdoors. Go there, it was awesome!
Read More
Heather F.
Jun 18, 2022
We went here Friday and I ordered a hot fudge sundae and a banana split for my husband. There was a new girl and a girl training her. My first recommendation would be that the owners require staff to wear hair nets. After my husband worked his way through all the whipped cream and got to the ice cream, he took a scoop and there was a nice, long hair in it. He's bald so definitely not his. Ten dollars for a banana split that went into the garbage can once said hair was discovered. Additionally, there was a sharp spot on his spoon and he cut the inside of his lip on it. My hot fudge sundae was fine except they were out of hot fudge. Sigh.
Read More
Matt F.
Jul 29, 2020
The ice cream is delicious and you are paying tourist prices. Would I come back? Likely.And they are super safe. You MUST wear a mask just to stand in line, outside.
Read More
Rated: 4.1 (13 reviews) · $$
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Juice Bars & Smoothies