Beef Wellington
Seared Salmon
Chambord Truffle Lava Cake
Rack of Lamb
Inside
7/27/23 - Warm Caesar salad good flavor just warm.
Whole Fish Red Snapper with broccolini and roasted potatoes
interior
Delicious appetizer
interior
Inside
Lemon drop
two people sitting at a table
interior
Dining Area
Oysters on the half shell
a patio with a fire pit
Inside
interior
the dining room
the front of the restaurant
Leah J.
Feb 8, 2025
I've heard nothing but great things about Steinhilber's so I couldn't wait to try them out for a friend's birthday dinner. Steinhilber's is a beautifully quaint restaurant hidden in a neighborhood near Town Center. The exterior landscape of the restaurant was absolutely stunning at night and the outdoor seating included fire pits to keep you warm.We made reservations for 5:45pm on a Sunday and the table was ready upon arrival. The servers were very informative of the menu and provided the specials for the evening which all sounded great. We were also served complimentary bread which was warm and tasty. Our food was served fairly quickly. I decided on the Crab Cake with Twice-Baked Potato and it was absolutely amazing. The Crab Cake was a great size and full of fresh crab meat. The Twice-Baked Potato was also very good but I did have to add some salt. I tasted my friend's Filet Mignon and it was divine, especially with their homemade sauce. The restaurant manager, Kelly, came by to check on us, which I really admired. She was awesome and welcomed me to the restaurant. I wish I could give 10 stars for my experience! Everything about this restaurant was amazing and I can't wait to return.
Read More
JayR T.
Dec 7, 2024
I had set a reservation at 8 pm. We arrived 10 minutes early. I observed only 1 dining room was being utilized and the other across the hall was empty.For a reservation that was made and receiving a confirmation via text, I expected the table already available waiting for us and not the opposite of where we are waiting for the table. Given the restaurant seems to be at full capacity, at least the one dining room at the entrance, expectation of a reservation should still be available.While waiting as the time for the reservation of 8 pm approaching, we were not checked on. This gives me a sense that our reservation at 8 pm would not happen promptly. Therefore, we just left.This was a very bad first impression.
Read More
Dena W.
Nov 24, 2024
I think this is gonna be my new favorite spot! It was a Friday night and boy was it busy apparently, it's everybody's favorite spot. They had a party booked the dining room was full, but as always, the service was great. I had to come back the pumpkin martini was calling my name so of course I stopped to get a pumpkin martini and I had to get a dessert. Because as we know, dessert pairs well with a cocktail. Pumpkin martini is made to perfection so good I had two with a piece of their chocolate cake.Oh yes, I will be coming back. They're still things on the menu that I need to tackle.
Read More
Xavier W.
Feb 25, 2025
The food was was really amazing and the whole place was super nice even for it being cold and windy. The only thing I would say is it seemed like the other waiter knew more about what was going on than ours did like the sides and specials for the day but other than that it was great.
Read More
Olga B.
Jan 11, 2025
Came here for a birthday dinner - a very nice cozy place. Staff were extremely professional and helpful. The pear martini was delicious, but tad too tart, and the maple old fashioned- a bit too sweet. We had their famous fried shrimp - very juicy and perfectly cooked. My lobster ravioli was good, but over salted, and my husband's Wellington could've used another minute or so in the oven. The lava cake was amazing though. Overall - a nice experience and will recommend to maybe go in spring/summer to enjoying the outdoor seating with a river view.
Read More
Steve D.
Mar 3, 2025
Excellent food, service, and atmosphere. I eat there every opportunity! Special Steinie's shrimp required.
Read More
Ian M.
Dec 24, 2024
We have come here several times for a team dinner. Excellent service every time! We end up having our event downstairs, which is nice and keeps it private with our own set of servers and bartenders. The food is really good and we typically have just about every appetizer available on tables pre-dinner while we enjoy cocktails, wine and beer and then choose entrees from the menu. I have always had an amazing meal here! We come here a lot because our team is over 30 people and there's only so many restaurants that can accommodate such a large party...! Luckily this place can not only accommodate, but do an amazing job with amazing service and culinary acumen as well!
Read More
Ara A.
Dec 2, 2024
It's been well over 2years since my last visit. Started with the she crab soup and it was on the yellow side but tasted fine. For dinner I had the NY strip and hubby had the filet. The steaks were made well.
Read More
Gary G.
Sep 6, 2024
Steinhilber's is located in a beautiful, peaceful setting. We sat by the window, gazing at a beautiful garden and stretch of lawn all the way to a waterway with boats sparsely docked. It's really a perfect setting for any kind of celebration or an intimate dinner. Ours was a tale of two meals: one spectacular the other disappointing. I had the whole fish of red snapper, which was spectacularly presented. The large portion of fish was fresh, tender, and wonderfully flavored. The flavors did not overwhelm the seafood. The sides of broccolini and roasted potatoes were perfect. Also, the portions were surprisingly generous.On the other hand, let's talk about the filet mignon. We had come to expect a high-level of quality and expertise at Steinhilber's based on many reviews. But this piece of filet mignon did not live up to that expectation. A great filet mignon should be slightly charred on the outside and tender and juicy on the inside. This medium rare steak was grey on on the inside and lacked any juiciness and flavor , and the outside was undistinguished. It definitely was not a great quality of steak. We've had much better filet mignon at "lesser"restaurants. The dipping sauce for the steak was really too bitter to be of any use: it didn't add anything and overwhelmed the steak. We would've returned it, but it was awkward during a celebration. We won't make that mistake again.The twice baked potatoes were very dry and the seasoning was weak. The brussels sprouts looked beautiful on the plate, but they weren't crispy - in fact, they were a bit rubbery. And again, the seasoning was disappointing.The service was always professional if a bit remote.Again, with the beautiful setting and the great reputation we may come back at some point in the future and give it another chance. Since one of our meals was excellent I have some hope that our next visit will be better.
Read More
Sarah M.
Aug 25, 2024
We came back with family due to their amazing patio seating. I love eating outside here. You feel like you're in a little garden oasis. We had a yummy dinner this time. We got seafood which was delicious and cooked to perfection! I tried the daily catch which was salmon with a delicious rice base. Their mashed potatoes were also delicious. Service was good!
Read More