Salty Dog Pizzeria

First time customer. I have to keep in mind that 3 restaurants were closed in the court house so they were extremely busy. Ordered two pizzas for pick up, a medium meat lovers and a large mud duck. Said it would be ready in 25 minutes. No issues there. Arrived after 20 minutes, told it would be 6 more minutes and wound up being 20 more minutes. Got pizzas home and they both looked really good. The meat lovers pizza was, to my taste, dam near perfect. The mud duck however was not. Outside crust looked cooked, not as much as I'd like but ok, but the bottom crust was still very damp, soft and doughy on the inside. You could see the discoloration where it had been exposed to a heat source but definitely not "cooked" enough. I know they were busy though but because of the other 3 popular restaurants being closed or because their pizza is normally satisfactory?

Every pizza shop should sell pizza by the slice every day and not limit the time you can buy a slice of pizza. This pizza is just average nothing special.

Stopped in for a quick bite and got a great Greek salad and a slice of pepperoni! Yum yum and very friendly service

We visited while on vacation and popped in for pizza. Friendly staff, spotlessly clean! Wonderful first impression. The puzza is, hands down, one of the BEST pizzas we've enjoyed. We ordered just thin crust pepperoni pizza. Pizza sauce is perfect blend of flavor, bottom was browned, just as it should be!!! Everything is made to order. Can't recommend this pizzeria highly enough!!

The pizza is good - all of my family likes it, but quite often it take a while for the pizza to be ready. I knocked off a star because of the incredibly disappointing salad. wanted a Caesar salad but they were out so got a house salad with Italian dressing. It was the tiniest salad ever. Not worth $4.75 at all. That was a 2 dollar salad at best. Salad was supposed to be most of my meal. At least I know for next time.

Our family of four had a great meal - cheese pizza, meat lovers "the mess" pizza, and the focaccia bread. All high quality ingredients! The dough/crust held up well to the homemade sauce and great cheese combination. Not greasy at all! Wish it was closer to us!

Last night a friend brought us two pizzas from Salty Dog and they were fantastic ... the Pepperoni was classic and the other one we had, The Moon, had pesto, tomatoes and pine nuts and Canadian bacon. They were fantastic!!!!

The pizza was delicious, we had The Mess and it was very tasty! The crust was fresh and well cooked. We also had the focaccia which was basically cheese pizza without the sauce, so not quite what we were expecting but still good. Will definitely will be eating here again!

Wow, what a great surprise! We got an amazing pepperoni pizza (get the garlic sauce!), a fresh and crispy Greek salad with all the necessary toppings (awesome dressing), and some boneless bbq wings that blew our minds. Just what we needed- we'll be back every time we visit Mathews.

We have eaten in and also ordered to go from Salty Dog. If you are a meat eater I highly recommend the Mess pizza. We also enjoyed the focaccia. The dough is soft and light. The cheese is high quality. Toppings are plentiful and fresh. Overall we really enjoy the pizza here!Keep up the good work!