Sal's NY Pizza
Sal's NY Pizza
a pepperoni pizza in a box
"Deluxe Calzone" ... with no pepperoni, onions, bell peppers, and only 1 little mushroom. More like a sausage calzone.
Don't waist your time or money
a slice of pizza with cheese and pepperoni
a plate of pasta with shrimp
a close up of a basket of bread rolls
food, pizza
The Stuffed pizza. A layer of salty crap on top a crap pizza.
Extra toppings on my Deluxe!
food
food, pizza
menu
Front entrance
The front counter
Pizza looks great
Menu
Clean and neat place!!
menu
I thought it was over cooked, my kids loved it. Tomato/Tomato. A bit pricey but pretty good service. As long as the kids are happy.
Seating
interior
The menu that literally had a picture of chicken wings that are the same price as what I paid, chicken fingers are totally separate
interior
18inch pepperoni
Lou S.
Apr 12, 2024
Don't waste time or money would have rather had a hot and ready. Went in for a slice didn't
Read More
Amanda K.
Nov 5, 2023
I ordered for delivery and received within the estimated time frame. Quick and easy process, decent price for a big pizza. The pizza itself was pretty good in my opinion! I like the crust and the taste. My issue is we got a meat lovers pizza and they were pretty skimpy with the meat. It felt like there was barely any meat and then on top of it, the sliced meatballs were rotten. They tasted absolutely foul. I don't know how they keep track of the freshness of the meats but this one definitely slipped through the cracks. We removed all the visible pieces of meatball from the pizza but some were still buried beneath the cheese and it really overpowers the entire bite of the pizza. I would still order from here again but would make sure I don't have meatballs on it because I am traumatized now.
Read More
Kaitlin A.
Jan 15, 2024
I give it a 1 because their service over the phone was nice. Their food however, is not good. They have a big pizza if you want, but only for it to be bland and have the taste and texture of old crust. Their jalapeños were thick and spicy, mushrooms cooked nice, but pepperoni very mediocre, hardly salty, just greasy mostly. Their cheese is also not flavorful. Their garlic knots were also super bland, and tasted old. I was very surprised when I took a bite and it was like biting into an old soft pretzel someone left out on a counter for a few hours. Also, because I couldn't taste the garlic whatsoever. I couldn't tell they even put any on, it just looked like they brushed it with butter and doused it in parmesan. The sauce on the side was the thing that had the most flavor. But, what's the point of that whenever the main thing I wanted was garlic knots? Very disappointing, almost inedible really, but I hadn't eaten anything all day, and felt bad for my friend who paid. I almost feel bad typing this review, but I also feel the need to let people know. Don't waste your money, trust the reviews and try someplace else people!
Read More
Ashley Nicole N.
May 4, 2022
Okay so it's like this....We ordered pick up for a pepperoni calzone and deluxe stromboli. The food took maybe 20 minutes before it was ready so not bad at all. When i went to pick up the food there was a lady at the counter who was very friendly! I saw 2 guys at in the back cooking as well. I was in and out in less than 5 minutes. The food smelled sooooo good! I get home and open the box to notice that the pepperoni calzone is actually a pepperoni stromboli and the deluxe stromboli is actually a calzone. Well, hey everyone makes mistakes and the person i ordered for decided they were okay with having ricotta in theirs so no big issue right? Moving on, the crust was cooked to a golden brown and had a garlic butter on top with parmesan sprinkled on. Digging into the food... my now pepperoni stromboli is tasty. Lots of cheese and a decent amount of pepperoni - no complaints here other than wishing it had the ricotta. Once my partner decided he was ready to dig into his calzone is where it really went downhill. As you can see from the picture there's lots of sausage! Well, that was about it. We dug through the calzone and there was NOTHING else in there except we did find one little mushroom. What happened to the pepperoni, onions, and bell peppers??? There was also still no ricotta! Is this what is supposed to be deluxe? Anyways, the food was good, service was good, but it was completely not what we ordered. I would've put two stars but they did honor our request for extra marinara with no extra charge so we were thankful for that. Will i come here again? Probably not this location, but i know a few other Sal's locations that don't disappoint!
Read More
Renee D.
Jul 2, 2024
Food was supposed to be delivered at 8:43pm. By 9:15 p.m., it still wasn't here. My husband called and was told it would be just a few more minutes. When it finally arrived, it was cold, rubbery, and dried out (XL pizza, deluxe cheesesteak, and chicken parm sub). So this time, i called. I asked to speak with a manager. Instead, they put me on the phone with one of the cooks, who told me how they're shortstaffed. I can understand that, but that doesn't mean we should be stuck with old, cold food - which is why i asked them to remake it. The kitchen guy said he can't cause everything is closed down now (which isn't true. They're still open as I write this. At that point, I said forget it and asked for a refund. I was then told he can't do that cause he's a cook. Again, I asked for a manager but he said "he's overseas". He can call him tomorrow. So here I am, stuck with nothing to feed my family on the one night we didn't cook this week, because im getting over being sick. I will be escalating this with Slice (the app they use to process delivery orders) in order to get a refund. Never again will I order from Sal's.
Read More
Cortney J.
Oct 14, 2023
Frustrating to put in an order for delivery for it to be canceled 30 min later and no good reason either..
Read More
Miranda H.
May 21, 2022
Waited an hour for a medium pizza and 4 cheese ravioli. Pizza- the cheese wasn't even cooked and the dough wasn't even done I HAD TO PUT IT IN THE OVEN MYSELF raviolis- OVERCOOKED. My fork wouldn't even go through them. Literally don't go here. Go to the Airline Blvd one. ten times better.
Read More
Carol Ann B.
Oct 11, 2024
I ordered Sal'S Ziti from Uber when I got my order I got Spaghetti with meatballs and sausage NOT what I ordered since I have a copy of the receipt and a picture of the spaghetti and meatball with sausage it was written as I ordered it. I feel since the cook messed up the order Sal's should fix it NOT Uber eats.
Read More
Luke E.
Sep 21, 2024
Was looking forward to having a pizza and movie night.. $60 later it was the worst pizza I've had. An insurmountable amount of cheese and way undercooked. The service was decent, got here at a reasonable time but absolutely would not order again. Pizza, mozzarella sticks, and tiramisu all horrible. Would not recommend.
Read More
Jay R.
Feb 9, 2024
I was given old pizza with new cheese added when i ordered and only got one of the 2 toppings i paid for
Read More
