Milton’s Bay Cafe

We have been weekly breakfast patrons of this establishment for over two+ years. Both the cuisine and service are first class! The place is usually busy; however, they turn tables fairly quickly and the wait is minimal (if ever).Milton and his staff are quite visible, super friendly, and go out of their way to provide a super experience.

Decided to check out this gem this past Sunday and it's good food that not many know about which was a plus for us because we did not feel like waiting the normal hour plus line. I should really keep these to myself but what fun would that be. We sat ourselves and were greeted immediately and service was excellent and food was great as well. Will most definitely come back again soon.

Umm.. just a big WOW! This place is a treasure! I truly mean that! Set back from the street you easily pass it and takes a little effort to find parking, But folks it's all worth it! The decore is simple when you walk in, but soon as the waitress brings out the food plates my eyes and smile was ear to ear! The Lobster Beni was made perfect and very generous along with the home fries. The Cornbeef Hash was awesome added grilled onions on top. And it's so nice they can make it to order The Stuffed Berry French Toast was so stuffed with FRESH berries and they put even more on the side witj whip cream! I was so glad the owner "Milton" came by to see if everything was good! Cause I just wanted to tell him how fabulous my experience was! So for you foodies find this treasure and give it a try! Definitely will be back plenty of times!

The ambiance is downright homey, cozy, like what a neighborhood cafe should be - the owner sitting at the bar sharing pleasantries with customers. Service was quick and friendly. It wasn't on the menu but my friend got creative and asked if we can get lobster omelette. The waitress even said they can add avocado slices as well! The lobster omelette was delicious, generous chunks of lobster meat, very fresh avocados in the omelette.

To me this is a locals spot. It is an ok size inside. Not a super big place but roomy enough that your not sitting right on top of another group. The wait staff are good. Not overly friendly but like I said a lot of locals go here so if you know them they talk to you more. They are good at taking your order and they get it right every time. Even when you put in special request. We have been a few times now. My bestie loves this place. This is her favorite place to go. I personally think the food is fine. The Classic eggs benedict is ok. Their sauce is not my favorite. I have a couple other places I like better. The omlette is good. House hashbrowns are ok. Bacon could be a little more crisp for my taste. But that is my preference. I do ask for extra crispy and they have done that but the first time I had it was wimpy. So you have to know to ask to make things crispy. I am not use to telling the chef how to cook everything I order. For me this is a solid 3 1/2. Food is a 4 or 4 1/2. Staff are a 3. Parking lot is small but we have not been when it is busy. I would NEVER go on a busy time. Ya know there is always room for improvement . So for now I I will stick with the 3 1/2 With room for improvement

This is a local gem. I had the eggs beni Florentine. It was delicious. Eggs Beni is hard to do well because of all the moving parts but it was very good. If you're on Shore Drive you need to check this place out.

My husband and I thoroughly enjoyed our meals. Great servings, made well, and our waitress was amazing! This is going to be a new regular for the two of us!

I almost don't want to leave a review because I like that this is a hidden gem! Right next door to the always-too-busy Citrus, Milton's is cozy and comfortable and delivers awesome, traditional, tasty breakfast and lunch. Service is local and friendly and quick. Mimosas and bloody Mary's are generous! I think these are the best pancakes I've ever had and everything else is just as yummy. Get your English Muffin grilled on the flat top. You're welcome!

I loved the service ! The food was amazing ! And the mimosas were amazing as well definitely coming back !

Waitress staff DO NOT KNOW HOW TO SMILE , and be somewhat friendly at least just a little they will never see another dime for me again