Mama Mia's Italian Family Restaurant

Literally the worst pizza I have ever had. Ever. If you watched The Office (US) and remember Kevin Malone saying "It's like a hot circle of garbage," he was almost definitely talking about this pizza.I ordered through Eat24, and I hoped the order would be better than the other two reviews that are existing on the Yelp website said. I really wanted delivery, and I really wanted something halfway decent, at least Chanello's quality. This wasn't it. I am pretty sure im going to get food poisoning.My order came less than 5 minutes ago, but the woman delivering called twice through the app and both times it started off with something about not giving anyone my credit card number through the Yelp Eat24 app - when I finally got through to an actual person after the automated system called me, she couldn't figure out where my house was, and I had to go stand outside to meet her. She was older and friendly enough but kept assuring me that she did not call me through any app and had no idea what I was talking about even though the app direct dial phone call from her twice came straight to me with both the app talking to me and then her voice. I recognize that older people frequently don't understand how technology works, so that part was fine... But I paid $20 for a pizza, and it is supposed to be a large, and it is Tiny and kind of terrible.The chicken tastes rotten. Like... I would feed this to homeless people, maybe, if they were desperate, but next time I will absolutely order Chanello's or Domino's or Pizza Hut and that's saying something.And... after the tip it was about 23 bucks, and she wasn't even troubled to thank me for the tip even though I had to go find her on my street after she called me twice. Downtown delivery that is ALWAYS quality: Gyro Palace. And they can find you AND thank you for the tip.EDIT: I called back and asked to return the pizza, and they agreed, WITHOUT APOLOGY and WITHOUT ANY SURPRISE. The phone number on the Yelp app is inaccurate, the correct phone number that you need to call to get any sort of service or return on your investment in their food is 757-229-1388. They didn't apologize, and they didn't sound surprised.

Whenever I call to make an order the guy on the phone sounds unbelievably tired and annoyed. One time I called and he told me to call back after 15 minutes. The food is delicious though. The fries I get are consistently horrible but the gyro and spanakopita are great.

Arrived in Williamsburg last night and ordered delivery from Mama Mia's. Not long after my daughter and I ate, we didn't feel well. Daughter's food was so contaminated that when she threw up, her nose was bleeding at the same time. We are here on vacation and Mama Mia has totally ruined it by cooking and selling spoiled/contaminated food. I do not recommend this establishment.

I ordered a steak and cheese and gyro. It was a delivery. The food arrived 15 earlier than posted and it was still steaming hot. And the food was really good. And price was on point as well. NICE JOB.! I will order again