Mammoth Brisket
Halliford Beef and Cheddar
Variety of beers
Newly renovated!
Custom cut meats!
The daily special Scallop Po' Boy with fries.
Cuban sandwich
Supreme (1/2 w/o mushrooms; which we had requested; not a mistake!)
1/2 pepperoni 1/2 ham, pineapple, & bacon
Bbq with Carolina sauce
Cheeseburger with the BEST shoestring fries!
Outside Eating
Sandra W.
Apr 16, 2022
Good Italian sub! Not had anything else. Hit and miss on inventory. Glad to have it available for the limited choice in Mathews.
Read MoreElizabeth F.
Apr 30, 2017
Cute little convenience store on the way to Old Point Comfort Lighthouse. Has gas and a deli counter, bait and tackle. You can also pick up some fresh seafood to take home too.Be sure to order a crab muffin (Chesapeake Deviled Crab on a crispy English muffin). Other treats in the deli case too.
Read MoreDavid V.
Jul 23, 2018
A great place to pick up supplies without having to head into Mathews. Deviled crab. Great shrimp. Virginia peanuts. A wide array of motor oil. Local eggs. Bunkers. Pirate gear. And remarkably good bacon.
Read MoreElizabeth H.
Jun 1, 2024
This our fourth time to the market and I finally remembered to take pictures before we ate. Island Stop is both a restaurant (carry out) and market. The food has been top quality. The scalloped s in the Po' Boy were tender and cooked to perfection. They add seasoning (tastes like Old Bay) to the shoe string fries. The market has a bit of everything, but the vintage candy is fun to come across. The owners and staff are all welcoming and cheerful. If you are in Mathews you should stop by.
Read MoreJack P.
Jul 23, 2024
We were very pleased with our pizza from Island Stop! The toppings were more than generous, sauce delicious, and crust was actually lightly seasoned with herbs/oil (a pleasant surprise which most places don't do). Island Stop will be a part of our regular pizza nights for sure! P.S., the staff here are always helpful, patient, and friendly.
Read MoreJessica K.
May 18, 2024
Brand New owners and they are killing it! We bought a cheeseburger, bbq, fries and pasta salad everything was better than we could have imagined! We'll be back for pizza soon!!!
Read MoreRichard H.
May 18, 2024
The island stop recently reopened after renovation. We called in and ordered pizza, when I arrived to pick it up, they had made a mistake and instead of making excuses, they said "dinner is on your s tonight, sorry for the inconvenience ". The best customer service is how you respond to the customer when you make a mistake!!! And the pizza is amazing too!
Read MoreVirginia F.
Dec 12, 2023
Great place for sandwiches chips and a drink. You can also get bait and fishing gear, gas,etc
Read MoreTom V.
Jul 24, 2018
The place to go for crab dip, deviled crab, and Virginia peanuts! Port Haywood ain't big, but Island Stop is a must stop if you're hungry. Super friendly folks run this authentic local market.
Read MoreRated: 4.4 (28 reviews) · $$
Pizza, Specialty Food, Beer, Wine & Spirits