Island Creamery
Island Creamery
Praline flavored ice cream with pecans, almonds, walnuts, peanuts and a caramel swirl
Cake batter ice cream with buttercream swirl and rainbow sprinkles (gluten)
Homemade fresh black raspberry ice cream
A touch of Virginia Gentlemen Bourbon, Heath Bar pieces, and a caramel swirl
Homemade fresh butter pecan ice cream
Yellow cake batter ice cream (gluten)
Brandy flavored ice cream with brandy soaked cherries
Our homemade vanilla ice cream swirled with black cherries
Homemade fresh chocolate ice cream
Homemade fresh coffee ice cream
Vanilla ice cream loaded with homemade cookie dough pieces (gluten)
America-s favorite cookie made into ice cream (contains gluten)
Homemade fresh cotton candy ice cream
Espresso ice cream with chocolate chunks and fudge swirl
Strong coffee ice cream with homemade brownie chunks and chocolate covered espresso beans (gluten)
Double strength chocolate ice cream
Mint ice cream with chocolate chunks
Peanut butter ice cream with peanut butter cups
Vanilla ice cream with homemade hot fudge, peanut butter cups and peanut butter swirl
Rum flavored ice cream with rum soaked raisins
Cheesecake ice cream with caramel swirl and Snickers pieces
Homemade fresh strawberry ice cream made with local strawberries (in season)
Creamy vanilla ice cream made with Madagascar bourbon pure vanilla extract
Made with Splenda
Made with Splenda
Made with coconut milk
Made with coconut milk
Made with coconut milk
Coconut ice cream with chocolate covered almonds and a fudge swirl
Local apples from M&C Vessey Farm, homemade cobbler pieces (gluten)
Local fresh cider from M&C Vessey Farm, fat and lactose free, vegan
Banana ice cream with a caramel swirl and a hint or rum flavor
Fresh local blueberries
Cheesecake ice cream swirled with graham and strawberry or blueberry (gluten)
Buttery ice cream with butter brittle pieces
Sweet cream ice cream with Cadbury chocolate pieces and creme egg filling swirled in
Local sweet potatoes with cinnamon and brown sugar, praline pecans and caramel swirl
Ricotta ice cream with chocolate covered waffle cone pieces and chocolate chips (gluten)
Made with fresh local cantaloupes
Chocolate ice cream with peanut butter swirl
Cinnamon ice cream with cinnamon bun pieces and icing swirl (gluten)
Homemade fresh coconut ice cream
Egg nog ice cream with rum flavor
Ginger snap ice cream with pieces of homemade ginger snap cookies (gluten)
Lemon juice, zest and a touch of limoncello
Cereal flavored ice cream with Lucky Charms swirled in (gluten)
Fresh mangos, fat and lactose free, vegan
Malt ice cream with Milky Way candy bar pieces swirled in
Marsh mud ice cream with peanut butter swirl and Nutter Butter cookie pieces (gluten)
A minty version of Marsh Mud ice cream
Fresh orange juice, fat and lactose free, vegan
Fresh local peaches
Mint ice cream with crushed peppermint candy
Cake batter ice cream with pineapple, swirled with caramel (gluten)
Imported Sicilian pistachio paste with California pistachios (no almonds here)
Pumpkin ice cream with a graham cracker swirl (gluten)
Fresh raspberries, fat and lactose free, vegan
Cream cheese ice cream with red velvet pieces (gluten)
Fresh grapefruit, fat and lactose free, vegan
Cake batter ice cream with rum flavor, caramel swirl and cake pieces (gluten)
House made caramel with a touch of sea salt
Icing flavored ice cream with homemade sugar cookie pieces (gluten)
Local strawberries, fat and lactose free, vegan
Minty ice cream with pieces of Girl Scout thin mint cookie pieces (gluten)
Homemade fresh vanilla ice cream with a butterscotch swirl
Homemade fresh chocolate ice cream mixed with cinnamon and chili pepper
Chocolate ice cream with toffee pieces and whiskey flavor
Choose from: Our Homemade Waffle Cone, Sugar Cone, Plain Cone or Cup
made with Splenda Choose from: Our Homemade Waffle Cone, Sugar Cone, Plain Cone or Cup
made with coconut milk Choose from: Our Homemade Waffle Cone, Sugar Cone, Plain Cone or Cup
Choose Ice Cream (2 Scoops), Topping, Nuts Toppings: Hot Fudge, Caramel, Butterscotch, Peanut Butter, Marshmallow, Strawberry, Pineapple, Chocolate, Assorted Dry Toppings, Pecans, Peanuts, Almonds
Choose Ice Cream (2 Scoops), Topping, Nuts Toppings: Hot Fudge, Caramel, Butterscotch, Peanut Butter, Marshmallow, Strawberry, Pineapple, Chocolate, Assorted Dry Toppings, Pecans, Peanuts, Almonds
Choose Ice Cream (5 Scoops), 3 Toppings, Nuts, Whipped Cream & a Cherry Toppings: Hot Fudge, Caramel, Butterscotch, Peanut Butter, Marshmallow, Strawberry, Pineapple, Chocolate, Assorted Dry Toppings, Pecans, Peanuts, Almonds
Homemade Brownie, Choice of 2 Scoops, Hot Fudge, Caramel, Pecans, Chocolate Chips & Toffee Pieces
Choose Ice Cream (2 Scoops), Hot Fudge, Caramel, Pecans
Chocolate cake crunch filled with Chocolate and Vanilla ice cream
Crushed Oreo crust filled with Oreo ice cream
Chocolate cake crunch filled with Marsh Mud ice cream and frosted with fudge
The best place on the whole shore for frozen treats
Interior view.
Lucky Charms
Chocolate
two waffle cones with ice cream and caramel sauce
Scrumtiousness
Java Jolt Mint Chip Vanilla Cookie Dough
food
Black cherry shake
Ice Cream Heaven
a view of the lighthouse from the deck
The pickup place
Banana split with our three selected flavors.
Pony tracks and orange sorbet
Outside
food
interior
Dark chocolate with salted caramel
food
March 2021
outside
Chocolate Peanut Butter and Java Jolt in a waffle cone
Mike S.
Aug 25, 2024
The Yelp says open till 10 am...it should say 10 PM.Cute ice cream spot. Nice little day trip from Virginia Beach!
Read More
Eric G.
Feb 19, 2025
While traveling to the area, people as far away as Pocomoke City told us "if you're going to Chincoteague, you have to go to the Island Creamery". It was great advice.A nice shop, decorated with a lighthouse shaped building. Upon entering you are greeted by the aroma of freshly made waffle cones - yum! Shop was spotless, service was fast and friendly. I had the Mud Marsh - probably the best chocolate ice cream I've had - silky, dark chocolate without too much cream, slight hint of bitterness - amazing!
Read More
Phuong O.
Oct 5, 2024
Loved the ice creams that they had. All the flavors looks so awesome and we wish we could have tasted all of them. My only complaint is that while we were there, we felt rushed and the workers had RBF when we asked for samples. It wasn't even busy.I know it gets busy, but to really experience an ice cream shop, u would need to look at the ice cream itself and not just look at a drawing board of the flavors... If we were on the island longer we would have come back for other flavors.
Read More
Linda O.
Oct 5, 2024
The ice cream is not to my liking.I tried plain vanilla, butter pecan, and rum raisin. For these flavors, I had a hard time determining what was what. It was basically vanilla, with some added flavoring. Didn't get many pecans in the butter pecan and the raisins in the rum raisin were chewy.Colorful, large space that's family friendly.Even given that, the main thing--their ice cream--doesn't make the grade for me.
Read More
Ping R.
Sep 23, 2024
The flavors were loaded with toppings! Quality of the ice cream itself was fine as far as your average hard scoop texture. Staff were reasonably friendly and the restaurant was clean. The space is surprisingly larger than you expect of most ice cream shops but it only seems that way during the early hours. In the evenings this place has a line spanning dozens of people and a madhouse of vacationers inside. You can tell lots of families spanning multiple generations are mostly coming here out of tradition.Overall this was a fun touristy to-do if you're in the area.
Read More
Bill G.
Sep 22, 2024
I am usually waiting in line for the best ice cream on the shore, but it is 1:00pm on a Sunday... and got right back in.
Read More
Meghan K.
Apr 12, 2024
I visit island creamery every time I go to Chincoteague island! They were voted the best ice cream shop in America in 2023 and it's well deserved! They have so many flavors to choose from, anyone (even with dietary restrictions) could easily find something to get! My go to is typically the Oreo flavor. All of their ice cream is homemade and it shows. There are always chunks of Oreos and the ice cream is SO creamy, no ice crystals like you get in your ice cream at some places. My last visit I tried the snickers cheesecake flavor. If you like snickers, you'll love this flavor!There's always a line, even during off season occasionally, but they're so efficient you'll never have to wait in line more than a few minutes. There's parking directly out front of the shop, but that gets full pretty quickly. They have a separate parking area directly across the street and more parking behind the shop. This place is a must visit! Definitely worth the stop if you're anywhere close to Chincoteague.
Read More
Ruth C.
Jul 19, 2024
Competitive parking lot situation during post-meal hours. The poor staff probably spend as much time explaining what's in the various flavors to tourists as they do waiting for people to finish sampling. I don't get the hype. The flavors are alright, with coconut being one of the favorites for our group, but the texture across the board is a little gummy, rather than creamy. The last straw was when I found a small hair in my ice cream. I'd originally planned on hitting up another of their locations to try other flavors like Cherries Jubilee / Rum Raisin / Limoncello, but this experience encouraged me to save my calories for other treats.
Read More
Melissa T.
Jul 7, 2024
Best ice cream in Chincoteague! I love to go here with the kids. And the affogato is perfection! The parking lot is small, so we prefer to ride our bikes and avoid the parking lot. The service never disappoints and they have a great system for the busy crowds. I also bought a long sleeve sweater this time!
Read More
Anthony M.
Apr 28, 2024
When I say this was a great detour back to our part of Virginia is was the service from Hailey was great inviting cordial and just plain ole food vibes the whole shop was bustling with ice cream lovers from all over and the lines were moving that you just new this was a well organized cool treat establishment.The ice cream is extraordinary coffee ice cream chocolate syrup hot fudge wet walnuts just plenty of options for your ultimate cool treatThis is a must go and see and a go and eat!
Read More
