il Paesano Pizza & Pasta

Decent pizza joint. Basic pizzas but they can make it big!!! Bang for your buck here. Service a little slow, but the foods come quick. Ambiance is lacking as it looks like an older establishment and does not really have a theme in their arrangement. Come here for good cheap pizzas and cold beer. Coming back for sure.

This pizza joint was delicious!!! Been living in the area for about 3years and decided to try it for the first time. My family and I ordered a Large Pepperoni and a Medium Cheese no complaints. Service was great from the staff!! Recently changed names to IL Paesano Pizza & Pasta

I returned to Sals (now called "il Paesano") a couple years ago to give them another chance after my last [poor] review. They have come a long way since then. Yesterday, I brought my family in for lunch. We've ordered pizza for my grandchildren, ages 2 and 4, many, many times at other pizzerias. They usually eat a slice or two [with the crust cut off, of course] and leave some behind. Yesterday, these two children finished a 12-inch pizza; after revery slice, they asked for more, it was that good. Sure, we cut off the crust for them but they did not go to waste, because the crust was SO good, they made the most delicious breadsticks I've ever had! I ordered a small cheesesteak calzone. It was cheesy and garlicky and amazing! It was a large serving, enough to feed two or three people. My usual go-to is the penne ortolana which is a penne in marinara sauce with eggplant and ricotta. The plate is usually enough to make two or three servings. My wife's favorite is the Godfather sub; an Italian-style sub with a nice assortment of meats. They also have some of the best Buffalo wings in the area! Service is always friendly and attentive.

Amazing pizza. Good service. Just don't go on Thursday nights. They have Karaoke. Old people who think they can sing. I'm old too, but they are awful. And old people hogging tables and not eating. I saw 2 families walk out because there were no empty tables. I guess they like to lose business. Pizza is good though.

"managers" at Sal's need to learn some manners and professionalism- tonight in front of customers- the owner FIRED a driver - very rudely - from this my daughter who has worked there for about 3 months- she's been telling me that she's been getting talked down too, ignored and talked about as she walks away- I allowed her to voice her concern and quit tonight- it wasn't taken well and the "Manager" decided to respond as was expected- DO BETTER SAL's !!!!

Pizza is worth every penny. And the calzones are a freaking steal! Nice, cozy place for a little night out

Save your money and calories and go elsewhere. They changed the name from Sals to il Paesano....emphasis on the il or ewww is more like it. It was mediocre at best when it was Sals and still the same. We thought they might have someone decent making a pizza on a Saturday night. No such luck. Sometimes you might hit the jackpot and get a better one than you would during the week. Nope! Ordered a large cheese and a large White Florentina. Supposed to be garlic on the Florentina. Not a hint of it. Overdone. You always get about 2" at least of crust on all of their pizzas. Bottom crust is always caked with flour. We actually stopped going here for a year or more because it was always disappointing. Sad when frozen pizza is a better option. You do not go here if you want and crave pizza. You go here if you need it immediately and are too lazy to drive to north Suffolk or elsewhere to get it. At least with Papa John's and other similar places you will save yourself some money. You at least know what you are getting there. It would be nice to get your money back ($42 for this and a large cheese) when you are served tasteless junk like this. Heed the warning.

I ordered a pizza from Il Paesano for the third and final time! Even though I can walk there. I ordered a hamburger pizza with extra BBQ sauce and extra meat like I have done for years. The pizza was overcooked and dry. I finally called to complain for the first time and was told to bring it back. It's Friday night I was hungry! I asked the manager if I could get a break on the next pizza next time, he said no! I extremly disgudted that the pizza was awful and more pissed that the manager would not make it right! Beware if you order a pizza for pickup or delivery, you might not get what you paid for! I'll go out of my way to Pizza Hut from now on. You should too!

Sals has never been my first choice in the area, but I will eat it occasionally as I feel like it is significantly overpriced for the value of the food. Today we ordered Sals for my work lunch. I ordered boneless wings and garlic knots. The boneless wings were just frozen nuggets that had lemon pepper on them, and my garlic knots had a 1.5-2" black hair baked into the garlic knot. I immediately threw all the food away and that will be the last time I eat there.

very poor establishmen, customer service is poor and they cater to only one customer base which is pale people