Heritage Bake Shoppe

Thursday 8/15/2024I first visited this spot last year and I already knew that I was going to come back the very next year (which I did). I got the same items I got last year: cinnamon roll $2.95 and carrot cake cupcakes with the 4 for $9.95 deal.The cinnamon roll was fresh, soft, and fluffy. It was a really good cinnamon roll and it was better than the one I had last year. The carrot cake cupcake was pretty good and that cream cheese icing was next level. Overall, I'm still a fan of the heritage bake shoppe and will continue to recommend it and return whenever I'm in the area.

Terrific selection of baked goods, prepared foods, etc. The cinnamon rolls and pies are great!

Truly delicious desserts, friendly people, and a unique shop. Try the butter cheese in the deli.

Crinkle cookies. It's hard to find them when you crave for some. But I tell you, it's great to know that when you search on Yelp, you get results with great photos that Heritage Bake Shoppe does bake them. And customer service was wonderful since they answer the call and tell you they have cinnamon crinkle cookies sold in 6 or a dozen; and chocolate ones that are included in cookie platters. Sure enough, we ended getting the platter. By the way for the holidays, the gingerbread cookie didn't disappoint, they are bits of ginger, what a treat in texture and of course Mr Gingerbread man was cute! All cookies were of good size and they look freshly baked. Always love the ambiance here. You feel the love of baked goodies as soon as you enter, the aroma, the delectable selections ... the whole experience.

You're in for a treat! They have shoofly pie , whoopie pies, cinnamon rolls to die for, coffee cake , soft molasses cookies, oatmeal peanut butter cookies- yes believe it ! It's a real unique cookie flavor, and it's amazingly good! I want to go back to load up on all these delicious baked goods. We also noticed this time that they make Ezekiel bread! How Cool! Staff is efficient, friendly, and helpful. The place is clean and so so beautiful. The bakery is attached to an Amish furniture store, everything is stunning! Parking is plentiful, location is great due to being next to the fun Farmers Market! Go, go, go , you must ! Don't miss out on Heritage Bake shoppe!

This place is absolutely amazing! Their monster cookies are the best I've ever had, bar none. Just before Christmas I got yeast rolls, cinnamon rolls, pecan pie, pumpkin pie, rhubarb pie (had like a crisp topping, and even though it was just rhubarb, not strawberry rhubarb, it was still the perfect amount of sweet) Recently, I brought pumpkin bread, banana bread, coffee cake, caramel popcorn, monster cookies and chocolate chip cookies to work and they were gone within 30 minutes. Plus all the employees are so kind and the place is pretty neat! 10/10 Would recommend!

Fresh Amish bakery, grocery and furniture shop. When you first step in you immediately smell the fresh baked goods on the spot! Plus you can wonder around and shop for jams and other fresh items. The back is the furniture shop. Tried the cinnamon roll. Very tasty, but I prefer Cream Cheese Frosting VS White icing. If you are going to make fresh quality dessert. Go the extra mile and just add one more ingredient.

The oatmeal raisin cookies are delicious! And, decided to try their chocolate covered banana chips which were tasty, as well. The staff, once again, were pleasant and helpful. Love all of their spice selections, too! Did I mention, it always smells delicious in there! Lol

This is such a great store with fresh baked goods as well as snacks and deli items.The staff are friendly,and helpfull.

Amazing - simply amazing. My new second home. Pastries, Pies, Herbs, Butter, EVERYTHING is amazing. Service is unequal anywhereStore / Ambiance is very Amish (outstanding)